CAT - ['Ernakulam']
Administrative and Public LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

The application was dismissed as infructuous after the respondents paid the entire amount.

N Appukuttan Nair vs DEFENCE

CAT - ['Ernakulam']JUDGMENT: October 06, 20261 MIN READSOURCE JUDGMENT
The application was dismissed as infructuous after the respondents paid the entire amount.. N Appukuttan Nair  vs DEFENCE. CAT - ['Ernakulam']. LawLens
THE ORIGINAL LAWLENS SUMMARY
01

Facts

The applicant, a retired Refrigeration Mechanic, brought an Original Application against the Union of India and other authorities.

Source reference: no citation

At the hearing, the respondents’ Standing Counsel submitted that the entire amount claimed had been paid and that the application had therefore become infructuous.

Source reference: no citation

The Tribunal had directed the applicant to verify and report on that submission, but there was no representation for the applicant on the previous hearing date or at the final hearing.

Source reference: no citation
02

Issues

1. Whether the Original Application had become infructuous in light of the respondents’ submission that the entire amount had been paid.

Source reference: no citation

2. Whether the application should accordingly be dismissed.

Source reference: no citation
03

Law Applied

The Tribunal cited no statute, precedent, or specific legal test.

Source reference: no citation

It disposed of the application on the procedural basis that, once the relief sought had been satisfied, the matter was infructuous and no further adjudication was required.

Source reference: no citation
04

Reasoning

The Tribunal recorded the Standing Counsel’s submission that the entire amount had been paid.

Source reference: no citation

Although the applicant had been directed to verify that position, he was unrepresented at the final hearing and had not appeared on the prior hearing date. In those circumstances, the Tribunal accepted the submission that the application no longer required adjudication.

Source reference: no citation
05

Holding

The Tribunal treated the Original Application as infructuous and dismissed it.

No costs were awarded.

Source reference: no citation
CAT - ['Ernakulam']

Original Court PDF

N Appukuttan NairvsDEFENCE

CAT - ['Ernakulam'] · October 06, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment