CAT - ['Chandigarh']
Social Security and PensionsAdministrative and Public Law

Challenge to the New Pension Scheme became infructuous after applicants received Old Pension Scheme coverage.

Gurpreet Singh Sidhu vs Education Deptt., Ut Chandigarh

CAT - ['Chandigarh']JUDGMENT: September 17, 20261 MIN READSOURCE JUDGMENT
Challenge to the New Pension Scheme became infructuous after applicants received Old Pension Scheme coverage.. Gurpreet Singh Sidhu vs Education Deptt., Ut Chandigarh. CAT - ['Chandigarh']. LawLens
THE ORIGINAL LAWLENS SUMMARY
01

Facts

The applicants, employees of the Chandigarh Administration, sought coverage under the Old Pension Scheme-cum-General Provident Fund (OPS-cum-GPF) instead of the New Pension Scheme.

Source reference: p. 4, para. 2

During the pendency of the Original Application, the respondents granted the requested relief pursuant to Office Memorandum dated 3 March 2023. Applicants’ counsel therefore submitted that the matter had become infructuous

Source reference: p. 4, para. 2
02

Issues

Whether the applicants’ claim for coverage under OPS-cum-GPF had been satisfied during the pendency of the Original Application, rendering it infructuous

Source reference: p. 4, para. 2

Whether the Original Application should accordingly be disposed of as infructuous

Source reference: p. 4, para. 3
03

Law Applied

The Tribunal cited no statute, precedent, or substantive pension-law principle.

Source reference: p. 4, paras. 2–3

It proceeded on the stated fact that the respondents had granted the applicants’ requested relief pursuant to the Office Memorandum dated 3 March 2023; the order does not set out the terms or legal effect of that memorandum

Source reference: p. 4, paras. 2–3
04

Reasoning

The Tribunal recorded counsel’s submission that the respondents had granted the precise relief sought—OPS-cum-GPF coverage instead of the New Pension Scheme—during the proceedings under the 3 March 2023 Office Memorandum.

Source reference: p. 4, paras. 2–3

On that basis, it treated the dispute as no longer requiring adjudication and disposed of the application as infructuous

Source reference: p. 4, paras. 2–3
05

Holding

The Tribunal disposed of the Original Application as infructuous because the requested relief had been granted during its pendency.

Any pending miscellaneous applications were also disposed of accordingly

Source reference: p. 4, para. 3
CAT - ['Chandigarh']

Original Court PDF

Gurpreet Singh SidhuvsEducation Deptt., Ut Chandigarh

CAT - ['Chandigarh'] · September 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment