Kultarnjit Singh vs State Of Punjab And Another
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CWP-678-2
IN
2025 (O&M)
1
N THE HIGH COURT OF PU
UNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIG
GARH
(233)
CWP-678-2025 (O&M)
Date of Decision : 16.11.2026
Kultarnjit Si
ingh
…Petitioner
Versus
s
State of Pun
njab and another
...Respondents
CORAM:
Present:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KU
ULDEEP TIWARI
Mr. Randhir Singh Manhas, Ad
Mr. H.S. Saini, Advocate
for the petitioner.
dvocate
Mr. Vikas Arora, DAG, Punjab
b.
KULDEEP
P TIWARI, J. (ORAL)
1.
Through the instant writ petiti
ion, cast under Article 226/227
of
the Constitu
ution of India, a prayer is made
for issuance of a mandamus , up
pon
the respond
dents, to grant interest @ 18% p
per annum to the petitioner, on t
the
delayed pay
yment of retiral benefits, i.e.
leave encashment, GIS, pensio
on,
gratuity and
d commutation of pension etc., w
which had been after delay of ni
ine
months.
2.
The issue involved in the instan
nt writ petition is as to whether, t
the
petitioner is
s entitled for grant of interest o
on the delayed payment of reti
iral
benefits, or
not.
3.
What is not disputed before th
his Court is that the petitioner,
on
attaining the
e age of superannuation on 31.0
03.2024, retired from the service
e as
District Edu
ucation Officer. He was paid
d leave encashment, pension a
MANPREET SINGH
and
2026.11.17 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP-678-2
gratuity afte
2025 (O&M)
2
er more than a period of six mo
onths after his retirement where
eas
GPF was pa
aid after a period of three months
s.
4.
The respondents have come
up with sole submission that
on
account of
f intra departmental procedure
e, the delay has occurred. T
The
explanation
put forth by the respondents be
efore this Court is neither plausib
ble
nor acceptab
ble.
5.
This issue as involved in the i
instant writ petition as regards t
the
entitlement
of the interest on the delayed
payment of retiral benefits, is
no
more res int
tegra .
6.
Since the pensionary benefits h
have been released to the petition
ner,
after an ino
ordinate delay, therefore, the p
petitioner is held entitled for t
the
interest, by
y virtue of law laid down b
by Full Bench of this Court
in
‘A.S. Randh
hawa versus State of Punjab’ 1
1997 (3) SCT 468 , and a decisi
ion
rendered by
y a Coordinate Bench of this Cou
urt in ‘J.S. Cheema versus State
e of
Haryana’ 2
2014(13) R.C.R. (Civil) 355 .
7.
Furthermore, similar issue h
has already been examined b
by
Coordinate B
Bench of this Court in CWP-602
2-2023 , titled ‘Hira Lal Karakar
ra
versus State
e of Punjab and others’ decid
ded on 09.05.2024. The releva
ant
paragraphs o
of the said judgment are extracte
ed hereinafter :-
4. Learned counsel for
r the petitioner submits that th
he
petitioner has retired f
from service on 31.10.2022 an
nd
since the retiral dues of
f the petitioner have been release
ed
after a considerable de
elay, therefore, he is entitled fo
for
interest on the same in vi
iew of the law laid down by a Fu
ull
Bench of this Court in
n A.S. Randhawa Vs. State o
of
Punjab and others : 199
97(3) S.C.T. 468 and J.S. Cheem
ma
Vs. State of Haryana : 2
2014(13) RCR (Civil) 355 .
MANPREET SINGH
2026.11.17 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP-678-2
2025 (O&M)
3
5. On the other hand,
learned counsel for responde
ent
No.2, while referring to
the averments made in the reply
ly,
submits that since the w
whole amount of retiral dues ha
as
already been paid to the
e petitioner, therefore, the insta
nt
petition has been rendere
ed infructuous.
xxx xxx xxx
7. Since either before
or after the retirement of th
he
petitioner, no departme
ental/criminal proceedings we
re
pending against him, th
herefore, his retiral benefits we
re
required to be released w
within a reasonable time after h
his
retirement. Moreover, a
a perusal of reply filed by th
he
respondent No.2 shows
that although the retiral dues
of
the petitioner have been
released, however, the same hav
ve
been released after a
a considerable delay and n
no
explanation has been fur
rnished for not releasing the sam
me
at the time of retireme
ent or within a reasonable tim
me
thereafter.
