01Facts
The applicant, an ST Loco Pilot (Goods) at Nizamuddin Railway Station, Northern Railway, sought selection to the post of Chief Loco Inspector.
¶ 1His candidature was rejected on the ground that he lacked the prescribed 10 years of qualifying service as Loco Pilot (Goods).
¶ 1The rejection relied on Railway Board Circular dated 21.03.2006 (RBE No. 34/2006), which limits the counting of past service in a previous unit to the length of service of the applicant's immediate senior in the new unit.
¶ 1The applicant relied on Raghubir Singh v. Union of India (OA No. 1755/2009, PB, decided 23.11.2009) and on OA No. 772/2016 (Jabalpur Bench, decided 29.03.2019), which had followed Raghubir Singh.
¶ 2The respondents contended that the applicant had not completed the requisite 5 lakh km of footplate duties and that his immediate senior had only 7 years and 10 months of service.
¶ 3The impugned communication dated 22.08.2024 rejected the applicant's candidature.
¶ 702Issues
i.1. Whether past service rendered by the applicant in his previous unit, after transfer on his own request and consequent placement at the bottom of the seniority list, can be counted for determining eligibility for promotion.
¶ 5ii.2. Whether the respondents were justified in restricting the applicant's past service through the condition in Railway Board Circular dated 21.03.2006 (RBE No. 34/2006).
¶ 603Law Applied
The Tribunal relied on the Supreme Court decisions in Renu Mallick (Smt.) v. Union of India, (1994) 1 SCC 373, and Union of India v. C.N. Ponnappan, (1996) 1 SCC 524, as considered in OA No. 772/2016.
¶ 5The Principal Bench decision in Raghubir Singh (supra) holds that the entire service rendered in the old unit must be counted for eligibility, and that a candidature cannot be rejected for lack of qualifying service where selection is open to all eligible employees on merit through written examination and screening of records rather than seniority.
¶ 5, quoting OA No. 772/2016 · ¶ 13-14The Jabalpur Bench's quashing of RBE No. 34/2006 is treated as binding in effect, so that reliance on the circular is illegal.
¶ 6The principle of judicial discipline requires the Tribunal not to take a divergent view from the earlier decision.
¶ 704Reasoning
The Tribunal found that the issue was already settled by OA No. 772/2016, which had considered Renu Mallick, Ponnappan and Raghubir Singh.
¶ 5The selection in question was made by inviting applications from all eligible candidates and was based on merit, through a written examination and screening of service records, with seniority not being the basis for promotion.
¶ 5On that footing, the restriction under RBE No. 34/2006 had no application, and the respondents erred in limiting the applicant's past service to his immediate senior's length of service.
¶ 6Because the circular had been quashed, its continued use rendered the rejection illegal.
¶ 6The Tribunal did not decide whether the applicant met the 5 lakh km footplate requirement or other eligibility conditions, leaving those questions for the review selection process.
¶ 705Holding
The respondents were not justified in restricting the applicant's past service under RBE No. 34/2006, and his service must be counted in accordance with Raghubir Singh and OA No. 772/2016.
¶ 6 · ¶ 7The OA is allowed. The communication dated 22.08.2024 is set aside. The respondents must consider the applicant's candidature for Chief Loco Inspector by counting his previous-unit service and decide through a review selection process within 60 days of receipt of a certified copy of the order. If found eligible and fit, the applicant is to be given the benefit of selection from the date on which the other selected candidates were appointed, with consequential benefits but no interest. Pending MAs are disposed of, and no costs are awarded.
¶ 7 · ¶ 8Original Court PDF
MUKESH MEENAvsNORTHERN RAILWAY
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![Past service rendered in a previous unit, despite transfer on request, must be counted for promotion eligibility.. MUKESH MEENA vs NORTHERN RAILWAY. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/past-service-rendered-in-a-previous-unit-despite-transfer-on-request-must-be-counted-for-p-539eb6f922d54627b02f72738a782c6a.webp)