01Facts
On 03.03.2020, the claimant, then aged 43, was injured in a road traffic accident caused by the rash and negligent driving of KSRTC bus No. KA-06-F-693.
¶ 4, 10The claimant was admitted as an inpatient at Sanjay Gandhi Institute of Trauma and Orthopaedics from 03.03.2020 to 24.03.2020 (22 days).
¶ 11His wound certificate (Ex-P6) recorded five injuries, three of which were fractures.
¶ 10PW2, the treating/examining doctor, assessed 45% disability to the limb and 21% to the whole body and stated that the claimant had been fitted with an implant requiring removal.
¶ 12, 13The Tribunal (MACT, Bengaluru, MVC No. 4281/2021) awarded ₹8,04,778 under six heads with 6% interest from the date of petition, applying multiplier 14 and notional income of ₹14,500 per month.
¶ 5, 10The claimant appealed for enhancement, contending that he was a bar bender and centering worker and that loss of amenities and future medical expenses were not awarded.
¶ 8KSRTC appealed, contending that the claimant was not proved to be a passenger, that his 2023 alcohol-related hospital bills were unrelated, that one bill belonged to another person, and that the award was excessive.
¶ 902Issues
i.1. Whether the claimant has established that he was a passenger in the autorickshaw and sustained injuries in the accident caused by the KSRTC bus.
¶ 16ii.2. Whether the Tribunal's assessment of disability (21% whole body), multiplier (14) and notional income (₹14,500) was correct, and whether the claimant is entitled to enhancement under the heads of loss of amenities and future medical expenses.
¶ 8, 10, 12iii.3. Whether the Tribunal's awards under attendant/conveyance, food and nourishment, laid-up period income and medical bills were correct, including whether the impugned medical bills were properly allowable.
¶ 9, 11, 1303Law Applied
The judgment rests on the appellate jurisdiction conferred by Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, under which both appeals were preferred.
¶ 1–2 · pp. 2–3On liability and causation, the Court relied on the charge sheet (Ex-P7) for offences under Sections 279, 337 and 338 IPC, treating its recital that the claimant was travelling in the autorickshaw as proof of passenger status and injury.
¶ 16On quantum, the Court applied the principles that compensation must be based on proved evidence, including medical evidence of disability, proved income, and proved expenses, and that compensation must be reasonable for injuries and the period of hospitalisation.
¶ 10–13No precedent from the Supreme Court or High Court is cited for multiplier, future income, or amenities awards.
Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 279Section 337Section 338
04Reasoning
The Court accepted the charge sheet narrative (CW2 Anand, injured while travelling in the autorickshaw) as sufficient to establish that the claimant was a passenger and was injured, rejecting KSRTC's contention.
¶ 16On multiplier, the Court held that the Tribunal correctly applied multiplier 14 for a claimant aged 43.
¶ 10On income, it held that bar-bending work was not proved by evidence, so the Tribunal correctly adopted the notional income of ₹14,500 for 2020.
¶ 10The Court accepted the doctor's 21% whole-body disability and upheld the ₹5,11,560 award for loss of future income.
¶ 12For pain and suffering, it upheld ₹1,20,000 given the five injuries, three fractures.
¶ 10It granted ₹60,000 for loss of amenities, which the Tribunal had not awarded.
¶ 10Given 22 days of hospitalisation, it enhanced attendant, conveyance and food/nourishment charges to ₹22,000 (₹1,000 × 22) from the ₹80,000 total previously awarded, and allowed ₹43,500 for three months' laid-up income.
¶ 11For medical expenses, it excluded ₹925 (₹140 in another person's name, ₹185 and ₹600 for liver function tests and alcohol-related treatment) from the ₹6,278 claimed, leaving ₹5,353.
¶ 13It awarded ₹30,000 for future medical expenses (implant removal).
¶ 13The Court did not separately address KSRTC's argument that the treating doctor was not the treating surgeon or that the fracture had united.
¶ 905Holding
The Court held that the claimant was a passenger injured in the accident.
¶ 16It found the total compensation to be ₹7,92,413, which is lower than the ₹8,04,778 awarded by the Tribunal.
¶ 14–15Both appeals were allowed in part.
¶ 17(i)The operative order, however, states ₹7,82,413, which conflicts with the computed figure of ₹7,92,413 and must be corrected.
¶ 17(ii) · ¶ 14–15The order directs KSRTC to deposit the compensation with interest at 6% per annum from the date of petition within six weeks, including the amount already deposited.
¶ 17(ii)–(iii)The deposit is to be transmitted to the Tribunal.
¶ 17(iv)50% is to be kept in fixed deposit at Karnataka Bank, High Court Branch, Bengaluru, in the claimant's name, with the remaining 50% released to him.
¶ 17(v)The Registry is directed to return the trial court records.
¶ 17(vi)Original Court PDF
THE MANAGING DIRECTORvsSRI. ANANDA. K. S.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
