Kashish Products Impex Pvt Ltd vs Deputy Commissioner, Goods And Service Tax, Central Taxes

Court
Delhi High Court

$~2
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
st
Date of decision: 01 September, 2026
# CNR No. DLHC010138882025
+ CEAC 4/2025
M/S KASHISH PRODUCTS IMPEX PVT. LTD.
KHASRA NO.915-916,
RITHALA INDUSTRIAL AREA,
DELHI
...APPELLANT
Through: Mr. Rajesh Rawal, Mr. Juvas
Rawal, Advocate.
Versus
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
GOODS & SERVICE TAX, CENTRAL TAXES,
DELHI WEST, DIVISION - ROHINI,
CGO COMPLEX, LODHI ROAD, NEW DELHI
…RESPONDENT
Through: Mr. Aditya Singla, SSC, CBIC
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY DIGPAUL
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE, J.
1. The present appeal is filed under section 35G of the Central
Excise Act, 1944, (hereinafter referred to as the “ Act ”), challenging
nd rd
the impugned orders dated 02 May, 2024 and Misc. order dated 23
September, 2024 passed by the respondent-Central, Excise and
Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as the
“ CESTAT ”).
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
Signing Date:16.09.2026
16:24:02
CEAC 4/2025 Page 1 of 10

2. The Appellant, engaged in the manufacturing of PVC
compounds and PVC masterbatches, among other products, had
allegedly issued invoices without actually supplying the said goods,
to its buyers. It is further alleged that the Appellant had received only
invoices from its suppliers without the actual receipts of inputs.
According to the respondent-Revenue, the entire transaction is a
transaction without there being any transaction in reality. Same has
resulted in the wrongful availment of CENVAT credit by the
Appellant. Based on these allegations, the respondent-Department
initiated an investigation which has culminated in issuance of a Show
th
Cause Notice dated 12 February, 2007, based on which the
nd
Adjudicating Authority, vide Order-in-Original dated 2 December,
2010, confirmed a demand of Rs. 9.73 crores against the Appellant,
along with interest thereon, and further imposed a penalty.
nd
3. Being aggrieved by the Order-in-Original dated 2 December,
2010, the Appellant filed an appeal (Appeal No. E/577/2011) along
with a stay application before the CESTAT .
4. The stay application was disposed of with a direction to the
Appellant to deposit a sum of Rs. 1.5 crores as pre-deposit. Besides,
during the course of the investigation, the Appellant claims to have
deposited a sum of Rs. 15,00,000/- in addition to Rs. 1.5 crores as
stated above. As per the Appellant, the total amount deposited came
to Rs. 1.65 crores.
nd
5. Vide order dated 2 February, 2018, the Learned Tribunal
allowed the appeal preferred by the Appellant.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
Signing Date:16.09.2026
16:24:02
CEAC 4/2025 Page 2 of 10

6. Pursuant to the above, the Appellant submitted an application
th
dated 09 April, 2018 seeking refund of the pre-deposit amount of
Rs.1.65 crores along with interest payable thereon.
th
7. The Revenue Department, vide order dated 10 May, 2018,
decided the Appellant's refund application holding as under:-
“The party has submitted Copies of the Challan Nos. 00064
dated 17.05.2013, 00062 dated 17.05.2013 for Rs. 1.0 Crore
and Rs. 50 lakhs respectively. Also, party submitted copies of
Demand Draft and Cheque in support of Rs. 15 Lakhs
deposited during the investigation evidencing payment of the
total amount claimed by them to the tune of Rs. 1.65 Crores.
The interest at this amount calculated @ 6% p.a. comes out
to be Rs 55,80,263/- effective from the date of deposit of pre
deposit amount and date of deposit of amount during the
period of investigation till the date of its payment. Hence, the
total refundable amount comes to Rs 2,20,80,263/-, as per the
calculation below.
xxxxxx
“I hereby sanction the refund claim of Rs. 1 ,65,00,000/~
(Rupees One crore and Sixty Five lakhs only) alongwith a
total interest of Rs. 55,80,263/- (Rupees Fifty Five lakhs
Eighty thousands Two hundred and Sixty Three only) to" M/s
Kashish Products Impex Pvt. Ltd., Khasra No. 915-916,
Rithala, Delhi-110085 in accordance with the Hon'ble
CESTAT's Final Order No. A/50465-50481/2018-EX (DB)
dated 02.02.2018. The sanctioned amount of Rs.
1,65,00,000/- along with an interest of Rs. 55,80,263/- comes
to a total of Rs. 2,20,80,263/- (Rupees Two crores Twenty
lakhs Eighty thousands Two hundred and Sixty Three only),
which is to be paid through cheque #563224 dated
10.05.2018.”
th
8. Subsequently, vide Corrigendum dated 14 May, 2018, the
interest amount was reduced to Rs. 51,30,986/- while the refund of
the principal amount of Rs. 1.65 crores remained unchanged. The
reason assigned in the said Corrigendum for reducing the interest
amount was in respect of the sum of Rs. 15,00,000/- deposited during
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
Signing Date:16.09.2026
16:24:02
CEAC 4/2025 Page 3 of 10

