Jharkhand High CourtCriminal LawConstitutional Law

Prayag Group Directors Get Bail After About 40 Months in Custody Across Cases, With Charges Yet to Be Framed

BASUDEB BAGCHIv.DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT, GOVT OF INDIA THROUGH ITS ASSISTANT DIRECTOR

Prayag Group Directors Get Bail After About 40 Months in Custody Across Cases, With Charges Yet to Be Framed. BASUDEB BAGCHI vs DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT, GOVT OF INDIA THROUGH ITS ASSISTANT DIRECTOR. Jharkhand High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the twin conditions under Section 45(1) PMLA can justify continued pre-trial detention where the petitioners were not arrested during investigation, the trial is unlikely to conclude soon, and the evidence is predominantly documentary.

The court held

The rigours of Section 45 PMLA cannot eclipse Article 21, and the present case is fit for bail given the custody undergone, the documentary nature of the evidence, the attachment of assets, and the remote prospect of an early trial.

It also directed

The Court allowed the bail application. The petitioners are to be released on bonds of Rs. 1,00,000 each with two sureties of the like amount each, to the satisfaction of the Special Judge, PMLA, Ranchi, in ECIR Case No. 01 of 2019. Conditions include surrender of passports, with release subject to application to the trial court; no tampering with evidence or inducement to witnesses; appearance on every date unless exempted; no conduct prejudicial to a fair and expeditious trial; and no similar offence in future. The observations are prima facie for bail only and do not bind the trial court on the merits.

01Facts

The Directorate of Enforcement (ED), Ranchi Sub-Zonal Office, registered ECIR No. RNSZO/01/2016 on 14.09.2016 based on three CBI FIRs (RC 8(A)/2015-D, RC 7(A)/2015-D, RC 8(S)/2015-R, all dated 30.06.2015) against the Prayag Group companies and their promoters.

¶ 48–49

The ED alleged that the companies collected about Rs. 2,862.84 crores from about 38.71 lakh investors, repaid about Rs. 1,140.26 crores, and left an outstanding liability of about Rs. 1,906.22 crores as on 31.03.2016.

¶ 50

A prosecution complaint dated 22.05.2019 was filed under Sections 44 and 45 PMLA, and cognizance was taken the same day.

¶ 50–51

The petitioners, Basudeb Bagchi (aged about 69–70) and Avik Bagchi, were not arrested during the investigation.

¶ 58, 85

The petitioners sought exemption from appearance, which was rejected on 18.07.2019; non-bailable warrants were issued on 13.08.2019; anticipatory bail was rejected on 03.10.2019, and proceedings under Sections 82–83 CrPC followed.

¶ 52–53

The High Court quashed the first proclamation process on 24.06.2020 with a direction to pass fresh orders.

¶ 54, 80

The petitioners were arrested in ECIR No. KLZO-I/15/2024 (Kolkata) on 26.11.2024 and remained in judicial custody there.

¶ 80

On 30.03.2026 the petitioners sought a production warrant before the Special Court, disclosing that custody.

¶ 54

On 11.05.2026 the Special Court rejected their application for recall of process and release on bond, granted liberty to seek regular bail, and remanded them to judicial custody.

¶ 55

The Supreme Court granted the petitioners regular bail in the Kolkata ECIR on 24.07.2026 (SLP (Crl.) No. 7613 of 2026), noting incarceration of about 40 months, transactions from 2013–14, and no likelihood of early conclusion of trial.

¶ 59–60

The Special Judge, PMLA, Ranchi rejected the petitioners' regular bail on 28.08.2026, prompting the present application.

¶ 13

No charge-sheet has been filed in the predicate FIRs after about eleven years; charges have not been framed; 19 witnesses and about 1,000 pages of RUDs are cited; the properties stand attached and the attachment was confirmed on 21.05.2026.

¶ 64, 66, 63, 89–90

02Issues

i.1. Whether the twin conditions under Section 45(1) PMLA can justify continued pre-trial detention where the petitioners were not arrested during investigation, the trial is unlikely to conclude soon, and the evidence is predominantly documentary.

¶ 18–19, 69, 75–77, 91–94

ii.2. Whether the petitioners' earlier non-appearance before the Special Court, and the ED's contention that it reflects a risk of absconding, disentitles them to bail.

¶ 78–81

iii.3. Whether the Supreme Court's bail order in the connected ECIR (Kolkata) and the aggregate pre-trial incarceration across successive ECIRs and predicate proceedings are relevant to bail in the present ECIR.

