01Facts
The Chhattisgarh Public Service Commission (CGPSC) issued Advertisement No. 5/2019 on 06.03.2019 for 61 posts of Sports Officer in the Higher Education Department.
¶ 3(a) · pp. 3–4The petitioner, a UR-Female candidate holding CGTET qualification in Physical Education, appeared in the written examination (26.11.2019) and interview, scoring 147.9701 marks and placed at Serial No. 65 in the final merit list.
¶ 3(b) · pp. 4–5Respondents 4 to 8, belonging to the OBC category, were placed at Serial Nos. 7, 9, 21, 28 and 13 with scores of 213.8344, 211.7936, 200.6305, 188.3247 and 207.6712, and were selected against UR-Female posts.
¶ 3(b) · p. 5The CGPSC stated that the cut-off was 205.7121 for unreserved and 87.4672 for reserved candidates.
¶ 4 · p. 5The select list dated 18.09.2020 (Annexure P/9) was challenged. On 19.10.2020 the Court stayed appointments under the list, and the stay was challenged in Writ Appeal No. 443/2021.
¶ 2 · pp. 2–3The interim order was vacated on 11.06.2024 and the connected petitioners were appointed, after which the interim order in this petition was also vacated on parity grounds.
¶ 2 · p. 3The petitioner contended that OBC candidates could not migrate to UR-Female posts because women's reservation under the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Special Provision for Appointment of Women) Rules, 1997 ("1997 Rules") is horizontal and category-specific.
¶ 5–6 · pp. 6–802Issues
i.1. Whether the migration of OBC female candidates to the General women category under the 1997 Rules is permissible.
¶ 11 · p. 903Law Applied
Rule 3 of the 1997 Rules reserves 30% of posts for women at direct recruitment on a "horizontal and compartment-wise" basis, meaning reservation within each of the SC, ST, OBC and General categories.
¶ 12 · p. 9Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 distinguishes horizontal from vertical reservation and holds that no rule prohibits adjustment of socially reserved women in the open category.
¶ 14–15 · pp. 10–11Saurav Yadav v. State of U.P., (2021) 4 SCC 542 states that horizontal reservation is calculated concurrently with vertical quotas, that merit-based migration from reserved to open slots is permissible, and that the first rule is adjustment.
¶ 15 · pp. 11–12Sadhana Singh Dangi v. Pinki Asati, (2022) 12 SCC 401 examined analogous Madhya Pradesh Rules and held that merit takes precedence even in horizontal reservation.
¶ 16 · p. 13Chhaya v. State of Maharashtra, 2026 INSC 277 holds that relaxation in qualifying criteria affects eligibility, not merit, and that migration is permissible absent express prohibition in the recruitment rules.
¶ 17 · pp. 13–14Airport Authority of India v. Sham Krishna B, 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 83 holds that reserved candidates scoring above the General cut-off must be treated as qualified against open vacancies.
¶ 18 · pp. 14–1504Reasoning
The 1997 Rules contain no prohibition on adjusting socially reserved women into the General category; they only require adjustment against the candidate's social category where selected.
¶ 14 · p. 10 · ¶ 16 · p. 13Applying Saurav Yadav, the court treated merit as controlling, so reserved-category women who score above the open cut-off may be placed in open posts.
¶ 15–16 · pp. 11–13The court rejected the petitioner's reading of the 1997 Rules as category-specific and held that the Rules do not bar migration; the CGPSC Rules of Procedure, 2014 (as amended) do not displace this position.
¶ 19 · p. 15On the facts, the court noted that respondents 4 to 8 secured more marks than the petitioner and the unreserved cut-off, and that the respondents 1 to 3 therefore committed no illegality in including them in the select list.
¶ 20 · p. 15The petitioner's argument that OBC candidates who used relaxed standards cannot migrate was answered by reference to Chhaya, which holds that relaxation affects eligibility rather than merit.
¶ 17 · pp. 13–14The court's reasoning on this specific point is brief, and the judgment does not record a finding that respondents 4 to 8 availed no relaxation, though it relies on their higher merit scores.
¶ 20 · p. 1505Holding
The Court answered the sole issue in the affirmative: migration of OBC female candidates to the General women category under the 1997 Rules is permissible where they secure merit above the open cut-off and no rule expressly prohibits it.
¶ 16–17 · pp. 13–14 · ¶ 20 · p. 15The writ petition was dismissed, and the selection and appointment of respondents 4 to 8 were upheld.
¶ 20 · p. 15Original Court PDF
SMT. SHAHANA KHATOONvsSTATE OF CHHATTISGARH
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
