01Facts
The respondent worked for the Nigam as a daily wager from 15 November 1979 to 31 July 1987, on a work-charged basis from 1 August 1987 to 20 February 1989, and thereafter in regular service from 21 February 1989 until his retirement on 30 April 2019.
¶ 2–3The Nigam refused to count the earlier periods as qualifying service for pensionary benefits, on the ground that the daily-wage service had not been followed by regularisation.
¶ 2The trial Court granted the respondent relief; the first appellate court affirmed his entitlement but directed deduction of the employee provident-fund share, with interest, in accordance with *Ishwar Dass*.
¶ 6–7The Nigam appealed to the High Court.
¶ 802Issues
i.Whether the respondent’s daily-wage service, followed continuously by work-charged and regular service, could be counted as qualifying service for pensionary benefits under Rule 3.17-A of the Punjab Civil Services Rules, as applicable to the Nigam.
¶ 9, 11–13ii.Whether Rule 3.17-A’s provision concerning service paid from contingencies excluded the respondent’s daily-wage service from qualifying service.
¶ 9, 12–1303Law Applied
Rule 3.17-A(a) provides that interrupted or continuous service followed by confirmation is qualifying service, with any break excluded from the aggregate.
¶ 12Rule 3.17-A(f) addresses temporary employees and sets out exceptions, including provisions concerning service paid from contingencies; the relevant contingency-service provision requires, among other conditions, continuity and absorption into regular employment without a break.
¶ 11–12Rule 3.17-A(g) provides that work-charged service counts towards retirement benefits where it is followed by regular employment, is continuous or has only condonable interruptions, and is whole-time service.
¶ 11The lower courts also referred to *Kesar Chand v. State of Punjab*, AIR 1988 P&H 265, and *Ishwar Dass v. The Managing Director, Uttar Pradesh Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited and others*, CWP No. 14218 of 2017, decided on 12 September 2022.
¶ 6–704Reasoning
The Court found that the respondent’s daily-wage service was followed by work-charged service and then regular appointment without a break, and that he had not been paid from contingencies during the earlier periods.
¶ 13Accordingly, the contingency-service provision in Rule 3.17-A(f) did not govern his daily-wage service; the continuous service, followed by regular appointment, could be counted towards qualifying service. The work-charged period was also countable under Rule 3.17-A(g), subject to its stated conditions.
¶ 11–13The Court therefore found no illegality in the courts below’ decisions.
¶ 1405Holding
The High Court dismissed the Nigam’s Regular Second Appeal, holding that the respondent’s daily-wage and work-charged service was countable as qualifying service for pensionary benefits.
¶ 14–15The first appellate court’s direction to deduct the employee provident-fund share, with interest, remained undisturbed.
¶ 7, 15No order as to costs was made, and any pending applications were disposed of.
¶ 15–16Original Court PDF
Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam & OrsvsChiman Lal Singla & Anr
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
