01Facts
The appellant entrusted 40,444 bags of salt for shipment from Gujarat to Assam via the respondent-railway on November 10, 2009
p. 2Upon arrival, a shortage of 1,742 bags was recorded, for which a shortage certificate was issued
p. 2The goods were loaded directly by the consignor’s employees without railway supervision, and the Railway Receipt (RR) contained a "said to contain" remark under "owner’s risk"
p. 3The Railway Claims Tribunal and the Gauhati High Court concurrently rejected the appellant’s claim for damages totaling Rs. 3,48,400/-, prompting this appeal
p. 302Issues
i.1. Whether the Railway Administration can be held liable for shortage in consignment when goods are carried at "owner’s risk" and the receipt contains a "said to contain" remark
p. 10 / para. 10ii.2. Whether the appellant discharged the burden of proof regarding the actual number of bags loaded as required under the proviso to Section 65(2) of the Railways Act, 1989
p. 17 / para. 1503Law Applied
Section 65(2) mandates that if a railway servant does not check the weight or number of packages, the burden of proving the quantity lies on the consignor
p. 6Section 93 establishes the general responsibility of railways as a carrier, subject to specific exceptions
p. 7Section 97 is a non-obstante clause providing that for goods carried at "owner’s risk," the railway is not responsible for loss or shortage unless negligence or misconduct by the railway or its servants is proved
pp. 7-8Rule 1811 of the Indian Railway Code for Traffic (Commercial) Department regarding "said to contain" receipts
p. 10Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Railways Act, 1989 Section 65Section 93Section 97Section 99
Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 Section 23
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 1811
04Reasoning
The Court determined that the non-obstante clause in Section 97 overrides the general obligations of the Railways under Section 93
¶ 11Since the salt was transported at "owner’s risk," the appellant was required to prove negligence or misconduct
¶ 11The Court defined negligence as a breach of a duty of care, but noted that such a duty only arises if the Railway had verified the goods at the time of loading.
¶ 12.1-12.5Under the proviso to Section 65(2), because the Railway did not supervise loading or verify the count, the legal burden remained with the appellant to prove the initial quantity
¶ 14The Court found that the appellant failed to produce documents (such as procurement or processing records) to establish the initial 40,444 bags
¶ 15Consequently, without proof of the initial quantity, the question of negligence due to transit shortage could not be sustained
¶ 1505Holding
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, holding that the Railway Administration is not liable for shortages in "owner’s risk" consignments where the consignor fails to discharge the statutory burden of proof regarding the quantity loaded at the starting point
¶ 15-16The Court affirmed the concurrent findings of the Tribunal and the High Court, reinforcing that a "said to contain" remark shifts the evidentiary burden entirely to the claimant
¶ 14-16Original Court PDF
M/S Bajaj Trading CompanyvsUnion Of India
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
