Karnataka High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Less meritorious appointee cannot retain a post once a more meritorious candidate is appointed under tribunal order.

SMT. SHRUTHI Bv.THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Less meritorious appointee cannot retain a post once a more meritorious candidate is appointed under tribunal order.. SMT. SHRUTHI B vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Tribunal erred in dismissing the petitioner's Application No. 1107/2019 challenging her relief from service.

The court held

The Court held that the Tribunal did not err in dismissing Application No. 1107/2019. A less meritorious candidate, appointed earlier, cannot continue in a post once a more meritorious candidate is appointed under a competent Court or Tribunal order. The petitioner's failure to contest Application No. 6619/2016 and to seek accommodation relief therein barred her challenge to the consequential relief order.

It also directed

The writ petition was found devoid of merit and was dismissed. The Court made no further directions.

01Facts

The Karnataka Public Service Commission (KPSC) issued a recruitment notification dated 21.02.2015 for Horticulture Assistant posts. The petitioner and one Smt. Kalavathi applied.

¶ 3.1

The petitioner was selected per the final list dated 06.07.2016, was appointed on 16.11.2016, and reported for duty at Chamarajanagar. Kalavathi was not selected and filed Application No. 6619/2016 before the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal (KSAT).

¶ 3.2

The petitioner was arrayed as Respondent No. 4 in Application No. 6619/2016 and was served notice but did not contest it.

¶ 3.3–3.4, 6

On 11.08.2016, the Tribunal directed the KPSC to consider Kalavathi's candidature, treating her job-oriented Pre-University Diploma as equivalent to a two-year pre-university course.

¶ 3.5

Kalavathi was subsequently appointed, and the petitioner was relieved from service by order dated 02/04.01.2019.

¶ 3.6

The petitioner did not challenge the 2016 order. She instead filed Application No. 1107/2019, which the Tribunal dismissed on 07.03.2019. She then filed this writ petition under Article 226 seeking to quash that order.

¶ 2, 6

The petitioner contended that the relief was impermissible because she had served for over two years and, if Kalavathi was eligible, the petitioner should have been retained in the existing vacancy.

¶ 4

The State contended that Kalavathi was more meritorious but was initially excluded solely for lacking the regular pre-university qualification, and that the petitioner's relief followed from the Tribunal's order.

¶ 5

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Tribunal erred in dismissing the petitioner's Application No. 1107/2019 challenging her relief from service.

¶ 8

ii.2. Whether a less meritorious candidate, already appointed earlier, can claim continuance in a post when a more meritorious candidate is later appointed pursuant to a competent Court/Tribunal order.

¶ 7

iii.3. Whether the petitioner, having not contested Application No. 6619/2016 and having not sought accommodation relief therein, can challenge the consequential order of relief.

¶ 6–7

03Law Applied

Appointments to a sanctioned post must follow merit-based selection by the KPSC, so a more meritorious candidate's entitlement to that post prevails over a less meritorious incumbent's claim to continue.

¶ 7

Once a competent Court or Tribunal directs the appointment of such a candidate, the incumbent cannot claim continuance in the post, even if appointed earlier.

¶ 7

A party served with notice in a proceeding who does not contest it, and does not challenge the resulting order, cannot later attack the consequential action taken under that order.

¶ 6

Relief not sought in the earlier proceeding cannot be granted in a subsequent challenge to consequential action.

¶ 7

The writ court under Article 226 reviews the Tribunal's order for error and does not re-examine the merits of the underlying selection.

04Reasoning

The petitioner was served in Application No. 6619/2016 and admittedly did not contest it or challenge the 2016 order. Her relief from service was a direct consequence of that Tribunal order, and she filed a fresh application only after being relieved.

¶ 6

Her contention that the Tribunal ought to have directed the KPSC to accommodate her was rejected because she had never sought such relief as Respondent No. 4. On the merits of the competing claims, the Court applied the merit principle: the post had been sanctioned for a candidate found more meritorious, and Kalavathi's appointment followed a Tribunal direction that remedied her earlier exclusion. The petitioner's length of service and her prior appointment did not create a right to continue in a post meant for the more meritorious candidate.

¶ 5, 7

Having found no error in the Tribunal's approach, the Court held that the Tribunal correctly dismissed the petitioner's application.

¶ 8

05Holding

The Court held that the Tribunal did not err in dismissing Application No. 1107/2019. A less meritorious candidate, appointed earlier, cannot continue in a post once a more meritorious candidate is appointed under a competent Court or Tribunal order. The petitioner's failure to contest Application No. 6619/2016 and to seek accommodation relief therein barred her challenge to the consequential relief order.

¶ 6–8

The writ petition was found devoid of merit and was dismissed. The Court made no further directions.

¶ 8
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SMT. SHRUTHI BvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka High Court · November 06, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment