01Facts
The Respondent-Assessee imported "n-Hexane" (or "Exxsol Hexane"), classifying it as a saturated acyclic hydrocarbon under Customs Tariff Heading (CTH) 2901.10 and Central Excise Tariff Heading (CETH) 2901.90
pp. 2-3The Revenue challenged this, relying on a test report showing a distillation range of 67°C–70°C and a flash point below 25°C, arguing the product was an admixture of hydrocarbons classifiable as "Motor Spirit" under CTH 2710.00 and CETH 2710.12
p. 3The Assistant Commissioner ruled in favor of the Revenue
pp. 4-5the Commissioner (Appeals) reversed this, citing HSN Notes
pp. 6-7The CESTAT subsequently dismissed the Revenue’s appeal, holding that n-Hexane is a separately chemically defined organic compound
pp. 7-1002Issues
i.1. Whether the imported product, "n-Hexane," merits classification under Chapter 27 (Petroleum Oil/Motor Spirit) or Chapter 29 (Pure Hydrocarbon/Separate Chemical Compound)
p. 2, 16 / para. 1, 3403Law Applied
General Rules for the Interpretation of the Import Tariff, specifically Rule 3(a), which mandates that a specific description prevails over a general one
p. 21, 23The burden of proof for classification lies with the Revenue, as established in Union of India v. Garware Nylons Ltd.
p. 20HSN Explanatory Notes are a "safe guide" for interpreting the Tariff Act (CCE v. Wood Craft Products Ltd.)
p. 25Three-fold test for "Motor Spirit" defined in the Supplementary Notes to Chapter 27: (i) it must be hydrocarbon oil, (ii) have a flash point below 25°C, and (iii) be suitable for use as fuel in spark ignition engines (CCE v. GAIL (India))
pp. 38-39DGFT decisions regarding classification doubts are final and binding under Para 2.3 of the Foreign Trade Policy
p. 45Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Customs Tariff Act, 1975 Section 27Section 29
Customs Act,1962 Section 17Section 18
04Reasoning
The Court found that n-Hexane meets the criteria for Chapter 29 as a "separate chemically defined organic compound" because it possesses a constant ratio of elements (C6H14) and a definitive linear structural diagram, distinguishing it from its branched isomers
pp. 41-42Regarding the Revenue's claim under Chapter 27, the Court held that while the flash point was indeed below 25°C, the Revenue failed to provide any evidence that the product was suitable for use as fuel in spark ignition engines—a mandatory third condition for "Motor Spirit"
pp. 38-40The presence of impurities did not disqualify the product from Chapter 29, as they resulted naturally from the distillation process (unconverted starting materials) and were not deliberately added or left behind to alter its use
pp. 43-44The Court also emphasized the DGFT Policy Circular dated 14.07.2004, which explicitly clarified that Hexane falls under Chapter 29
pp. 44-4505Holding
The Court answered the issue by holding that "n-Hexane" is correctly classifiable under CTH 2901.10 and CETH 2901.90
pp. 47-48The Revenue failed to discharge its burden of proof to show the product was a Motor Spirit under Chapter 27
p. 47The Court affirmed the CESTAT order and dismissed the Revenue's appeal
p. 49Original Court PDF
Commr.Of Customs KandlavsM/S Reliance Industries Ltd.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
