01Facts
The accused applied under Section 91 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC), for documents including unrelied-upon material, registers, committee minutes and other records.
pp. 1–2, paras 2–3The Special Court allowed the application, and, after the CBI filed a compliance report resisting production of some documents or stating that they were unavailable, made a further order on 18 July 2022.
pp. 1–2, paras 2–3The High Court affirmed that order.
pp. 1–2, paras 2–3The CBI appealed, challenging the directions to produce documents at the charge-framing stage.
pp. 1–2, paras 2–3Before the Supreme Court, the accused stated that he no longer sought the source-information records or case diaries.
p. 2, para 502Issues
i.1. Whether, and at what stage, an accused may seek access to unrelied-upon documents held by the prosecuting agency.
p. 3, para 7ii.2. Whether the CBI could be directed to produce documents that it stated were unavailable or confidential, and how the accused could obtain documents identified during inspection of voluminous unrelied-upon material.
pp. 5–7, paras 9–1303Law Applied
Section 91 CrPC provides for summons or production of documents or other things necessary or desirable for an investigation, inquiry, trial or other proceeding.
pp. 2–3, paras 6–7In State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi, the Court stated that an accused’s entitlement to seek an order under Section 91 ordinarily arises at the defence stage;
pp. 2–3, paras 6–7Sarla Gupta v. Directorate of Enforcement discussed that observation in the context of the record considered at the charge-framing stage and stated that, ordinarily, an accused is not entitled to copies of unrelied-upon documents at that stage.
pp. 2–3, paras 6–7The Court did not resolve the scope of those precedents, proceeding instead on the premise that an accused is entitled to documents available with the prosecuting agency to prepare a defence; the stage for seeking particular documents depends on the documents sought.
pp. 2–3, paras 6–7Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 91Section 227
04Reasoning
The Court distinguished between material held by the CBI and material it said was unavailable or confidential.
p. 6, para 10It accepted that the seizure memos had been produced, while the accused had withdrawn his request for the CBI registers and source information.
p. 6, para 10For the voluminous unrelied-upon documents, the accused could inspect them and identify specific documents for production when the relevant witness was examined; alternatively, the parties could record and sign the identified documents during inspection, with those documents then made available at trial.
pp. 6–7, para 11If the specified committee minutes were among the records available for inspection, the accused could seek them through that process; if unavailable with the CBI, he could obtain and prove them in his defence, with their evidentiary value left to the Trial Court.
p. 7, para 12The CBI could not be required to produce records it stated were unavailable.
pp. 7–8, paras 13–1405Holding
The Court set aside the impugned orders to facilitate an expeditious trial and directed the Trial Court to proceed in accordance with its directions.
pp. 6–8, paras 11–15The CBI was to keep the relevant files available for inspection and trial, and documents specifically identified through inspection were to be produced without delay; the accused could independently obtain unavailable documents and prove them in defence.
pp. 6–8, paras 11–15The appeal was disposed of.
p. 8, para 15Original Court PDF
Central Bureau Of InvestigationvsAnil Dixit
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