the course of the investigation, the interest would be calculated from
the date of filing of the appeal and not from the date of deposit of the
said amount.
th th
9. Against the said orders dated 10 May, 2018 and 14 May,
2018, the Revenue preferred an appeal before the Commissioner of
Central Tax (Appeals-II), Delhi.
th
10. The appellate authority passed an ex-parte order dated 7
January, 2019, on the basis of the material available on record, and
remanded the matter back to the Original Authority for the re-
consideration of interest payable to the Appellant. The relevant
th
portion of order dated 07 January, 2019 reads as under:-
“Personal Hearing has been granted to the appellant (Revenue) and the
&
respondent on 06.12.2018, 11.12.2018 13.12.2018. No one appeared
for the same. Since none of the parties involved has appeared for
Personal Hearing despite providing sufficient opportunity for the same, I
proceed to decide the matter ex-parte on the basis of facts on
record.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
4(ii) From the perusal of impugned order, I find that the pre-
deposit has been made by the respondent during February/March
2006 and May 2013. During that time, Section 35(FF) of CEA,
1944 provides payment of interest on delayed refund of pre-deposit
"after the expiry of three months from the date of communication
of the order of the appellate authority, till the date of refund of such
amount." Undisputedly the impugned order has been passed after
the amendment in Section 35FF ibid, but at the same time, it is to
be borne in mind that in terms of proviso below amended Section
35(FF) of CEA, 1944, the payability of interest on pre-deposit
made prior to 06.08.2014 shall be governed by pre-amended
Section 35(FF) of CEA, 1944. Neither amended Section 35 (FF) of
CEA, 1944 nor any of the circulars relied upon by the Adjudicating
Authority to decide the admissibility /quantum of interest is
applicable on the issue in hand. In view of clear-cut statutory
provisions cited above, I hold that the appeal is allowable. For
such conclusion, I place reliance on CCE Vs ITC Ltd. [2005 (179)
ELT 15 (SC)] wherein the Supreme Court has ordered payment of
interest on pre-deposit upon expiry of 3 months from the date of
final disposal. This judgment has also been relied upon by the
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
Signing Date:16.09.2026
16:24:02
CEAC 4/2025 Page 4 of 10

Hon'ble Supreme Court in UOI Vs Tata SSL Ltd. [2007 (218) ELT
493 (SC)]. Circular No. 802/35/2004-CX dated 08.12.2004 issued
by Central Board of Excise and Customs (CBEC) also provides
that interest is payable only upon expiry of 3 months from the final
disposal of dispute, Applying the ratio of these
judgments/instructions on peculiar facts and circumstances of
issue in hand, while allowing the appeal, the matter is referred
back to Adjudicating Authority for limited purpose to re-quantify
the interest payable to the respondent in the light of discussion
made above and pass a reasoned order thereafter following the
law of natural justice. In view of discussion, analysis and
judgements cited above, the appeal is disposed of as per para 4(ii)
above.”
11. Being aggrieved, the appellant preferred an Appeal contending
th
that the impugned order dated 07 January, 2019 was passed in
violation of the principles of natural justice and prayed that the matter
be remanded for fresh adjudication by keeping all issues open for
consideration. The appellant also contended that it had never received
th
the notice of personal hearing and in fact on 13 December, 2018.
According to him, on the very same day he had appeared before the
same Appellate Authority in an appeal preferred by him thereby
furnishing the details of the same. According to the Appellant, he would
have definitely appeared and participated in the hearing, in case, the
notice of hearing was served. He would urge that there was no
justifiable reason for him to avoid the hearing.
12. The appeal preferred by Appellant was dismissed by the learned
nd
Tribunal vide order dated 02 May, 2024 inter alia holding that the
amount was pre-deposited by the Appellant in February–March 2006
and May 2013. The relevant provisions of Section 35FF applicable at
the said time entitled the Appellant to the interest only from the expiry
of three months from the date of communication of the order passed by
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
Signing Date:16.09.2026
16:24:02
CEAC 4/2025 Page 5 of 10

