Karnataka High CourtCriminal Procedure and EvidenceCriminal Law

Chicken-Grazing Row Turns Into Rival Assault Cases; Karnataka HC Refuses To Quash, Orders Separate Trials Before Same Judge

SRI NAGESHAv.THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Chicken-Grazing Row Turns Into Rival Assault Cases; Karnataka HC Refuses To Quash, Orders Separate Trials Before Same Judge. SRI NAGESHA vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the FIR, charge sheet and cognizance in Crime No. 44/2025 can be quashed on the ground that a civil dispute over the same properties is pending between the parties.

The court held

The pending civil dispute is not a ground to quash the criminal proceedings, and rival versions of the incident must be tested on evidence at trial; no ground is made out to quash the FIR, charge sheet, or proceedings in C.C. No. 122/2025.

It also directed

The petition is dismissed. Directions: (i) The Civil Judge & JMFC, Gudibande, shall ascertain the status of Crime No. 42/2025 proceedings and ensure that Crime Nos. 42 and 44/2025 are tried by the same Court and Judge; (ii) the trials shall follow the procedure in Eshwara v. State of Karnataka; (iii) the two cases shall not be consolidated and shall be tried consecutively with separate evidence and separate, sequentially pronounced judgments; (iv) the observations are confined to this petition and the trial Court shall assess the evidence independently; (v) pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.

01Facts

Respondent No. 2 (Smt. Rathnamma) lodged a complaint on 12.02.2025 alleging that on 11.02.2025 at about 7.30 p.m., the petitioners questioned her for grazing a chicken on their land, then verbally and physically assaulted and kicked her.

¶ 2, 3

She was examined at the Government Hospital at about 11.35 a.m. on 12.02.2025 and complained of left shoulder and left hip pain; X-rays were taken.

¶ 3

FIR No. 44/2025 was registered. After investigation, a charge sheet was filed on 16.03.2025 under Sections 115(2), 118(1) and 3(5) of the BNS. Cognizance was taken on 20.03.2025 and the matter was numbered C.C. No. 122/2025 before the Civil Judge & JMFC, Gudibande.

¶ 2

The petitioners contend that a civil dispute over the subject properties is pending in RFA No. 2027 of 2022 and that the complaint is a counterblast to their earlier complaint.

¶ 4, 5

Their complaint, registered as Crime No. 42/2025 under Sections 118(1), 115(2), 352 and 3(5) of the BNS, alleges that petitioner No. 2 owns Survey No. 67/1, petitioner No. 1 works there, and that the respondents assaulted them on 11.02.2025.

¶ 5, 8

A charge sheet in Crime No. 42/2025 was filed on 20.03.2025.

¶ 5

Both investigations have culminated in charge sheets.

¶ 9, 13

02Issues

i.1. Whether the FIR, charge sheet and cognizance in Crime No. 44/2025 can be quashed on the ground that a civil dispute over the same properties is pending between the parties.

¶ 4, 11, 20

ii.2. Whether the subsequent complaint can be quashed as a counterblast that is false or malicious, merely because the petitioners lodged a prior complaint on the same occurrence.

¶ 12, 13

iii.3. Whether the Court, under its quashing jurisdiction, can choose between two rival versions of the incident.

¶ 18

iv.4. How case and counter-case arising from the same occurrence are to be investigated and tried.

¶ 14–17, 21

v.5. Whether the material supports the invocation of Sections 118(1) and 3(5) of the BNS.

¶ 19

03Law Applied

The Court exercised its inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC (filed under Section 528 BNSS) to test the impugned FIR, charge sheet and cognizance order.

¶ 1

A pending civil dispute over property does not, by itself, bar criminal proceedings for an alleged physical assault.

¶ 11, 20

A second complaint lodged after a rival complaint on the same occurrence is not, for that reason alone, false or malicious; rival versions must be tested on evidence.

¶ 12

Eshwara v. State of Karnataka, Criminal Appeal No. 100101 of 2016 (decided 17.03.2022): both cases are investigated by the same Investigating Officer, who must examine injuries on both sides and determine the aggressor and any right of private defence.

¶ 14, 15

Eshwara v. State of Karnataka: both cases are tried by the same Court and Judge, with different Public Prosecutors ordinarily conducting them; they are tried consecutively with separate evidence and separate judgments, and each judgment rests only on the evidence in that case.

¶ 16

Section 118(1) of the BNS requires that the hurt be caused by a weapon or means specified in the provision, and Section 3(5) of the BNS requires material indicating common intention.

¶ 19

Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 528

Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 Section 115Section 118Section 352Section 3

04Reasoning

The civil proceedings (RFA No. 2027/2022) do not preclude criminal action, since the complaint alleges independent assault causing bodily pain and medical treatment, not merely a property claim.

¶ 11

The prompt medical examination on 12.02.2025 is a circumstance that cannot be ignored at this stage, though the medical record alone does not establish who caused the injuries.

¶ 10, 18

The fact that the complaints are rival versions of the same occurrence does not establish that either is false, and the sequence of filing does not, by itself, show malice.

¶ 12

Both charge sheets do not establish that either version is true or false; the Investigating Officer must examine both complaints together, which is consistent with the possibility of mutual aggression, self-defence, or independent offences.

¶ 13

Because the rival versions turn on disputed facts, the Court declined to choose one account at the quashing stage.

¶ 18

The examination of the BNS ingredients is reserved for the trial Court, and the Court expressly disclaimed any finding of guilt.

¶ 19

Since the complaints form a case and counter-case, the Court directed application of the Eshwara procedure rather than quashing.

¶ 17, 21

05Holding

The pending civil dispute is not a ground to quash the criminal proceedings, and rival versions of the incident must be tested on evidence at trial; no ground is made out to quash the FIR, charge sheet, or proceedings in C.C. No. 122/2025.

¶ 22

The petition is dismissed. Directions: (i) The Civil Judge & JMFC, Gudibande, shall ascertain the status of Crime No. 42/2025 proceedings and ensure that Crime Nos. 42 and 44/2025 are tried by the same Court and Judge; (ii) the trials shall follow the procedure in Eshwara v. State of Karnataka; (iii) the two cases shall not be consolidated and shall be tried consecutively with separate evidence and separate, sequentially pronounced judgments; (iv) the observations are confined to this petition and the trial Court shall assess the evidence independently; (v) pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.

¶ 21 · Order (i)–(v)
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SRI NAGESHAvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka High Court · November 11, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment