01Facts
The petitioner challenged Order-in-Original No. 100/2025-GST (Supdt-R-II) dated 07.10.2025 for the tax period 2018-19 and sought its quashing under Article 226 [p.1].
p. 1The petitioner's counsel contended that the respondent uploaded all notices under the "View Additional Notices and Orders" tab on the GST common portal. The petitioner was unaware of these notices and therefore did not reply in time, and the impugned order was passed without a personal hearing [para. 3].
¶ 3The petitioner undertook to pay 25% of the disputed tax and sought an opportunity to contest the matter [para. 4].
¶ 4The respondent's counsel stated that notices were uploaded on the portal, but fairly admitted that no personal hearing was granted before the impugned order was passed, and sought remand subject to the 25% payment [para. 5].
¶ 5The Court noted that the show cause notice was uploaded on the portal, that the original was not furnished to the petitioner, and that the assessment order confirmed the show cause proposals without affording a personal hearing [para. 7].
¶ 702Issues
i.1. Whether service of a show cause notice solely by uploading it on the GST portal constitutes effective service where the assessee was unaware of it and the officer did not explore other statutory modes of service [para. 7–9].
¶ 7–9ii.2. Whether an ex parte order passed without a personal hearing, following non-effective service, is liable to be set aside and remanded subject to pre-deposit of 25% of the disputed tax [para. 8–10].
¶ 8–10iii.3. Whether the attachment of the petitioner's bank account survives once the impugned order is set aside [para. 10(iv)].
¶ 10(iv)03Law Applied
The Court held that uploading a notice on the GST portal is sufficient service under the Act [para. 8].
¶ 8Where the assessee does not respond, the proper officer must apply his mind and explore other valid modes of service prescribed under Section 169 of the CGST Act, preferably by RPAD, failing which service is not effective and the proceedings amount to an empty formality [para. 8–9].
¶ 8–9An order passed ex parte without a personal hearing, after ineffective service, cannot stand, and the Court exercised its Article 226 writ jurisdiction to remand the matter for fresh consideration on conditions [para. 10].
¶ 10No statutory provision or precedent was expressly cited for the 25% pre-deposit condition, which was imposed on the basis of the petitioner's undertaking and the respondent's consent [para. 4–5, 10] [no citation].
¶ 4–5, 10 · no citationThe Court treated the bank attachment as dependent on the continued existence of the impugned order [para. 10(iv)].
¶ 10(iv)Provisions in the judgment · 1
Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 Section 169
04Reasoning
The Court accepted that portal upload is a valid mode of service but found that the officer, faced with repeated non-responses, failed to attempt other modes under Section 169 [para. 8].
¶ 8This lack of effort rendered the service ineffective in substance, so the ex parte order based on it was a formality that would only generate avoidable litigation [para. 8–9].
¶ 8–9The respondent's concession that no personal hearing was granted confirmed the procedural defect [para. 5, 7].
¶ 5, 7Because the defect went to the root of the adjudication, the Court set aside the order rather than relieving the petitioner on merits [para. 10].
¶ 10To balance the petitioner's right to be heard with the revenue's interest, the Court made remand conditional on payment of 25% of the disputed tax, which the petitioner had offered [para. 4, 10].
¶ 4, 10Once the impugned order was set aside, the attachment founded on it could not survive, and the Court directed its lifting upon proof of payment [para. 10(iv)].
¶ 10(iv)05Holding
The Court held that portal-only service of the show cause notice, without exploring other modes under Section 169 after repeated non-response, was not effective, and that the ex parte order passed without a personal hearing could not be sustained [para. 8–10].
¶ 8–10The writ petition was disposed of with the following directions: (i) the impugned order dated 07.10.2025 is set aside and the matter remanded, conditional on payment of 25% of the disputed tax within four weeks of receipt of the order, with the setting aside effective from the date of payment [para. 10(i)]; (ii) the petitioner must file a reply within three weeks of payment [para. 10(ii)]; (iii) the respondent must issue a 14-day clear notice fixing a personal hearing and pass a fresh order on merits, as expeditiously as possible [para. 10(iii)]; (iv) the bank is directed to de-freeze the petitioner's account upon production of proof of payment and a copy of the order [para. 10(iv)]. WMP No. 51187 of 2026 was allowed, and no costs were awarded [para. 11].
¶ 10(i)–(iv) · ¶ 11Original Court PDF
M/S.HYBRID SOLUTIONS INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED,vsThe Superintendent of GST and C.Ex,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