the appellate authority, until the date of actual refund of the deposited
amount.
13. Thereafter, the Appellant preferred an application seeking
nd
rectification of the order dated 02 May, 2024, inter alia , on the ground
that the controversy before the Learned Tribunal was confined to the
issue of violation of the principles of natural justice and the
consequentially sought remand of the matter for fresh adjudication with
keeping all issues open. It was submitted that the Learned Tribunal
exceeded the scope of the controversy by adjudicating the matter on
merits, despite the fact that the was never argued by the Appellant on
the merits, as such, opportunity was never offered.
14. However, the Learned Tribunal, vide order dated 23rd
September, 2024, dismissed the application filed by the Appellant
seeking rectification of the mistake apparent on the face of the record.
15. The issue raised before this Court pertains to the period from
which the Appellant would be entitled to interest as regards amount
deposited by the Appellant in compliance with statutory mandate as a
pre-deposit before the learned Tribunal.
16. Heard learned counsel for the parties.
17. The question of law this Court contemplates to consider in the
aforesaid background is as to whether the CESTAT as well as the
Commissioner (Appeals) were justified in passing the impugned order
thereby recording a finding that, the notices of personal hearing were
though served, particularly, when there was no acknowledgment of
service of the notice on the record of the respondents, thereby resulting
in denial of an opportunity of hearing, the Appellant had chosen not to
appear in the matter.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
Signing Date:16.09.2026
16:24:02
CEAC 4/2025 Page 6 of 10

18. In the proceedings before the Commissioner of Central Tax
th
(Appeals-II), it was observed, vide order dated 7 January, 2019, that
th th
notices of hearing dated 11 December, 2018, 13 December, 2018 and
th
16 December, 2018, had been duly served upon the appellant, who had
failed to appear in the matter.
19. As against above, the case of the appellant is that such notices
were never received by it.
20. The facts of the present case, prompted this Court to pass the
th
order dated 11 February, 2026, so as to enable the learned counsel for
the respondent to verify the aforesaid facts from the record of the
Commissioner (Appeals).
21. Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that a specific
ground to that effect was raised before the learned Customs, Excise and
Service Tax Appellate Tribunalwhich reads thus:-
“ B.The learned Commissioner Appeal passed the impugned
order without giving a fair opportunity of personal hearing.
The hearing as per the impugned Order-in-Appeal is statedto
have been given on 06.12.2018, 11.12.2018 & 13.12.2018 and
it is stated that none from the Appellant or Respondent had
appeared on those dates. The appellant had not received the
Letters of hearing. The fact is clear from the Order-in-Appeal
No.298/Central Tax/ Appi-11/Delhi/2018 dated 07.01.2019.
One of the dates stated to be given in the present case is
13.12.2018. On 13.12.2018 itself representatives of the
appellant appeared before the learned Commissioner Appeal
in the case of appellant itself decided Vide the Order-in-
Appeal. No. 298/Central Tax/ Appi-11/Delhi/2018 dated
07.01.2019. Had the appellant been intimated about hearing
on 13.12.2018 in present case also the representative of the
appellant would have attended the hearing in this case also as
he had appeared in the above cited case on the same day. The
impugned order is liable to be set aside/ remanded on this
ground alone.”
th
22. Relevantly, para 3 of the order dated 07 January, 2019 holds
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
Signing Date:16.09.2026
16:24:02
CEAC 4/2025 Page 7 of 10

