01Facts
The appellant, an officer of the Punjab and Sind Bank, was served a charge sheet on 30.09.2011 regarding irregularities in loan disbursements
¶ 3(i)On the same day, the appellant superannuated from service
¶ 3(ii)Despite his retirement, the bank continued disciplinary proceedings under the Punjab and Sind Bank Officers’ Service Regulations, 1982.
¶ 3(ii)On 15.06.2013, the Disciplinary Authority found Charge No. 2 (failure to ensure end-use of loan) partly proved and imposed a punishment of reduction by three stages in the time scale of pay on a permanent basis
¶ 3(ii)The Appellate Authority upheld this on 19.04.2014
¶ 3(iii)A Single Judge of the High Court set aside the punishment, holding that only penalties under the Pension Regulations, 1995, could be imposed post-retirement
¶ 3(v)However, the Division Bench reversed this decision, ruling that Service Regulations permitted the continuation and conclusion of proceedings initiated prior to retirement
¶ 3(vii)02Issues
i.1. Whether, post-retirement, the punishment of reduction of three stages in the scale of pay was permissible under the Service Regulations, or if action was restricted to the Pension Regulations.
¶ 13(i)ii.2. Whether there was any perversity or infirmity in the inquiry report and disciplinary orders, and whether such grounds could be raised if not pressed before the High Court.
¶ 13(ii)03Law Applied
Regulation 20(3)(iii) of the Punjab and Sind Bank Officers’ Service Regulations, 1982, which creates a legal fiction that an officer against whom proceedings were initiated prior to superannuation remains in service until the proceedings are concluded
¶ 25Chairman-Cum-Managing Director, Mahanadi Coalfields Limited v. Rabindranath Choubey (2020) 18 SCC 71, which established that disciplinary proceedings initiated during service can be brought to a logical conclusion, including the imposition of major penalties like dismissal, post-retirement
¶ 32, 34Ramesh Chandra Sharma v. Punjab National Bank (2007) 9 SCC 15, confirming that statutory service regulations and pension regulations must be read in conjunction to give effect to the legal fiction of continued service
¶ 29Provisions in the judgment · 2
PAYMENT OF GRATUITY ACT, 1972 Section 4Section 7
04Reasoning
The Court first addressed the merits, noting that the appellant failed to challenge the factual finding that huge cash withdrawals were permitted without supporting bills, which evidenced a failure to ensure the "end-use" of the loan
¶ 16, 18The Court emphasized that bank officers hold positions of trust, and any financial irregularity—even without proof of actual loss—constitutes serious misconduct
¶ 19-20Regarding the legality of the punishment, the Court held that Regulation 20(3)(iii) provides a clear mandate for proceedings to continue as if the officer were still in service
¶ 36While the appellant argued that only the Pension Regulations (allowing for withholding/recovery of pension) applied, the Court reasoned that since pension is computed based on the "salary last drawn or payable," a punishment reducing the pay scale "relates back" to the date of superannuation and is practically implementable
¶ 37The Court distinguished Prabhakar Sadashiv Karvade on the grounds that in that case, the charge sheet was served after retirement, whereas here, the proceedings were initiated during service
¶ 9, 3605Holding
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court
¶ 39It held that disciplinary proceedings initiated prior to retirement can be concluded post-superannuation under the Service Regulations due to the legal fiction of continued service
¶ 36, 38The Court specifically ruled that the punishment of reduction in pay scale is permissible and implementable post-retirement as it directly affects the computation of the appellant's pensionary benefits
¶ 37No perversity was found in the inquiry report, and the punishment was held not to be shockingly disproportionate
¶ 22Original Court PDF
Virinder Pal SinghvsPunjab And Sind Bank
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