8. A Full Bench of this C
Court in A.S. Randhawa Vs. Sta
ate
of Punjab and others :
1997(3) S.C.T. 468 has held th
at
where there is an inord
dinate delay in releasing benefi
fits
and the delay is not just
tifiable, employee will be entitle
ed
for interest. The relevant
t paragraph of said judgment is a
as
under:-
“Since a governm
ment employee on his retireme
ent
becomes immediat
tely entitled to pension and oth
er
benefits in terms
of the Pension Rules, a duty
is
simultaneously ca
ast on the State to ensure th
he
disbursement of p
pension and other benefits to th
he
retiree in proper
time. As to what is proper tim
me
will depend on the
e facts and circumstances of eac
ch
case but normally
y it would not exceed two month
hs
from the date of
retirement which time limit ha
as
been laid down
n by the Apex Court in M
M.
Padmanabhan Na
air's case (supra). If the Sta
ate
MANPREET SINGH
2026.11.17 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
commits any defau
ult in the performance of its du
uty
CWP-678-2
2025 (O&M)
4
thereby denying t
to the retiree the benefit of th
he
immediate use of h
his money, there is no gainsayin
ng
the fact that he ge
ets a right to be compensated an
nd,
in our opinion, th
he only way to compensate him
is
to pay him interes
st for the period of delay on th
he
amount as was d
due to him on the date of h
his
retirement.”
8.
Apart from this, a Coordi
nate Bench of this Court
in
‘ J.S. Cheem
ma Vs. State of Haryana’ 2014
4 (13) RCR (Civil) 355 , had he
eld
that an emp
ployee will be entitled for the i
interest on an amount which h
as
been retaine
ed by the respondents without an
ny valid justification. The releva
ant
paragraph o
f the said judgment is as under: -
-
“The jurisprudent
tial basis for grant of interest
is
the fact that one p
person's money has been used b
by
somebody else. It
is in that sense rent for the usag
ge
of money. If the
e user is compounded by an
ny
negligence on the
part of the person with whom th
he
money is lying it m
may result in higher rate becaus
se
then it can also in
nclude the component of damag
es
(in the form of int
terest). In the circumstances, eve
en
if there is no negl
ligence on the part of the State
it
cannot be denie
ed that money which right
tly
belonged to the pe
etitioner was in the custody of th
he
State and was bein
ng used by it.”
10. In view of the
above factual position and settle
ed
principles of law,
, the present petition is allowe
ed
and respondent N
No.2 is directed to pay interest @
@
6% per annum to
o the petitioner, on the delaye
ed
payment of retiral
l dues w.e.f. 01.01.2023 (after tw
wo
months of his re
tirement) till the actual date
of
payment, within a
a period of 03 months from th
he
date of receipt of c
certified copy of this order.”
MANPREET SINGH
2026.11.17 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP-678-2
9.
2025 (O&M)
5
In view of the above settled po
osition, the instant writ petition
is
disposed of
f , with a mandamus , upon the r
respondents, to calculate and pa
ay
the interest
after three months from the date
e of retirement of the petitioner t
ill
its realizatio
on, @ 6% per annum. The exerc
cise (supra) be carried out within
n a
period of th
hree months, from the date of
receipt of certified copy of th
his
order.
10.
Needless to say that, in case, th
he above said payment is not mad
de
to the petiti
ioner, within the stipulated perio
od, the petitioner shall further b
be
entitled for t
the interest @ 9% per annum, til
ll actual realization.
11.
Ordered accordingly.
12.
Pending applications, if any, sta
and disposed of accordingly.
(KULDEEP TIWARI)
JUDGE
November 1
Manpreet
16, 2026
Whether speaking/reasoned
Whether reportable
: Yes/No
: Yes/No
MANPREET SINGH
2026.11.17 16:43
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment