01Facts
The five petitioners, claiming through Sheragar Laxma Bhovi, sought to quash notices dated 17.07.2021 issued by Respondent No. 2, the Assistant Executive Engineer, Minor Irrigation Department (Annexures H to H4).
¶ 1Their claim rested on a grant order dated 31.03.1954 in favour of Sheragar Laxma Bhovi (Annexure-B).
¶ 2The petitioners' title was said to have been declared in O.S. No. 96/1997, decreed on 30.07.2001, which became final after the State's appeal was dismissed for delay and the matter reached the Supreme Court.
DB para. 2The State disputed the grant and contended that the land in Sy. Nos. 52, 61 and 82 of Dattagalli Village, Mysore Taluk, was Government land: "Sarkari Kere" (Government Lake) classified as B-Kharab.
DB para. 2, DB paras 6, 4.8–4.9The Division Bench in W.A. No. 1333 of 2025, arising from W.P. No. 24304/2021, examined the original records and found no entry naming the petitioners or their predecessors as grantees.
DB paras 10–13The Division Bench held the Annexure-B photocopy unsigned by the competent authority, bearing only an "Amaldar" signature.
DB paras 10–13The Division Bench allowed the State's appeal, set aside the Writ Court's order, and dismissed that writ petition.
DB para. 22The petitioners do not dispute that the land covered by the grant shown in their later document (Annexure-F, Form No. VII, dated 13.11.1995) is recorded as "Lake" in Government records.
¶ 3The State contended that Annexure-F is also a shady document.
¶ 4–602Issues
i.1. Whether the present writ petition, seeking quashing of the notices dated 17.07.2021, is governed by and must be decided in line with the Division Bench judgment in W.A. No. 1333 of 2025.
¶ 2, 6ii.2. Whether a grant of land recorded as Government Lake (Sarkari Kere) can be sustained, even if a grant order were genuine.
¶ 4iii.3. Whether a title or grant claim founded on an order that is fabricated or obtained by fraud can support a writ of certiorari against Government action.
¶ 6, DB paras 13–1803Law Applied
The court relied principally on the binding Division Bench judgment in W.A. No. 1333 of 2025, which was reproduced and followed as the governing authority.
¶ 2, 6The Division Bench applied the maxim that "fraud unravels everything", under which a judgment, decree or order obtained by fraud or suppression of material facts is a nullity and may be challenged at any stage, as stated in Vishnu Vardhan v. State of U.P. (2025 SCC OnLine SC 1501).
DB paras 14–15The Division Bench applied Meghamala v. G. Narasimha Reddy (2010) 8 SCC 383, quoting paras 28–36 of that judgment, on the same principle that fraud vitiates a judgment, decree or order.
DB para. 16, quoting paras 28–36The Division Bench applied Hinch Lal Tiwari v. Kamala Devi, AIR 2001 SC 3215, under which tanks, ponds and similar community natural resources are "nature's bounty" protected under Article 21, so the Government should not grant such lands.
DB paras 19–20The Division Bench noted Jagpal Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR 2011 SC 1123, that unauthorised occupation cannot be regularised merely because it has subsisted for years, though this principle was argued by the AGA and not expressly relied upon in the holding.
DB para. 6.7Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961 Section 4
04Reasoning
The court held that the present petition raises the same issues as W.A. No. 1333 of 2025 and is therefore covered by that judgment.
¶ 2Applying the Division Bench's findings, the court noted that the petitioners themselves accept that the land in the grant is recorded as "Lake" in Government records.
¶ 3The Division Bench had found no corresponding entry in the original records for the grant, and that the Annexure-B copy was unsigned by the competent authority. This led it to conclude the grant order was fake, dubious and obtained by fraud on the Civil Court.
DB paras 12–13, 17–18On that basis, the Division Bench held the decree procured on such a document could not stand.
DB para. 17Even if the grant were genuine, the Government could not validly grant land reserved as a lake.
DB paras 19–20In the present matter, the court reviewed the Kannada text of Annexure-F, which the State argued was equally suspect, and found that paragraph 2 records no payment or date.
¶ 5The court concluded that Annexure-F was also a "shady document."
¶ 6Because the petitioners' claim depends on documents that are either fabricated or fraudulently obtained and relates to Government Lake land, no enforceable right supports the writ of certiorari sought against the notices.
¶ 605Holding
The court holds that, following the Division Bench in W.A. No. 1333 of 2025, the grant relied upon, whether Annexure-B or Annexure-F, cannot sustain the petitioners' claim, since it is either fraudulent and unsupported by the Government records or relates to land recorded as a Government Lake that cannot be granted.
¶ 2, 5–6The writ petition is dismissed as devoid of merits.
¶ 6The relief sought to quash the notices dated 17.07.2021 (Annexures H to H4) is refused.
¶ 1, 6The order does not record any direction on costs.
Original Court PDF
P NAGARAJ S/O DURUGAPPAvsSTATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
