01Facts
The appellants (Owners) entered into a collaboration agreement on 09.04.2010 with the respondents' predecessor (Builder) for the reconstruction of a building
¶ 4Clause 7 stipulated completion within 12 months (plus a 2-month grace period) from the date of providing vacant land, failing which a penalty of ₹10,000/- per day was payable
¶ 5The Builder abandoned construction in August 2011, having paid only ₹45 lakh of the ₹64 lakh earnest money
¶ 6The Owners terminated the agreement on 11.11.2011
¶ 6An Arbitrator found the Builder in breach and awarded the Owners ₹72 lakh in penalties but directed the refund of the Builder's ₹45 lakh earnest money and ₹36.92 lakh construction costs
¶ 8A Single Judge of the High Court modified the penalty amount under Section 34
¶ 10On appeal under Section 37, the Division Bench set aside the Owners' penalty entirely, holding they failed to prove actual damages
¶ 1102Issues
i.1. Whether the court has the power to modify an arbitral award under Sections 34 and 37 of the Arbitration Act
¶ 14ii.2. Whether the Owners were required to adduce separate evidence of actual loss to claim a contractually stipulated penalty under Clause 7
¶ 19iii.3. Whether the computation of the "delayed period" for penalty must align with the date vacant land was provided and the date of termination
¶ 17-1803Law Applied
The Court applied the principles governing Sections 34 and 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, specifically the ground of "patent illegality" under Section 34(2A)
¶ 14It relied on the Constitution Bench precedent in Gayatri Balasamy v. ISG Novasoft Technologies Limited (2025), which established that Courts possess a nuanced power to modify awards—rather than just annulling them—to prevent hardship and delay
¶ 14The court also invoked Article 142 of the Constitution of India to do substantial justice and provide a quietus to long-standing litigation
¶ 24Provisions in the judgment · 1
Arbitration And Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 9, 34, 37
04Reasoning
The Court found the Arbitrator’s and lower courts' computations factually flawed. Under Clause 7, the 12-month clock only started when "vacant land" was provided; as the Builder’s uncontroverted evidence showed demolition took until 09.07.2010, the 14-month completion period expired on 09.09.2011
¶ 17The Court held the Division Bench erred in requiring proof of actual loss; since the contract stipulated a daily penalty for delay, damage was "implicit," and separate evidence was unnecessary
¶ 19However, the penalty could only run until the date the Owners terminated the contract (11.11.2011), as the Builder could not legally continue work thereafter
¶ 18While the Arbitrator’s failure to allow forfeiture under Clause 13 (breach) alongside Clause 7 (delay) was a "patent illegality," the Owners' failure to challenge the award under Section 34 made that finding final
¶ 12, 2105Holding
The Supreme Court set aside the Division Bench's judgment and modified the award using its powers under Article 142. It held that the Owners are entitled to a penalty of ₹6,30,000/- (63 days from 09.09.2011 to 11.11.2011)
¶ 18, 24-25The Respondents/Builder are entitled to a refund of ₹81,92,400/- (earnest money and construction costs) as previously awarded and unchallenged. After offsetting the penalty, the Appellants must pay the Respondents a balance of ₹25,62,400/- (accounting for ₹50 lakh already deposited); and no interest is payable to either party.
¶ 25Original Court PDF
Bhupesh BhayanavsKunal Seth
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
