Facts
Govind, a Junior Assistant appointed on probation for two years, was transferred from the District Collector’s office, Balotra, to the Sub-divisional Officer’s office, Shergarh, by order dated 10 July 2026.
Source reference: p. 1–2The respondents did not relieve him because Note No. 3 to the transfer order stated that employees on probation or under suspension would not be relieved to join their new postings.
Source reference: p. 1–2After his writ petition was dismissed by the Single Judge on 17 September 2026, Govind filed this special appeal.
Source reference: p. 1–2Issues
Whether a probationer may be transferred to another place during the probation period.
Source reference: p. 2–3Whether the respondents could refuse to relieve Govind under Note No. 3 of the transfer order when the Rajasthan Service Rules, 1951 contain no prohibition on transferring a probationer.
Source reference: p. 3–4Law Applied
The Court held that, absent a statutory prohibition, the authorities cannot impose a condition contrary to law preventing a probationer from joining a transferred posting.
Source reference: p. 3–4It found no provision in the Rajasthan Service Rules, 1951 prohibiting the transfer of a probationer.
Source reference: p. 3–4The Court also relied on Monika v. State of Rajasthan, D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 601/2024, decided 16 July 2024, which held that a probationer may be transferred during probation.
Source reference: p. 3Reasoning
Govind’s transfer had been ordered by the competent authorities, but he was not relieved solely because he was on probation and Note No. 3 applied.
Source reference: p. 3Since the Rajasthan Service Rules, 1951 did not prohibit such a transfer, the Court held that the note’s restriction was arbitrary and unreasonable.
Source reference: p. 3–4The decision in Monika supported the conclusion that probation does not itself bar transfer.
Source reference: p. 3–4Holding
The Court allowed the appeal and quashed the Single Judge’s order dated 17 September 2026.
The Court directed the respondents to give effect to the transfer order dated 10 July 2026 and immediately relieve Govind to join the Sub-divisional Officer’s office at Shergarh.
Source reference: p. 4Original Court PDF
GOVINDvsSTATE OF RAJASTHAN
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
