01Facts
The respondent, an Account Officer at AIIMS, was proceeded against under a charge memorandum dated 17 November 2021, issued by the Director on behalf of the President, AIIMS. The proceedings culminated in her dismissal on 31 December 2024.
p. 1She challenged the disciplinary proceedings before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), which allowed her application, set aside the proceedings and directed reinstatement with consequential benefits.
p. 2AIIMS challenged the CAT’s decision, contending that it had followed an earlier CAT ruling without addressing Note (ii), which authorises the Chairman of the Governing Body to initiate disciplinary proceedings against Group ‘A’ employees and faculty members.
pp. 2–302Issues
i.1. Whether the CAT’s decision to set aside the disciplinary proceedings could stand when it had followed its earlier ruling without separately considering the application of Note (ii) to the respondent, a Group ‘A’ employee.
pp. 2–4ii.2. Whether the matter required remand for the CAT to determine de novo the authority competent to initiate the proceedings, including the effect of the Health Minister holding both the offices of Chairman of the Governing Body and President, AIIMS.
pp. 3–403Law Applied
Note (ii) provides that, because Governing Body meetings are held at intervals, its Chairman is authorised to initiate disciplinary proceedings against Group ‘A’ employees and faculty members, while the final penalty decision is to be taken by the Governing Body.
p. 3The CAT had relied on All India Institute of Medical Sciences v. S.P. Vashisht, 2023 SCC OnLine Del 3168, in which it considered the President, AIIMS not to be the Disciplinary Authority in the circumstances before it.
pp. 2–3The High Court did not finally determine the scope or application of Note (ii); it held that the distinct issues raised in this case required specific adjudication by the CAT.
p. 404Reasoning
The CAT had set aside the proceedings by following its earlier decision, which treated the charge-sheet issued by the President, AIIMS as lacking jurisdiction.
p. 3AIIMS argued that the earlier case concerned a Group ‘B’ employee, whereas the respondent was a Group ‘A’ employee covered by Note (ii), and that the Health Minister’s roles as Chairman and President made the Chairman’s authority relevant.
pp. 3–4Because the CAT had not separately addressed these contentions, the High Court considered a more detailed, independent determination necessary and directed the CAT to examine the matter de novo.
p. 405Holding
The High Court did not decide whether the disciplinary proceedings were valid or whether the respondent was entitled to reinstatement.
p. 4It quashed the CAT’s judgment and remanded the application for de novo adjudication, directing the CAT to proceed uninfluenced by its earlier decision or the order under challenge.
p. 4The CAT was requested to hear the matter expeditiously, with final hearing fixed for 20 November 2026; the parties were directed to file exchanged notes of submissions of no more than four pages each at least two days beforehand, and neither side was entitled to seek an adjournment.
pp. 4–5Original Court PDF
All India Institute Of Medical SciencesvsMs Meenakshi Dabral & Anr.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