that personal Hearing was granted to the appellant (Revenue) and the
respondent (appellant herein) on 06.12.2018, 11.12.2018 &
13.12.2018, however, since none had appeared despite providing
sufficient opportunity, the matter was decided ex-parte .
23. Learned counsel for the appellant has stated, in categorical terms,
th
that on the very same day i.e. on 13 December,2018, Appellant had
appeared before the respondent in another case filed by it, wherein a
copy of which is placed on record as Annexure A-9 . wherein paragraph
3 of the said order reads thus: -
“3.Personal Hearing dated 13.12.2018 has been attended by
Sh. Rajesh Rawal (Advocate) on behalf of the appellant. He
has reiterated the submissions made earlier in the grounds
of appeal. No one appeared on behalf of Respondent
(Revenue).”
24. The appellant has pleaded that both matters were listed on the
same day before the Commissioner (Appeals) between the same
parties; hence, it is difficult to believe that the counsel appeared in one
matter but not in the other matter.
25. As against the above, a perusal of the written submissions of the
respondent reveals that what is claimed by them is the issuance of
th th
personal hearing notices dated 16 December, 2018, 11 December,
th
2018 and 13 December, 2018. The aforesaid was the statutory
requirement under Section 35A(3) of the Central Excise Act,1944.
26. What is sought to be demonstrated by the appellant is that
although the notices were issued, the respondents have failed to place
on record any acknowledgement evidencing service of the aforesaid
notices upon the Appellant. Consequently, denial of personal
opportunity of hearing can be inferred as respondents have failed to
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
Signing Date:16.09.2026
16:24:02
CEAC 4/2025 Page 8 of 10

demonstrate the service of notice of personal hearing.
27. There being no document placed on record by the respondent
th th
demonstrating service of notices dated 16 December, 2018, 11
th
December, 2018 and 13 December, 2018 upon the Appellant, we are
left with no other option but to accept the contentions raised by the
counsel for the Appellant that notices were not served upon the
Appellant. The contentions of the Appellant of having appeared for
personal hearing in another case between the same parties on the very
same day before the Commissioner (Appeals) furthermore establishes
the case of the appellant of having not received the notices of personal
hearing.
28. A perusal of orders Annexures A-9 and AnnexuresA-6 , passed by
the Commissioner (Appeals), dealing with appeals involving the very
same parties on the very same date, wherein learned counsel for the
Appellant, Mr. Rawal , had appeared in one of the matters, it cannot be
said that the counsel for the Appellant appeared in one matter and chose
not to appear in the other matter.
29. In such an eventuality, the contentions of the Appellant cannot
be faulted about his non-appearance, as the notices of hearing, even if
presumed to have been issued to Appellant, have not been established
to have been served upon him.
30. Apart from above, the fact remains that it was expected from the
CESTAT to deal with the aforesaid issue while dealing with the claim
of the Appellant as regards grant of opportunity of hearing to the
Appellant. The Tribunal, however, proceeded to decide the matter on
merits without dealing with the aforesaid issue. As such, impugned
order of CESTAT also results in denial of opportunity.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
Signing Date:16.09.2026
16:24:02
CEAC 4/2025 Page 9 of 10

31. Accordingly, we hold that the notices of personal hearing dated
th th th
16 December, 2018, 11 December, 2018 and 13 December, 2018 as
contemplated under Section 35A(3) of the Act, were not served upon
the Appellant.
32. We as such direct the Commissioner (Appeals) to consider the
appellant’s claim afresh.
33. The Appellant undertakes to appear before the Commissioner
st
(Appeals) on 21 September, 2026 at 02:30 P.M .
34. The appeal accordingly stands partly allowed.
35. Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
36. A copy of this Judgment be uploaded on the website of this
Court.
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
(JUDGE)
AJAY DIGPAUL
(JUDGE)
SEPTEMBER 1, 2026/ sky/ok
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
Signing Date:16.09.2026
16:24:02
CEAC 4/2025 Page 10 of 10