01Facts
On 1 December 2018, Ramesh Yadav died in a road accident involving a lorry while riding a motorcycle with his daughter as pillion passenger.
p. 7His wife, children and parents claimed compensation, asserting that he was a businessman earning ₹30 lakh annually.
p. 7The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal assessed his annual income at ₹5,81,150, added 25% for future prospects, and awarded total compensation of ₹87,87,220, including ₹40,000 for loss of consortium.
pp. 7–9The insurer appealed, challenging the dependency calculation; the claimants appealed seeking enhancement, including increased consortium compensation.
pp. 6, 9–1102Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal erred in assessing the deceased’s income and calculating loss of dependency, including by relying on the income-tax return for assessment year 2018–19 rather than averaging earlier returns.
pp. 9–14ii.2. Whether the award of ₹40,000 for loss of consortium was inadequate and should be enhanced for the eligible claimants.
pp. 11, 14–1503Law Applied
Appeals were brought under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act.
p. 3, 5Under Rashmirekha Tripathy v. The Branch Manager (Legal Claims), Sriram General Insurance Company Limited, where a self-employed person’s income is assessed, the average of income shown in up to three years of income-tax returns may be a reference point; however, relevant circumstances—including the nature and growth of the business and income fluctuations—must also be considered, and the filing date of returns may be relevant.
pp. 9–10Under National Insurance Co. v. Pranay Sethi, consortium is payable to each eligible claimant, with the judgment applying ₹40,000 per claimant in this case.
pp. 11, 14–15The claimants also invoked Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram, but the court’s stated basis for the consortium award was Pranay Sethi.
p. 11Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173
04Reasoning
The court found no basis to alter the dependency award.
pp. 12–14The claimants had produced income-tax returns from assessment year 2014–15 through 2019–20, and the income trend was upward without fluctuation.
pp. 12–14Considering the surrounding business circumstances and the principles in Rashmirekha Tripathy, the court upheld the Tribunal’s use of the 2018–19 return and rejected both the insurer’s request to average the preceding three years and the claimants’ request to reassess dependency.
pp. 12–14It held, however, that consortium had been under-assessed: the wife, four children and father—six claimants—were eligible for ₹40,000 each.
pp. 14–16The mother had died during the appeal, leaving six eligible claimants and a total consortium award of ₹2,40,000, an increase of ₹2,00,000 over the Tribunal’s award.
pp. 14–1605Holding
The insurer’s appeal, MFA No. 4505 of 2020, was dismissed; the claimants’ appeal, MFA No. 6056 of 2021, was allowed in part.
p. 16The award was modified by granting an additional ₹2,00,000, representing consortium at ₹40,000 each for claimants 1 to 6.
p. 16The Tribunal’s other directions concerning entitlement, apportionment, deposits and release remained undisturbed; claimant No. 6 was held entitled to the amount awarded in favour of the deceased claimant No. 7.
p. 16No order was made as to costs.
p. 16Original Court PDF
SMT. KIRAN DEVIvsROYAL SUNDARAM ALLIANZ INSURANCE CO. LTD
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
