Basant Paul Singh Sidhu And Another vs Sant Paul Singh Sidhu (Since Deceased) Through Lrs And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
RSA-1577-2023 (O&M) -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
120 RSA-1577-2023 (O&M)
Date of decision: 12.11.2026
Basant Paul Singh Sidhu and another
....Appellants
Vs.
Sant Paul Singh Sidhu (deceased) through
LRs. and others
....Respondents
CORAM : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER
Present: Mr. Manvinder Singh Dalal, Advocate
for the appellants.
*
HARSH BUNGER J.
1. For convenience, the parties herein are being addressed as per
their status in the original suit.
2. This is the defendants' second appeal challenging the judgment
and decree dated 27.11.2019 passed by learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division), Ferozepur, as well as the judgment and decree dated 24.11.2022
passed by learned Additional District Judge, Ferozepur.
3. Briefly, the plaintiffs filed a suit for permanent injunction,
wherein the following relief was sought:
“Civil suit for the issuance of the decree for permanent
injunction restraining the defendants from interfering wrongly
and illegally in installing the gate at private passage measuring
18'-6" x 250' of the plaintiffs at point A & B and shown in the
site plan attached with the plaint bounded as under:-
East : Readymade Garments shop of Anand Garments.
West : Shop of Defendant no. 1.
ANKIT
2026.11.16 11:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
RSA-1577-2023 (O&M) -2-
North : House of the plaintiffs.
South : Malwal Metal Road.
Situated opposite Sandeep Hotel, Malwal Road, Ferozepur City
and further restraining the defendants from making any kind of
interference in the usage of the private passage of the plaintiffs
alongwith the relief of mandatory injunction for the issuance of
the directions to the defendants for removing the iron gate
(shutter) which has been wrongly and illegally installed by the
defendants at Mark-C and D in the site plan over the private
passage of the plaintiffs, on the basis of oral as well as
documentary evidence.”
3.1 The aforesaid suit was filed by the plaintiffs on the plea that
defendant No. 1 (Basant Paul Singh Sidhu) is the brother of plaintiff No. 1
(Sant Paul Singh Sidhu), whereas defendant No. 2 (Jaipal Singh Sidhu) is
the nephew of plaintiff No. 1. It was averred that there is a private passage of
the plaintiffs measuring 18'-6" x 250' (as shown in the site plan), which starts
from Malwal Metal Road at point 'E' and leads to point 'F', which is a dead
end of the passage. It was averred that the houses of the plaintiffs are
situated towards the western side of the said passage and that the said
passage had been carved out by the plaintiffs out of their own land and the
said passage was their exclusive ownership and the defendants have got no
right or concern with the said private passage. Plaintiffs further stated that
the said passage was the only passage for ingress and outgress of the
plaintiffs to their houses and except the said passage, there is no other
passage to go to their houses.
3.2 It was further stated that there is one commercial shop of
defendant No. 1 situated at Malwal Road adjoining the said private passage,
ANKIT
2026.11.16 11:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
RSA-1577-2023 (O&M) -3-
and the gate of the said shop opened towards the Metal Road (Malwal
Road). Plaintiffs stated that since anti-social elements used to break open the
locks of the houses of the peaceful citizens of the city and for security
reasons, the plaintiffs want to install gate at point 'A' and 'B' (as shown in the
site plan) over the passage in question and two metal pillars were
constructed for the said purpose; but the defendants, along with some
anti-social elements, tried to demolish the said two metal pillars (as shown in
the photographs) and further threatened the plaintiffs to cause hindrance in
the installation of the gate at point 'A' and 'B'. Plaintiffs also stated that
defendant No. 1 has wrongly and illegally installed one iron gate (shutter) at
point 'C' and 'D' in the private passage of the plaintiffs, for which they have
got no right to do so, and the same was liable to be removed. With the
aforesaid pleas, the plaintiffs filed the suit.
4. Upon issuance of notice in the suit, the defendants appeared and
filed their written statement taking various preliminary objections as regards
the maintainability of the suit, locus standi, etc. It was stated that the
defendants are co-sharers in joint possession of the common passage in
dispute and the matter is regarding common street/passage, which the
plaintiffs intend to block by installing a gate in an illegal manner.
Defendants stated that plaintiffs No. 2 to 4 had purchased the plot from
defendant No. 1, on which they had built their houses, and the recitals of the
sale deed clearly mentions the fact that the passage in question is a common
passage and is not a private passage.
4.1 It is stated that the plaintiffs intentionally did not produce any
registered sale deed on record, which showed the street in question as a
ANKIT
2026.11.16 11:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
RSA-1577-2023 (O&M) -4-
common street for ingress and outgress of the defendants and plaintiffs. It is
stated that the plaintiffs admitted the legitimate and legal right of possession
of the commercial shop by the defendants, and that the plaintiffs never
denied the ownership rights of the defendants on the shop.
