01Facts
On 13.06.2018 at about 8.00 a.m., the deceased Kumar was a pillion rider on a TVS Victor two-wheeler (PY 02 C 8579) on the Poonthottam–Thiruvarur main road, near Poonthottam petrol bunk, when a Government of Tamil Nadu Police Department Mahindra Bolero LX (TN 50 G 0462) driven by its driver allegedly struck it.
p. 2He sustained a head injury, was taken to hospital, and died en route.
p. 2The claimants, the widow (R1), two minor daughters (R2, R3), and parents (R4, R5), sought Rs.20,00,000 as compensation, pleading that the deceased, aged about 44, earned Rs.20,000 per month as a plumber-cum-agriculturist.
p. 2The appellant denied the manner of accident, alleging that the two-wheeler carried three persons and was ridden rashly.
p. 3The claimants examined P.W.1 (the first claimant) and P.W.2 (an eyewitness) and marked Ex.P1 to P6. The respondents examined R.W.1 and R.W.2 and marked no documents.
p. 3The Tribunal held the Bolero driver 90% negligent and the deceased 10% negligent, on the basis of the FIR and P.W.1's admission that three persons rode the motorcycle.
p. 3The Tribunal assessed monthly income at Rs.9,000 (no income proof), age at 42 (per Ex.P4), added 25% future prospects, deducted 1/4 for personal expenses, applied multiplier 14, and awarded Rs.17,49,500 in total, less 10% contributory negligence, for a net Rs.15,74,550.
pp. 3–4The appellant challenged the negligence apportionment and quantum.
p. 5, 702Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal correctly apportioned negligence at 90% against the Bolero driver and 10% against the deceased, where three persons were riding the two-wheeler.
p. 5 / para. 7 · pp. 6–7 / para. 10ii.2. Whether the Tribunal correctly assessed the deceased's notional monthly income at Rs.9,000 in the absence of documentary proof, and the resultant loss of dependency.
p. 5 / para. 7 · pp. 7–8 / para. 11iii.3. Whether the awards under loss of consortium, loss of love and affection, and filial consortium were excessive and required reduction.
p. 5 / para. 7 · p. 8 / para. 1203Law Applied
The court applied Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, as the appellate provision.
p. 1On quantum, the court relied on National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017), which permits 25% future prospects for a deceased aged 40–50 with a permanent job.
p. 4 / para. 5 · p. 7 / para. 11The court followed Sarala Varma v. Delhi Transport Corporation (2009) for the multiplier of 14 applicable at age 42.
p. 4 · p. 7 / para. 11For non-pecuniary heads, the court relied on Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram (2018), which fixes conventional amounts for consortium, filial consortium and loss of love and affection.
p. 8 / para. 12On liability, the court relied on the principle that carrying more persons than the two-wheeler is designed for, contrary to the Traffic Rules, constitutes contributory negligence by the rider or pillion rider, supported by the FIR and oral evidence.
pp. 6–7 / para. 10Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173
04Reasoning
On negligence, the court accepted P.W.2's eyewitness account and the FIR registered against the Bolero driver as establishing the driver's rash and negligent driving.
p. 6 / para. 10The court then found that P.W.1's admission and the FIR both showed three persons on a two-wheeler built for two, which made loss of control likely and justified 10% contributory negligence. It rejected the appellant's plea for a higher share on the deceased's part.
pp. 6–7 / para. 10On income, the court accepted the Tribunal's Rs.9,000 figure because the claimants produced no documents to prove the pleaded Rs.20,000. It upheld the Pranay Sethi and Sarala Varma computations as correct.
p. 7 / para. 11Applying Magma General, the court held that the Tribunal's Rs.1,00,000 awards for consortium, filial consortium and love and affection were excessive. It reduced spousal consortium to Rs.40,000, parental filial consortium to Rs.40,000 each, and love and affection to Rs.40,000 per daughter. Other heads (funeral, loss of estate, transport, clothing) were left undisturbed.
p. 8 / para. 12The revised table yields Rs.16,49,500 gross and, after 10% deduction, Rs.14,84,550. The court did not address the discrepancy between the pleaded age of 44 and the age of 42 adopted from Ex.P4.
p. 9 · p. 2 · p. 305Holding
The court affirmed the 90:10 negligence apportionment and the Rs.9,000 notional income, multiplier of 14, and loss of dependency of Rs.14,17,500.
pp. 7–8 / para. 11The appeal is partly allowed. The court reduced the non-pecuniary awards under the Magma General standard, and the total compensation is reduced from Rs.15,74,550 to Rs.14,84,550, with interest at 7.5% p.a. from the date of filing the claim petition until deposit.
p. 8 / para. 12 · p. 9 · p. 10 / para. 13The appellant must deposit the amount, with interest and costs, within six weeks of receiving a copy of the judgment, to the credit of M.C.O.P. No. 85 of 2019. The claimants may then withdraw the award per the Tribunal's apportionment, with the Tribunal's disbursement directions remaining unaltered. No order as to costs.
p. 10 / para. 13Original Court PDF
THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICEvsGOMATHI
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