¶ 59–61, 82–84, 88

03Law Applied

The PMLA, 2002: Section 2(1)(u) (proceeds of crime), Section 3 (offence of money-laundering), Section 4 (punishment, maximum seven years), Section 24 (presumption), Section 45 (bail twin conditions), Section 50 (summons), Section 65 (CrPC applies subject to PMLA) and Section 71 (overriding effect).

¶ 22–31, 37–39, 45–46

Vijay Madanlal Choudhary v. Union of India (2022), applied for the interpretation of Section 3 and Section 45, including that Section 45 applies to bail under Section 439 CrPC and analogous proceedings.

¶ 33–34, 40, 43–44

Tarun Kumar v. ED (2023), applied on the mandatory nature of Section 45 conditions.

¶ 41–42

Gautam Kundu v. ED (2015), applied on the mandatory character of the Section 45 conditions.

¶ 45–46

Section 45 cannot override Article 21, and prolonged pre-trial incarceration without a realistic prospect of trial concluding cannot become punishment, drawn from Manish Sisodia v. ED (2024) read with V. Senthil Balaji v. ED (2024).

¶ 69–70, 75–77

Padam Chand Jain v. ED (SLP (Crl.) No. 17476 of 2024), which clarified Manish Sisodia and holds that predominantly documentary evidence already with the agency weighs against continued custody.

¶ 71–72

Vijay Nair v. ED (2024), Sanjay Sureka v. ED (2026), Anwar Dhebar v. ED (2025), and Arvind Walia v. ED (2026), which held that Section 45 cannot justify indefinite detention and granted bail to a 65-year-old accused.

¶ 73, 74, 67, 68

The Supreme Court's order of 24.07.2026 in the connected ECIR is a material circumstance, though not an automatic right to bail.

¶ 59–60, 82

Provisions in the judgment · 26 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 82Section 83Section 88Section 170Section 205Section 438Section 439

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 420Section 193Section 228

Prevention of Money-Laundering Act, 2002 14 provisionsSection 2Section 3Section 4Section 8Section 13Section 19Section 24Section 44Section 45Section 50Section 63Section 65Section 70Section 71

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 483Section 484

04Reasoning

The Court first set out the PMLA framework and the binding effect of Section 45 on bail applications under the CrPC/BNSS, and then held that Section 45 must be read subject to Article 21.

¶ 37–46, 69, 75

The petitioners were never arrested during the investigation, which concluded with a prosecution complaint in 2019.

¶ 80, 85–86

The trial has not begun: charges are not framed, 19 witnesses and about 1,000 pages of documents are cited, and the predicate FIRs have not produced a charge-sheet in about eleven years.

¶ 89–90, 93, 95

The evidence is largely documentary and already in the prosecution's custody, and nothing shows that further custody is needed for investigation or evidence preservation. The properties are under attachment, which reduces the risk of dissipation.

¶ 86, 93, 63

On the petitioners' non-appearance, the Court accepted that the ED's history was relevant but declined to treat it in isolation. It held that the petitioners could not be treated as absconders for Article 21 purposes, since the ED did not inform the Special Court of their custody in Kolkata, and the petitioners themselves sought a production warrant on 30.03.2026.

¶ 78–81

The Court treated the Supreme Court's bail order in the Kolkata ECIR as a material circumstance bearing on necessity and proportionality of detention, though not a binding determinative factor, and considered the overlap between the two ECIRs on the same transactions and the aggregate incarceration.

¶ 82–84, 88, 61, 65

The Court relied on the petitioners' compliance with bail conditions in other matters and their appearance in connected proceedings. The judgment does not expressly record a satisfaction under Section 45(1)(ii) that there are reasonable grounds to believe the petitioners are not guilty; the ground for relief rests on Article 21 and the absence of any realistic prospect of early trial.

¶ 62, 87–88, 91–94

05Holding

The rigours of Section 45 PMLA cannot eclipse Article 21, and the present case is fit for bail given the custody undergone, the documentary nature of the evidence, the attachment of assets, and the remote prospect of an early trial.

¶ 91–94

The Court allowed the bail application. The petitioners are to be released on bonds of Rs. 1,00,000 each with two sureties of the like amount each, to the satisfaction of the Special Judge, PMLA, Ranchi, in ECIR Case No. 01 of 2019. Conditions include surrender of passports, with release subject to application to the trial court; no tampering with evidence or inducement to witnesses; appearance on every date unless exempted; no conduct prejudicial to a fair and expeditious trial; and no similar offence in future. The observations are prima facie for bail only and do not bind the trial court on the merits.

¶ 96, 97(i)–(vi), 98
Jharkhand High Court

Original Court PDF

BASUDEB BAGCHIvsDIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT, GOVT OF INDIA THROUGH ITS ASSISTANT DIRECTOR

Jharkhand High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment