01Facts
The Appellant, an electricity distribution licensee, supplied electricity to Impex Metal & Ferro Alloys Ltd., the Corporate Debtor, during its CIRP.
¶ 3–12The Corporate Debtor consumed electricity between 1 March 2018 and 24 April 2019, resulting in outstanding consumption charges of ₹20,72,84,722, which the Appellant claimed as CIRP costs under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
¶ 3–12The Appellant filed I.A. No. 1061 of 2021 seeking payment of the outstanding electricity charges. That application was dismissed for non-prosecution on 8 November 2023 because the Appellant’s counsel was absent.
¶ 13The Appellant subsequently filed I.A. No. 1570 of 2024 seeking recall/restoration of I.A. No. 1061 of 2021.
¶ 15–19, 22–29The NCLT rejected the restoration application on 13 November 2025, holding that it was filed beyond the thirty-day period contemplated under Rule 48(2) of the NCLT Rules, 2016.
¶ 20–2102Issues
i.Whether the Appellant’s restoration application could be rejected solely because it was filed beyond the thirty-day period under Rule 48(2) of the NCLT Rules, 2016, despite the explanation that the delay resulted from the earlier counsel’s deliberate non-appearance and failure to provide an NOC?
¶ 21–29, 35–52ii.Whether a litigant should be made to suffer for the deliberate or negligent non-appearance of its counsel, resulting in dismissal of its application for non-prosecution?
¶ 23–30, 35, 48–49iii.Whether the Appellant was legally required to obtain the previous counsel’s consent/NOC before engaging a new counsel, and whether the absence of such consent justified the delay in seeking restoration?
¶ 27–34iv.Whether I.A. No. 1061 of 2021, concerning electricity charges allegedly incurred during CIRP, should be restored for adjudication on merits?
¶ 7–12, 51–5203Law Applied
The Court applied Section 14(2) and Section 14(2A) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, under which essential supplies and supplies necessary for preserving the Corporate Debtor as a going concern generally cannot be terminated during moratorium, subject to payment of post-commencement dues.
¶ 4–5It considered Rule 48(2) of the NCLT Rules, 2016, concerning restoration of applications dismissed for non-prosecution, and held that the thirty-day period was not an absolute bar where the delay could be considered under Section 238A of the Code read with Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
¶ 41–47, 51–52Rule 39 of the Bar Council of India Rules requires a subsequent advocate to obtain the earlier advocate’s consent or seek the court’s permission before entering appearance where a vakalatnama is already on record.
¶ 27–29Order III Rule 4 CPC was relied upon for the principle that a vakalatnama continues until determined by the client or advocate with the leave of the court.
¶ 32–34The Court relied on Rafiq v. Munshilal, (1981) 2 SCC 788, for the principle that an innocent litigant should not suffer because of the advocate’s default.
¶ 30The Court relied on Metalrod Pvt. Ltd. v. Harshit Finvest Pvt. Ltd., (2025) ibclaw.in 563, regarding the applicability of Article 137 and the Tribunal’s inherent powers in restoration matters.
¶ 35Provisions in the judgment · 12 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Electricity Act, 2003 Section 2
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. Section 3Section 5Section 7Section 14Section 53Section 61
Advocates Act, 1961 Section 49
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 144Section 152
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 137Section 5
04Reasoning
The NCLAT held that the dismissal of I.A. No. 1061 of 2021 was not a decision on merits but a dismissal for non-prosecution resulting from counsel’s absence.
¶ 13–14, 50–51The record indicated that the earlier counsel had not personally appeared for several dates and had allegedly withdrawn from effectively pursuing the matter without informing the Appellant.
¶ 23–26In these circumstances, the Appellant’s reliance on Rafiq was justified, since a litigant who has engaged counsel and entrusted the matter to him cannot ordinarily be expected to monitor every listing or compel counsel to appear.
¶ 30The Court further held that the Appellant’s explanation regarding the delayed restoration was sufficient.
Rule 39 of the Bar Council of India Rules and Order III Rule 4 CPC created a practical impediment to immediately engaging new counsel without obtaining the earlier counsel’s consent or seeking leave of the Tribunal.
¶ 27–34The delay therefore had to be assessed with reference to the circumstances, rather than mechanically applying Rule 48(2).
Section 238A, read with Section 5 of the Limitation Act, empowered the Tribunal to condone the delay where sufficient cause was shown, particularly because the underlying application had not been adjudicated on merits.
¶ 41–47, 50–52The Court concluded that the alleged deliberate conduct of the earlier counsel constituted sufficient cause and that the Appellant should not lose its substantive claim merely because of that conduct.
¶ 48–4905Holding
The appeal was allowed.
¶ 52The NCLAT quashed the NCLT’s order dated 13 November 2025, recalled the order dated 8 November 2023 dismissing I.A. No. 1061 of 2021 for non-prosecution, and allowed I.A. No. 1570 of 2024.
¶ 52I.A. No. 1061 of 2021 was directed to be considered by the NCLT on its own merits, including the Appellant’s claim for ₹20,72,84,722 towards electricity consumed during the CIRP.
¶ 52All pending interlocutory applications were closed.
¶ 52Original Court PDF
Eastern Power Distribution Company Of Andhra Pradesh LimitedvsTripti Agarwal Liquidator Of Implex Metal & Ferro Alloys Limited
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
