CAT - Ernakulam

Original Application Rendered Infructuous by Partial Cancellation of Transfer Order.

Anwer Hussain K.K. v. Union of India [Original Application No. 181/00492/2025]

CAT - Ernakulam1 MIN READSOURCE JUDGMENT
THE ORIGINAL LAWLENS SUMMARY
01

Facts

Anwer Hussain K.K., a Mechanic Grade A, challenged a transfer order (Annexure A3) issued by the 4th respondent

Source reference: p.3

The Original Application was filed in response to this order

Source reference: p.2

During the hearing, the learned Standing Counsel for the Lakshadweep Administration presented a corrigendum dated February 13, 2026, issued by the Director (Industries), which partially cancelled the Annexure A3 order to the extent of transferring the applicant

Source reference: p.2
02

Issues

Whether the Original Application challenging the transfer order had become infructuous due to the partial cancellation of the transfer order by the administration

Source reference: p.2
03

Law Applied

The court applied the principle that an application becomes infructuous when the underlying cause of action or the relief sought has been nullified or rendered unnecessary by subsequent events

Source reference: p.2
04

Reasoning

Upon the production of the corrigendum dated February 13, 2026, which cancelled the applicant's transfer as per Annexure A3, the very basis of the Original Application ceased to exist

Source reference: p.2

The learned Counsel for the applicant explicitly confirmed that, in light of this development, the O.A. had become infructuous

Source reference: p.2

This established that the relief sought by the applicant, which was to challenge the transfer, was no longer required as the transfer itself had been cancelled by the respondent's own action

Source reference: p.2
05

Holding

The Tribunal concluded that the Original Application had become infructuous due to the issuance of the corrigendum cancelling the applicant's transfer

Accordingly, the Original Application was closed with no order as to costs

Source reference: p.2
CAT - Ernakulam

Original Court PDF

Anwer Hussain K.K. v. Union of India [Original Application No. 181/00492/2025]

CAT - Ernakulam

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment