01Facts
The complainant, P. Mukundan (R-1), alleged that the petitioners (sisters Radhika Vasudevan, Sangeeth Ravikanth and Padmini Narayan) colluded with his brother to fabricate a relinquishment deed. He claimed that under a 1986 memorandum of agreement, properties were partitioned between him and his siblings, with separate khatas issued and taxes paid.
¶ 3He had obtained a money decree against his brother, with interest later allowed by the Supreme Court and attachment sought.
¶ 3He alleged that a relinquishment deed was executed in 2019 in favour of the sisters to defeat the attachment and sale.
¶ 3The relinquishment deed is dated 04.07.2018, after the execution proceedings were closed on 26.06.2018.
¶ 5, 6The complainant filed private complaints under Section 200 CrPC, which were taken cognizance of and process was issued in PCR Nos. 1033/2019 (C.C. No. 32915/2021) and PCR No. 2088/2019 (C.C. No. 12764/2020).
¶ 2, 4, 14The petitioners sought quashing under Section 482 CrPC on the grounds that the proceedings were a civil dispute, the complaint was filed as an afterthought while O.S. No. 67/2019 was pending, and no supporting affidavit was filed.
¶ 6, 7The complainant contended that the relinquishment deed was executed during the pendency of the SLP, that the property exceeds ₹10 crores in value, and that the accused subsequently executed a gift deed.
¶ 11, 13The petitioners in the second petition also pleaded full satisfaction of the execution.
¶ 14, 1502Issues
i.1. Whether the Trial Court erred in taking cognizance and issuing process against the petitioners, such that interference under Section 482 CrPC is warranted.
¶ 17ii.2. Whether the complaint is vitiated for non-compliance with the affidavit requirement, given that no prayer under Section 156(3) CrPC was made.
¶ 12, 22–2403Law Applied
The Court relied on Sections 482 and 156(3) CrPC and Sections 200 and 195–199 CrPC.
¶ 12, 22–24The Court applied the Bhajan Lal principles, which govern quashing where allegations do not disclose an offence and where proceedings are an abuse of process.
¶ 7, 25Under Priyanka Srivastava, an affidavit is required where a complaint seeks Section 156(3) investigation, but the Court held this is not mandatory where no such prayer is made.
¶ 12, 22The Court followed P. Nagaraju v. State (Crl.P. No. 1525/2018) and a Kalaburagi Bench order (Crl.P. No. 201319/2019) on the affidavit point.
¶ 12, 23The Court applied the Crl.P. No. 2394/2020 order, holding that offences requiring a complaint under Sections 195, 198 and 199 CrPC do not require an affidavit.
¶ 24On mens rea, the Court relied on the IPC provisions as invoked: Sections 206, 207, 421 and 424, concerning dishonest or fraudulent removal, concealment or transfer of property to defeat claims or attachment.
¶ 18–19The Court noted that HDFC Bank Ltd. v. State of Bihar (2024 INSC 807) requires mens rea for such offences.
¶ 7The Court noted that S.N. Vijayalakshmi v. State of Karnataka (2025 INSC 917) holds that civil disputes must not be tainted as criminal.
¶ 10The Court considered Botla Koteswara Rao v. State of A.P. and Md. Ibrahim v. State of Bihar, which the petitioners cited on fraud and abuse of process.
¶ 8, 9Provisions in the judgment · 19 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 154Section 156Section 195Section 198Section 199Section 200Section 482
Indian Penal Code, 1860 11 provisions
Section 109Section 201Section 206Section 207Section 217Section 420Section 421Section 423Section 424Section 462Section 471Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 Section 138
04Reasoning
The Court held that the existence of a civil suit does not bar criminal prosecution where the complaint alleges a dishonest, criminal act.
¶ 20The Court found that the timing of the relinquishment deed, executed while the partition suit and SLP were pending and after execution was closed, together with the subsequent gift deed, raised allegations of dishonest intention.
¶ 18, 19, 21Whether mens rea existed is a question of fact for trial and cannot be decided at the quashing stage.
¶ 19–20On the affidavit objection, the Court found that no Section 156(3) prayer had been made, so the Priyanka Srivastava requirement did not apply, and the petitioners' reliance on it was rejected.
¶ 22–25The Court applied Bhajan Lal and found that the allegations do not fall within the category warranting quashing, as the complaint is not merely a vengeful one given the conduct of the parties and the decree passed against the accused.
¶ 25Since the petitioners' grounds raised disputed questions of fact, the Court held they must be addressed by the Trial Court.
¶ 2505Holding
The Court answered Issue 1 in the negative: the Trial Court did not err in taking cognizance and issuing process, and no interference under Section 482 CrPC is warranted.
¶ 25, 26On Issue 2, the Court held that the absence of an affidavit does not vitiate the complaint where no Section 156(3) prayer is made.
¶ 22–24Both criminal petitions (Crl.P. Nos. 3748/2022 and 5666/2022) are dismissed. The petitioners' grounds, including the civil nature of the dispute, lack of mens rea, and full satisfaction of the execution, are left to be decided at trial.
¶ 25, 26Original Court PDF
MRS. RADHIKA VASUDEVANvsMR. LALITHA MUKUNDAN
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
