Madras High CourtCriminal Procedure and EvidenceCriminal Law

At discharge stage, probative value of evidence cannot be weighed; prima facie material suffices for trial.

Noornishav.State Of Tamilnadu Rep By Inspector Of Police, Tirunelveli Town

At discharge stage, probative value of evidence cannot be weighed; prima facie material suffices for trial.. Noornisha vs State Of Tamilnadu Rep By Inspector Of Police, Tirunelveli Town. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the trial court erred in dismissing A4's discharge petition, i.e., whether the revision petitioner is entitled to be discharged from S.C. No. 527/2025 for want of prima facie material.

The court held

The court answered the sole point for determination against A4: she is not entitled to be discharged from S.C. No. 527/2025.

It also directed

The evidentiary objections raised by A4 are matters for trial, and the trial court's finding of prima facie material is upheld. The court cautioned that its observations shall not influence the trial. The revision is dismissed, the trial court's order in Crl. M.P. No. 4/2026 is affirmed, and pending applications are closed.

01Facts

The investigating officer in Crime No. 68/2025 (Tirunelveli Town PS) filed a police report alleging that the deceased, a permanent Muthavalli of a Wakf Board mosque, was murdered on 18.03.2025 while returning from prayers.

¶ 5 · pp. 2–4

The prosecution alleges that A1, the husband of the revision petitioner (A4), had a land dispute with the deceased over 36 cents in T.S. No. 2591, which A1 and A4 claimed as private property but the deceased claimed for the Wakf Board.

¶ 5 · pp. 2–4

A prior case (Cr. No. 02/2025) had been registered on A1's complaint after the deceased tried to erect a shed on the land.

¶ 5 · pp. 2–4

The prosecution alleges that A1, A4, A5 and a child in conflict with law conspired on 17.03.2025 at A1 and A4's rented house to eliminate the deceased and his wife, the de facto complainant.

¶ 5 · pp. 2–4

The case is pending as S.C. No. 527/2025 before the IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tirunelveli.

¶ 5 · p. 4 · ¶ 3

A4, charged under S. 61(2), S. 103(1) r/w S. 49 (as stated in the judgment), filed a discharge petition (Crl. M.P. No. 4/2026), which the trial court dismissed on 30.06.2026.

¶ 5 · p. 4 · ¶ 3

A4 filed this revision under S. 438 BNSS.

¶ 3

The trial court relied on (a) the S. 180(3) BNSS statement of LW27, the owner of the rented house, who recorded A4 saying "so many men are here, kill him quickly"; and (b) CDR records showing post-occurrence communication between A4 and A1.

¶ 15

A4 contended that the CDR material is not legal evidence, that motive witnesses are interested, that LW27's statement cannot implicate her, and that electronic and forensic material was not properly appreciated.

¶ 8

The prosecution and the de facto complainant contended that prima facie material exists and that these matters require trial.

¶ 9–10

02Issues

i.1. Whether the trial court erred in dismissing A4's discharge petition, i.e., whether the revision petitioner is entitled to be discharged from S.C. No. 527/2025 for want of prima facie material.

¶ 11 · ¶ 18

ii.2. Whether the evidentiary challenges raised by A4 (reliance on LW27's statement, probative value of CDR records, credibility of motive witnesses, and electronic/forensic evidence) can be adjudicated at the discharge stage.

¶ 9 · ¶ 16

03Law Applied

The court relied on the settled scope of discharge and framing of charges as laid down in Sajjan Kumar v. CBI (2010) 9 SCC 368, under which the court may sift and weigh material only to determine whether a prima facie case exists, must not act as a post office for the prosecution, and must not conduct a roving enquiry or assess probative value; if two views are possible and one gives rise only to suspicion, discharge follows.

¶ 12(1)

The court applied State of Rajasthan v. Ashok Kumar Kashyap (2021 LiveLaw SC 210), which, following P. Vijayan and M.R. Hiremath, holds that the court must assume the prosecution material to be true and ask whether it discloses the ingredients of the offence, without weighing evidence or probabilities, relying on State of T.N. v. N. Suresh Rajan (2014) 11 SCC 709 that the law does not permit a mini-trial at this stage.

¶ 12(2)

The court relied on CBI v. Aryan Singh (2023) 18 SCC 399, which confines the inquiry at discharge to whether sufficient material exists to proceed to trial, and holds that malice and the merits of the allegations are for trial.

¶ 12(3)

The judgment frames these principles under the CrPC provisions (ss. 227, 228, 239, 482), which correspond to the BNSS provisions now applicable.

Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 438Section 442

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 227Section 228Section 239Section 482

04Reasoning

The court first identified the scope of its review as limited to whether the trial court's finding of prima facie material was erroneous or perverse.

¶ 12 · ¶ 17

The trial court based its finding on LW27's statement recording A4's remark and on CDR-based post-occurrence contact with A1.

¶ 15

Applying the Sajjan Kumar and Ashok Kumar Kashyap principles, the court held that whether LW27's statement is legally sustainable, whether the CDR material has probative value, whether motive witnesses are interested, and whether electronic and forensic evidence is reliable are all questions of trial, not of discharge.

¶ 16

Because the discharge inquiry does not extend to weighing evidence, the court found the trial court's conclusion that prima facie material exists against A4 for criminal conspiracy and abetment neither erroneous nor perverse.

¶ 15 · ¶ 17

The court therefore declined to re-appreciate the material as A4 requested.

¶ 16 · ¶ 17

05Holding

The court answered the sole point for determination against A4: she is not entitled to be discharged from S.C. No. 527/2025.

¶ 18

The evidentiary objections raised by A4 are matters for trial, and the trial court's finding of prima facie material is upheld. The court cautioned that its observations shall not influence the trial. The revision is dismissed, the trial court's order in Crl. M.P. No. 4/2026 is affirmed, and pending applications are closed.

¶ 16–17 · ¶ 19 · ¶ 20 · ¶ 21
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

NoornishavsState Of Tamilnadu Rep By Inspector Of Police, Tirunelveli Town

Madras High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment