01Facts
In final decree proceedings in F.D.P. No. 12/2014, an Advocate appointed as Court Commissioner submitted a report and sketch identifying the parties’ shares in different survey numbers.
pp. 4–5The petitioners objected that the shares lacked sufficiently clear boundaries and measurements and that access to the allotted portions was not established.
pp. 4–5The Senior Civil Judge and CJM, Kodagu at Madikeri, rejected the objections on 1 August 2025.
pp. 4–5The petitioners challenged that order under Article 227 of the Constitution.
pp. 4–502Issues
i.1. Whether identifying the parties’ shares by extent and colour, without clearly specifying boundaries and measurements, was sufficient to complete the demarcation
pp. 5–6ii.2. Whether the Commissioner’s report adequately established access to each allotted portion and could be relied upon to conclude the final decree proceedings
pp. 6–703Law Applied
The Court applied the supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
pp. 6–7It stated that identifying the extent allotted to each party is insufficient unless each portion is also identifiable by definite boundaries; where a larger extent is divided among several parties, adequate access must be provided to each allotted portion.
pp. 6–7Demarcation requiring boundaries, measurements and access calls for requisite technical expertise; an Advocate’s appointment as Commissioner does not, by itself, establish that expertise.
pp. 6–7The order cites no specific statute or precedent governing these principles.
04Reasoning
The Commissioner’s report identified the parties’ shares and extents by colour but did not demarcate the portions with sufficient clarity by specifying boundaries.
pp. 5–7Although the sketch showed dotted lines that might represent an approach road, the report did not clarify the nature or existence of that access, and the petitioner disputed that a road existed.
pp. 5–7The Court therefore considered the exercise incomplete.
pp. 5–7It also observed that the surveyor had acted under the Advocate Commissioner’s directions, whereas the required demarcation called for technical expertise.
pp. 5–705Holding
The Court allowed the petition and set aside the order dated 1 August 2025.
pp. 7–8It directed the Trial Court to appoint a person with appropriate technical expertise, preferably an officer from the Survey or Land Revenue Department, to demarcate the shares in accordance with the decree, specifying measurements, boundaries and access wherever applicable.
pp. 7–8The Trial Court was directed not to rely on the Commissioner’s report dated 16 September 2017 to conclude the final decree proceedings and to complete the proceedings expeditiously, preferably within six months of receiving the order.
pp. 7–8Original Court PDF
B P MEENA KUMARIvsA M SUCHETHA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
