01Facts
The petitioner, a company operating Cloudnine Hospital at Nagarbhavi and Jayanagar, Bengaluru, sought mandamus directing the police to act on its complaint dated 30.10.2026 and representations dated 30.10.2026, 31.10.2026 and 01.11.2026, and to provide police protection to its hospitals, patients and staff.
¶ 1Crime No. 362/2026 at Annapoorneshwari Nagar Police Station and Section 5A of the Medicare Act are referred to in the prayers.
¶ 1(d)The petition arose from untoward incidents at the hospital premises.
¶ 2The court had earlier, by orders dated 02.11.2026 and 05.11.2026, directed the police to ensure that ingress and egress was not blocked, that the gathered mob was dispersed, and that medical services were not disrupted.
¶ 2The parties jointly submitted that access was free, no mob was gathering, and services were functioning.
¶ 3Counsel for private respondents (R7–R8) contended that the parents' queries regarding the child's deteriorated condition, after admission for a minor ailment, had not been adequately addressed.
¶ 4The learned AGA requested that the petitioner pay for police deployment.
¶ 5The petitioner submitted that services had not presently been disrupted.
¶ 602Issues
i.1. Whether, in light of the compliance with the earlier interim orders and the absence of any current disruption, the petitioner's prayers for police protection and directions to the police warrant any further mandamus or directions.
¶ 3, 6, 7, 11ii.2. Whether the pending proceedings before the Karnataka Medical Council and other authorities, and the rights concerning police deployment charges, should be kept open or adjudicated in this writ petition.
¶ 8, 9, 1003Law Applied
The court relied on its own interim orders dated 02.11.2026 and 05.11.2026, which required police to ensure free ingress and egress, disperse any mob and prevent disruption of medical services.
¶ 2The petition was invoked under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, which govern the High Court's writ and supervisory jurisdiction.
The court referred to the Karnataka Medical Council's jurisdiction over the complaint, which it directed to continue.
¶ 8The court recognised the police's statutory authority to seek payment for deployment of personnel, to be exercised in accordance with law.
¶ 9Provisions in the judgment · 1
Companies Act, 1956 Section 5A
04Reasoning
Because the parties jointly reported that access was unobstructed, no mob was present and services were operating, the court found no live grievance requiring affirmative mandamus.
¶ 3, 6Instead of granting the prayers, the court held that the petitioner could approach the concerned authorities for assistance in any future situation, which would be addressed according to its gravity.
¶ 7The court left the Medical Council proceedings and the parents' grievances to be adjudicated in the forum where they were pending.
¶ 8On the AGA's request for deployment charges, the court held that the police could communicate a demand in accordance with law, and the petitioner could accede to or respond to it.
¶ 9The court declined to pass further orders on the directions sought, including those on Crime No. 362/2026 and Section 5A, as the matter was resolved by the parties' undertakings and the existing interim directions. The order does not record any adjudication on these matters.
¶ 11The reasoning rests on the factual position as it stood at the hearing, with no findings on the merits of the incidents.
05Holding
Given the compliance with its earlier orders and the absence of any present obstruction or disruption, no further orders were required.
¶ 3, 6, 11The petitioner may seek police assistance from the concerned authorities for any future situation, to be addressed according to its gravity.
¶ 7Proceedings before the Karnataka Medical Council and other authorities shall continue, with all rights open.
¶ 8, 10The official respondents may communicate any demand for expenses of police deployment, which the petitioner may accept or contest in accordance with law.
¶ 9, 10Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of. No mandamus was issued on the prayers (a)–(e), and the writ petition is disposed of.
¶ 11–13Original Court PDF
M/S KIDS CLINIC INDIA LIMITEDvsSTATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
