Madras High CourtCriminal Procedure and EvidenceCriminal Law

Separate FIRs allowed in alleged high-return investment fraud, as Madurai Bench finds complaints by different victims are distinct transactions

Anuradhav.Shakira

Separate FIRs allowed in alleged high-return investment fraud, as Madurai Bench finds complaints by different victims are distinct transactions. Anuradha vs Shakira. Madras High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the occurrences alleged in the Shakira and Gayathri complaints, and the Beula complaint underlying Cr. No. 41/2024, can be said to have taken place "in the course of the same transaction," so as to bar subsequent FIRs.

The court held

The three occurrences alleged by Beula, Shakira and Gayathri cannot be said to have taken place "in the course of the same transaction," and the subsequent FIRs on the Shakira and Gayathri complaints are not barred.

It also directed

All three criminal revisions were dismissed: Crl RC(MD) No. 1665 of 2026 and Crl RC(MD) No. 1687 of 2026 (upholding the order in Crl MP No. 6924/2026), and Crl RC(MD) No. 1684 of 2026 (upholding the order in Crl MP No. 8478/2026). The direction to the Inspector of Police, City Crime Branch, Tiruchirappalli, to register FIRs and investigate the Shakira and Gayathri complaints stands, and pending applications were closed.

01Facts

Three complainants alleged that the accused, portraying themselves as importers with large foreign business dealings, induced them to invest on promises of high returns and failed to repay.

Beula invested Rs.1.70 crore between December 2021 and August 2023 at 15% per month, and alleged offences under sections 417, 420 and 506(i) IPC against Anuradha, Hariharan and five others.

¶ 13, 14(1)

A FIR (Cr. No. 41/2024, City Crime Branch, Tiruchirappalli) was registered on 18.12.2024 pursuant to the trial court's order in Cr MP No. 6610/2024.

¶ 13, 14(1)

Shakira invested Rs.2.91 crore between November 2023 and November 2025 at 10% per 10 days, and alleged offences under sections 316(2), 318(2) and 318(4) BNS against Anuradha, Durga, Priyadharshini, Hariharan @ Karan and Nithish.

¶ 03(1), 14(2)

Shakira filed Cr MP No. 6924/2026 under section 175(3) BNSS.

¶ 14(2)

Gayathri invested Rs.4.35 crore between 2023 and May 2026 at 10–15% per 15 days, and alleged the same BNS offences against the same accused.

¶ 04(1), 14(3)

Gayathri filed Cr MP No. 8478/2026 under section 175(3) BNSS.

¶ 14(3)

The trial court (JM-I, Tiruchirappalli) on 25.09.2026 directed the Inspector of Police, City Crime Branch, to register FIRs on the Shakira and Gayathri complaints and investigate.

¶ 03(1), 04(1)

Anuradha and Priyadharshini (Crl RC 1665) and Durga and Hariharan @ Karan (Crl RC 1687, 1684) filed revisions under section 438 r/w section 442 BNSS.

The petitioners contended that the later complaints arose from the same transaction as Cr. No. 41/2024 and that successive FIRs would cause repeated investigation and prejudice.

¶ 06

The State and the complainants contended that the three sets of transactions were distinct.

¶ 07–08

02Issues

i.1. Whether the occurrences alleged in the Shakira and Gayathri complaints, and the Beula complaint underlying Cr. No. 41/2024, can be said to have taken place "in the course of the same transaction," so as to bar subsequent FIRs.

¶ 12, 17

ii.2. Whether the trial court's orders of 25.09.2026 directing registration and investigation of FIRs on the Shakira and Gayathri complaints are legally sustainable and warrant interference in revision.

¶ 06–07, 19

03Law Applied

A second or successive FIR for the same or connected cognizable offence committed in the same transaction, where investigation under the first FIR is underway or a final report has been filed, may warrant interference under inherent or constitutional jurisdiction, as held in TT Antony v. State of Kerala, (2001) 6 SCC 181.

¶ 10(a)

Amitbhai Anilchandra Shah v. CBI, (2013) 6 SCC 348 holds that fresh investigation on the same incident must be balanced against the accused's rights.

¶ 10(b)

Under Babu Bhai v. State of Gujarat, (2010) 12 SCC 254, the "test of sameness" determines whether two FIRs concern the same incident or distinct incidents or parts of the same transaction.

¶ 10(c)

Amish Devgan v. Union of India, (2021) 1 SCC 1 provides that the first FIR is ordinarily the principal one, subject to exceptions.

¶ 10(d)

State (NCT of Delhi) v. Khimji Bhai Jadeja (2026 INSC 25) sets out three non-cumulative tests for "same transaction": unity of purpose and design, proximity of time and place, and continuity of action; distinct victims and distinct offences require separate proceedings.

¶ 10(e)

Under Rutrij Bhagat Singh Wakhare v. State of Maharashtra (2026 INSC 740), complaints by different complainants, with no live link between transactions, disclose separate transactions despite a similar modus operandi and overlapping accused.

¶ 11, 16

Provisions in the judgment · 14 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 438Section 442Section 186Section 162Section 242

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 9 provisionsSection 482Section 173Section 162Section 218Section 219Section 220Section 221Section 222Section 223

04Reasoning

The court rejected the petitioners' premise that similarity of modus operandi and overlap of accused establish a single transaction, as these alone are insufficient.

¶ 11, 16

Applying the Khimji Bhai triple test, the court found that the three occurrences involved different complainants, different amounts, different periods, different rates of return and different sets of offences, with no connecting purpose or continuity between them.

¶ 14, 16

The accused did not operate from a single premises or office; rather, they approached each complainant independently, induced investment, received money on different dates and threatened the complainants when repayment was demanded.

¶ 15

On this basis, the complaints disclose distinct offences, so the bar against successive FIRs for the same transaction did not apply.

¶ 16–17

Because the Shakira and Gayathri complaints were not part of the transaction in Cr. No. 41/2024, the petitioners' objection of repeated investigation and prejudice failed, and the trial court's direction under section 175(3) to register FIRs was upheld.

¶ 17, 19

The court clarified that its observations were confined to the revisions and would not influence the decisions in the underlying cases.

¶ 18

05Holding

The three occurrences alleged by Beula, Shakira and Gayathri cannot be said to have taken place "in the course of the same transaction," and the subsequent FIRs on the Shakira and Gayathri complaints are not barred.

¶ 17

All three criminal revisions were dismissed: Crl RC(MD) No. 1665 of 2026 and Crl RC(MD) No. 1687 of 2026 (upholding the order in Crl MP No. 6924/2026), and Crl RC(MD) No. 1684 of 2026 (upholding the order in Crl MP No. 8478/2026). The direction to the Inspector of Police, City Crime Branch, Tiruchirappalli, to register FIRs and investigate the Shakira and Gayathri complaints stands, and pending applications were closed.

¶ 19(a)–(c), 20
Madras High Court

Original Court PDF

AnuradhavsShakira

Madras High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment