01Facts
The claimants, Dinesh Yadav and Pyari Bai, sought compensation under s.166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 for the death of Malkan Yadav alias Lal Yadav, aged 26, who died on 24/01/2022 when he fell from a vehicle while travelling as a pillion rider.
p. 2The deceased was a pillion rider on the offending vehicle, and the driver, Kamal Singh Verma, was prosecuted under s.304-A IPC in Crime No. 63/2022 at Thana Mar.
p. 2Respondent No. 2 is the vehicle owner, and Respondent No. 3 is the insurer, Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
p. 1The Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal framed issues on 01/05/2023.
p. 3On 22/06/2023 it passed an order holding that the death resulted from the deceased's own negligence, and dismissed the claim petition as not maintainable.
p. 3The claimants appealed under s.173 of the Act, challenging that order.
pp. 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal could dismiss the claim petition on 22/06/2023 after framing issues on 01/05/2023 without recording any evidence, any party's application, or any reasoned findings on those issues.
pp. 3–4ii.2. Whether the impugned order is sustainable in law and, if not, what course the appellate court should adopt.
pp. 4–503Law Applied
The Court's reasoning rests on s.173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, which provides the statutory appeal against the Tribunal's award or order, and s.166 of the same Act, under which the claim petition was filed.
p. 1The Court relied on the settled procedural requirement that, once issues are framed, the Tribunal must decide them on the basis of pleadings and evidence through a reasoned adjudication, and not by a summary dismissal without any application or record of consideration.
pp. 4–5The principle that an order that does not reflect adjudication on the issues cannot stand.
p. 504Reasoning
The Court first observed that the record showed the Tribunal had framed issues on 01/05/2023, yet the record did not show any application by either party for dismissal, and no application or consideration of such an application was recorded.
p. 4The impugned order does not show that it rested on a determination of those issues after evidence was led.
pp. 4–5The Court found that the Tribunal's dismissal on the ground of the deceased's own negligence was made without any indication of how the framed issues were examined or any evidence considered, and that the order therefore did not satisfy the requirement of a reasoned adjudication.
pp. 4–5Because the claim had been dismissed at a stage where the parties had not been permitted to lead evidence on the framed issues, the Court held that the claimants were entitled to have the issues decided on merits.
p. 505Holding
The Court held that the impugned order could not be sustained and that the matter required fresh consideration, as the Tribunal's order dated 22/06/2023 was passed without a proper adjudication of the framed issues.
p. 5The Tribunal's order dated 22/06/2023 is set aside. The Tribunal is directed to reconsider and decide the matter afresh, in accordance with law, after affording both parties an opportunity to lead evidence. The parties are directed to appear before the Tribunal on 07/12/2026 at 11:00 a.m., through their counsel, and the Tribunal is to decide the matter within four months from that date. A copy of the order is to be sent to the Tribunal forthwith.
p. 5Original Court PDF
DINU YADAVvsKOMAL SINGH VERMA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