4.2 It is the case of the defendants that the plaintiffs want to
illegally and forcibly install the gate so as to cause wrongful loss to the
defendants by converting the common street/passage for their own personal
benefits, for which they have no right, title, and interest to do so. It was
further stated that the shutter put up by the defendants on the eastern side of
their shop was legal and correct, as the common passage/street adjoins the
shop of the defendants, and they have right of access. Defendants maintained
that the plaintiffs cannot raise pillars or install gates on the common
street/passage. It was also stated that the said common street/passage has
two electric poles installed by PSPCL and even the said common passage
was constructed by the Municipal Authorities.
4.3 It was also stated that the plaintiffs never raised any objection
when they were installing shutter of their shop, and now they have filed the
suit with the intention to harass and cause wrongful loss to the defendants,
so as to illegally encroach upon the common passage/street. It was also
stated that as per the assessment register maintained by the Municipal
Committee, Ferozepur, the passage in question is described as a common
street/passage in the municipal records. It was stated that the suit is false and
frivolous. The other averments of the plaint were denied and prayer for
dismissal of the suit was made.
ANKIT
2026.11.16 11:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
RSA-1577-2023 (O&M) -5-
5. The plaintiffs filed replication, wherein they denied the
averments of the written statement filed by defendants and reiterated that the
passage in question is a private passage.
6. From the pleading of the parties, following issues were framed
by the learned Trial Court:-
“1. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the permanent
injunction as prayed for?OPP
2. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the mandatory
injunction as prayed for?OPP
3. Whether suit of the plaintiffs is not maintainable in its
present form?OPD
4. Whether the plaintiffs have not come to the court with
clean hands?OPD
5. Whether the plaintiffs have no locus standi to file the
present suit?OPD
6. Relief.”
7. Thereafter, the parties led their respective evidence on the
aforesaid issues.
8. The learned Trial Court, after considering the matter, decreed
the suit filed by the plaintiffs vide judgment and decree dated 27.11.2019.
9. Feeling dissatisfied, the defendants preferred an appeal before
the learned Additional District Judge, Ferozepur, which has been dismissed
vide judgment and decree dated 24.11.2022.
10. In the aforementioned circumstances, the present second appeal
has been filed before this Court.
11. I have heard learned counsel for the appellants/defendants and
perused the paperbook with his able assistance.
ANKIT
2026.11.16 11:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
RSA-1577-2023 (O&M) -6-
12. In the present case, the dispute between the parties is primarily
in respect of a street/passage, which the plaintiffs claimed to be their private
passage, whereas the defendants claim the said passage to be a common
passage.
13. The learned Trial Court, upon appraisal of the pleadings as well
as the evidence on record, came to the conclusion that the passage in
question is not a thoroughfare, but the same is exclusive ownership of the
plaintiffs in which defendants No. 1 himself relinquished his rights through
sale of his plots to plaintiffs No. 2 to 4 without reserving any right over the
same, therefore, the mere fact that the shop of defendant No. 1 adjoins the
passage in question, the defendant cannot be allowed to open the shutters in
the passage in question. Based upon the findings returned on various issues,
the learned Trial Court decreed the suit of the plaintiffs.
14. The findings returned by the learned Trial Court have been
further affirmed by the learned First Appellate Court by observing as under:
“9. ….. Perusal of the file shows that it is the admitted case
of both the parties that earlier there was residential house of
respondent No. 1 and a vacant plot measuring about 2 Kanal
was owned by appellant No.1 and there was private passage of
respondent No.1 and appellant No.1, which led to the house of
respondent No.1 and said plot of appellant No.1. Later on,
appellant No.1 sold his said plot to respondents No.2 to 4 and
they constructed their residential houses over the said plot. So,
since the appellant No.1 has sold his entire plot measuring 2
Kanal to respondents No.2 to 4. So, the private passage in
question has become the private passage of the respondents.
10. Appellant No. 1 in his cross examination has admitted
that earlier there was house of plaintiff No.1 being adjoined by
ANKIT
2026.11.16 11:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
RSA-1577-2023 (O&M) -7-
plot of 58 marlas owned by defendant No.1 and as per family
settlement, house of plaintiff No.1 was given to plaintiff no.1
and adjoining plot of 58 marlas was given to defendant No.1.
He further admitted that the passage in question was carved out
for being used for the house of plaintiff No.1 and for adjoining
his plot of 58 marlas and that he had also one plot on the
Malwal Road. He further deposed that it is correct that there
was no plot of him at Malwal Road, rather there was four small
shops at Malwal Road and the said shops have been demolished
and one large showroom had been constructed, He further
stated that the wall of the dead end of the passage in question
was raised in the year 1968 and volunteered that prior to 1968
there was Luxmi Rice Mill and the said passage was also meant
for Luxmi Rice Mills also. He admitted that since raising of the
wall on the dead end, the passage in question was being used by
the plaintiff No.1 and defendant no.1 only and except them none
else had any right, title or concern over the passage in question.
Appellant No.1 further deposed in his cross-examination that it
is correct that the entire plot of 58 marlas is the area mentioned
as A1, A2, F and F1 in the site plan Ex.P1 and he further
admitted that passage mark A1 to F was carved by the plaintiffs
no.2 to 4 from the plot measuring 58 marlas. He further
admitted that plaintiffs no.2 to 4 are the exclusive owners of the
said passage carved out by them from the land 58 marlas.
