01Facts
The petitioner challenged two Orders-in-Original under Section 73 of the Finance Act for tax period 2015-16: Order No. 29/2023-24 dated 29.09.2023 (Annexure A1) and Order No. 75/2023-24 dated 27.12.2023 (Annexure A2).
p. 4The petitioner also challenged a Recovery Notice dated 14.11.2025 under Section 87 directed to Canara Bank (Annexure A3).
p. 4The petitioner's counsel contended that the proceedings were based on information furnished by the Central Board of Direct Taxes under a Memorandum of Agreement, and that the petitioner's services were covered by Notification No. 25/2012 dated 20.06.2012.
¶ 2 · p. 5Counsel submitted that no Show Cause Notice for FY 2015-16 was served.
¶ 3 · pp. 5-6The petitioner's representative had appeared and filed documents, including Work Orders, in response to a Show Cause Notice for FY 2016-17, without being informed of the 2015-16 proceedings. The petitioner bona fide believed these documents sufficed.
¶ 3 · pp. 5-6The respondents contended that the petitioner may have a grievance regarding non-service of the 2015-16 notice, but not regarding lack of opportunity for the subsequent period, since the petitioner had produced documents and could have produced more.
¶ 4 · pp. 6-702Issues
i.1. Whether the Orders-in-Original dated 29.09.2023 and 27.12.2023 and the Recovery Notice dated 14.11.2025 should be quashed and the proceedings restored to the adjudicating authority for reconsideration, with liberty to file a further response to the show cause notices.
¶ 1 · pp. 4-5ii.2. Whether non-service of the Show Cause Notice for FY 2015-16, together with the petitioner's bona fide belief that the documents filed would suffice, warrants interference under Articles 226 and 227.
¶ 3-5 · pp. 5-8iii.3. Whether the petitioner's willingness to produce the Work Orders covering the entire transaction, and the decision in Karnataka Chinmaya Seva Trust, justify interference.
¶ 5 · p. 803Law Applied
The petition was filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, and the impugned orders were passed under Section 73 (demand of service tax) and Section 87 (recovery) of the Finance Act.
p. 4The petitioner's substantive defence rested on Notification No. 25/2012 dated 20.06.2012, which covers services that the petitioner claimed fell within the exemption from service tax.
¶ 2 · p. 5The Court relied on the Co-ordinate Bench decision in M/s. Karnataka Chinmaya Seva Trust v. Joint Commissioner of Central Tax, W.P. No. 11154/2023 (dated 03.07.2024), which addressed proceedings founded on CBDT-furnished information under a Memorandum of Agreement and the applicability of the same notification, and which the Court treated as persuasive for interference in similar circumstances.
¶ 2 and 5 · p. 5, 8The Court treated the non-service of a show cause notice and the petitioner's bona fides as grounds for restoring proceedings.
¶ 5 · p. 8Provisions in the judgment · 2
Finance Act, 1996 Section 73
Finance Act, 1994 Section 87
04Reasoning
The Court did not decide the merits of the tax liability. It accepted that the circumstances, taken together, formed "an amalgam of reasons" warranting relief.
¶ 5 · p. 8The first factor was the petitioner's non-service of the show cause notice for FY 2015-16. The second was the petitioner's bona fide belief that the Work Orders filed in response to the FY 2016-17 notice would suffice to establish the Notification No. 25/2012 exemption. The third was the petitioner's willingness to produce the Work Orders covering the entire transaction under tax.
¶ 3-5 · pp. 5-8The Court also relied on its earlier interference in Karnataka Chinmaya Seva Trust in similar circumstances. The respondents' argument that the petitioner had adequate opportunity for FY 2016-17 was not separately adjudicated.
¶ 5 · p. 8The Court instead quashed all three impugned instruments and restored the matter in full. The order does not separately analyse the two assessment periods, and it does not explain how the 27.12.2023 order relates to the 29.09.2023 order. The Court resolved the matter by remand for fresh consideration on a complete record rather than on the merits.
¶ 5 · p. 805Holding
The Court held that the petition is allowed in part. The Orders-in-Original dated 29.09.2023 (A1) and 27.12.2023 (A2), and the Recovery Notice dated 14.11.2025 (A3), are quashed, and the proceedings are restored to the first respondent (Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax) for reconsideration.
¶ A-B · p. 8The petitioner must appear before the first respondent without further notice by 07.12.2026. On the first appearance, the petitioner may seek copies of the Show Cause Notice relevant to FY 2015-16, and shall be granted a reasonable period to file a response. The petitioner's prayer for a direction to supply the show cause notice is thus effectively granted through this mechanism. The petition is not disposed of on the merits of the demand.
¶ C-D · pp. 8-9Original Court PDF
SHRI HARISH M RvsTHE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL TAX
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
