Facts
The Petitioner, a street vendor operating a food stall named ‘Patna Best Roll Centre’ near Adarsh Nagar Metro Station, approached the High Court seeking protection for his right to vend
Source reference: p. 1-2He holds a provisional Certificate of Vending (CoV) for food snacks involving the use of a gas cylinder
Source reference: para. 4The Petitioner alleged that officials from the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) and Delhi Police were obstructing his operations
Source reference: para. 6Conversely, the MCD submitted evidence showing the Petitioner was encroaching on pedestrian footpaths with tables, failing to maintain hygiene, and improperly placing gas cylinders outside his cart
Source reference: para. 7-9Issues
1. Whether a provisional Certificate of Vending (CoV) holder can be restricted from vending due to violations of hygiene and space-management conditions
Source reference: para. 102. Whether the Petitioner is entitled to protection against official interference while using a gas cylinder for vending
Source reference: para. 11-12Law Applied
The Court applied the provisions of the Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 2014, specifically Section 21 regarding the authority of the Town Vending Committee to regulate vending zones
Source reference: para. 13The Court also relied on judicial precedents established in Rajendra Singh v. Commissioner of Police and Mohd Badruddin v. MCD, which provide a framework for balancing vendors' livelihood rights with public order, safety, and hygiene requirements
Source reference: para. 11Reasoning
The Court observed that while the Petitioner holds a valid provisional CoV, the visual evidence provided by the MCD indicated a breach of vending norms, specifically the hazardous placement of gas cylinders and the obstruction of pedestrian space with auxiliary furniture
Source reference: para. 10The Court reasoned that the right to vend is not absolute and must be exercised in strict compliance with the conditions of the CoV and public safety standards
Source reference: para. 10By applying the "small cylinder" and "non-obstruction" directives used in previous similar cases, the Court sought to reconcile the Petitioner’s right to earn a livelihood with the statutory obligation of the MCD to keep public pathways clear and sanitary
Source reference: para. 11-12Holding
The Court disposed of the petition by granting the Petitioner permission to vend peacefully, subject to strict conditions: he must use only small gas cylinders for heating, avoid all pedestrian encroachment, maintain a dustbin, and ensure no sub-letting or permanent construction
The Court held that the MCD must conduct an inspection on August 13, 2026, to verify compliance... These directions remain subject to future relocation or regulatory plans formulated by the Town Vending Committee-II under the 2014 Act
Source reference: para. 13-14Original Court PDF
Mohd SabirvsMunicipal Corporation Of Delhi And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in