Further, perusal of Ex.P6 i.e. sale deed dated 01.06.2000
executed in favour of respondent No. 2 and Ex.P8 i.e. sale deed
dated 01.06.2000 executed in favour of respondent No. 4 clearly
shows that there is recital in the said sale deeds that the passage
in question is common passage and not a public passage and
that the appellant No.1 has received the sale consideration. So,
all these facts available on record proves that appellant No.1
has already sold his plot to respondents No.2 to 4 from point A1,
A2, F, F1 as per site plan Ex.P1 on which they have built their
ANKIT
2026.11.16 11:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
RSA-1577-2023 (O&M) -8-
houses, which is also admitted by appellant No.1 and the
passage in question has been carved out by the respondents
No.2 to 4 from point A1 to F from their own land. Moreover, it is
admitted case of appellant No.1 that he has given the showroom
on rent to Clara International and all the customers enter or
exit through the main gate installed at Malwal Road, Ferozepur
City and this fact proves that the shutter in question installed by
appellants at point C and D of Ex.P1 i.e. site plan is not at all
the basic necessity of appellants. It has been proved on record
that the passage in question is the private passage of the
plaintiffs and not a thoroughfare, so the appellants have no
concern with the passage in question and respondents can
install the iron gate at point A & B as shown in the site plan
Ex.P1 because the appellant No.1 himself relinquished his right
over the passage, so it cannot be said that by installation of gate
at point A & B any of the rights of the appellants have been
violated. I have gone through the impugned judgment and
decree passed by the learned civil court and found that the
learned civil court has rightly discussed all these facts and
circumstances alongwith the evidence in detail in the impugned
judgment and decree and has rightly held that the passage in
question is a not a public passage and is a passage carved out
by the respondents. Hence, this point of determination is hereby
decided in favour of the respondents and against the appellants.
11. Thus, in the light of the above discussions, this court is of
the considered view that the learned trial court has rightly
passed the impugned judgment and decree. Accordingly, this
court finds no reason to interfere in the findings of the learned
trial court, which are based upon the correct appreciation of
facts and evidence. Accordingly the present appeal is hereby
dismissed with costs and judgment and decree passed by the
learned trial court is upheld in its letter and spirit...”
ANKIT
2026.11.16 11:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
RSA-1577-2023 (O&M) -9-
15. Before this Court, learned counsel appearing for the appellants
has failed to show as to how the findings returned by the learned Courts
below are either illegal or perverse or based on misreading of evidence.
Apparently, there are concurrent findings returned by learned Courts below.
16. In Jaichand v. Sahnulal, 2025(2) Apex Court Judgments (SC)
336 ; Hon'ble Apex Court observed as under:-
“24. In Navaneethammal v. Arjuna Chetty reported in AIR
1996 S.C. 3521 , it was held by this Court that the High Court
should not reappreciate the evidence to reach another possible
view in order to set aside the findings of fact arrived at by the
first appellate Court.
25. In Kshitisn Chandra Purkait v. Santhosh Kumar Purkait
reported in (1997) 5 S.C.C. 438) , this Court held that in the
Second Appeal, the High Court should be satisfied that the case
involves a substantial question of law and not mere question of
law.
26. In Dnyanoba Bhaurao Shemade v. Maroti Bhaurao
Marnor reported in 1999 (2) S.C.C. 471 , this Court held:-
"Keeping in view the amendment made in 1976, the High Court
can exercise its jurisdiction under Section 100, C.P.C. only on
the basis of substantial questions of law which are to be framed
at the time of admission of the Second Appeal and the Second
Appeal has to be heard and decided only on the basis of such
duly framed substantial questions of law. A judgment rendered
by the High Court under Section 100 C.P.C. without following
the aforesaid procedure cannot be sustained."
27. This Court in Kondira Dagadu Kadam v. Savitribai
Sopan Gujar reported in AIR 1999 S.C. 2213 held:-
"The High Court cannot substitute its opinion for the
opinion of the first appellate Court unless it is found that
the conclusions drawn by the lower appellate Court were
ANKIT
2026.11.16 11:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
RSA-1577-2023 (O&M) -10-
erroneous being contrary to the mandatory provisions of
law applicable or its settled position on the basis of
pronouncements made by the Apex Court, or was based
upon inadmissible evidence or arrived at without
evidence."
28. It is thus clear that under Section 100, C.P.C., the High
Court cannot interfere with the findings of fact arrived at by the
first Appellate Court which is the final Court of facts except in
such cases where such findings were erroneous being contrary
to the mandatory provisions of law, or its settled position on the
basis of the pronouncement made by the Apex Court or based
upon inadmissible evidence or without evidence…”
17. Keeping in view the above discussion, I see no merit in this
appeal nor there is any substantial question of law involved in the present
regular second appeal.
18. Resultantly, the instant regular second appeal fails and the same
is accordingly, dismissed .
19. All the pending application(s), if any, shall also stand closed.
(HARSH BUNGER)
12.11.2026 JUDGE
Ankit
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
ANKIT
2026.11.16 11:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh