Supreme CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceProperty and Real Estate Law

Defendant cannot file additional written statement to introduce inconsistent pleas or retract admissions after trial commences.

Mondira Ghoshv.Chaitali Ghosh

Defendant cannot file additional written statement to introduce inconsistent pleas or retract admissions after trial commences.. Mondira Ghosh vs Chaitali Ghosh. Supreme Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether a defendant can be permitted to file an additional written statement under Order 8 Rule 9 of the CPC that introduces a plea inconsistent with and contradictory to the original written statement

The court held

The Court held that a defendant cannot use Order 8 Rule 9 to introduce an inconsistent case that retracts from original admissions once the trial has commenced

It also directed

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and set aside the High Court’s order dated 03.09.2025, thereby restoring the Trial Court’s order of 17.06.2025

01Facts

The Appellant (plaintiff) filed a title suit for declaration, eviction, and damages against the Respondent (defendant), alleging unlawful possession of the suit premises

¶ 5

In her original written statement filed on 08.12.2022, the defendant claimed she was a "bonafide co-sharer"

¶ 5

After issues were framed and trial commenced with the cross-examination of the plaintiff’s first witness (PW-1), the defendant filed an application under Order 8 Rule 9 of the CPC to submit an additional written statement and a counter-claim

¶ 6, 7

In this new pleading, the defendant shifted her stance, claiming she was a "tenant" under the plaintiff rather than a co-sharer

¶ 7

The Trial Court rejected the application, but the Calcutta High Court partially allowed it, permitting the additional written statement upon payment of costs, while disallowing the counter-claim

¶ 7, 8, 10

02Issues

i.1. Whether a defendant can be permitted to file an additional written statement under Order 8 Rule 9 of the CPC that introduces a plea inconsistent with and contradictory to the original written statement

¶ 2, 11

ii.2. Whether the filing of such an application after the commencement of trial constitutes an attempt to bypass the statutory restrictions imposed by the proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC

¶ 12

03Law Applied

Order 8 Rule 9 of the CPC, which restricts the filing of subsequent pleadings after the written statement unless required by the Court or in defense to a set-off/counter-claim

¶ 11

Order 6 Rule 7 of the CPC, which prohibits pleadings from raising new grounds of claim or allegations of fact inconsistent with previous pleadings except by way of amendment

¶ 7, 11

The proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC, which mandates that no application for amendment of pleadings shall be allowed after the trial has commenced unless the party could not have raised the matter earlier despite due diligence

¶ 9, 12

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 6Section 8

04Reasoning

The Court reasoned that the defendant’s attempt to change her status from a "co-sharer" to a "tenant" was a complete volte-face and a "retraction of her earlier stand"

¶ 11

This introduction of a totally inconsistent and contradictory position was found to be in direct violation of the mandate of Order 6 Rule 7

¶ 11

The Court criticized the High Court’s logic, noting that this was not a case of "inadvertent omission" but a deliberate attempt to fill a void after the trial had already progressed

¶ 11

The Court observed that since the trial had commenced and the witness (PW-1) had been cross-examined, the application was a "ploy" and an "abuse of process" designed to circumvent the strict embargo on amendments after the start of trial as stipulated in the proviso to Order 6 Rule 17

¶ 12

05Holding

The Court held that a defendant cannot use Order 8 Rule 9 to introduce an inconsistent case that retracts from original admissions once the trial has commenced

¶ 11, 13

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and set aside the High Court’s order dated 03.09.2025, thereby restoring the Trial Court’s order of 17.06.2025

¶ 14
Supreme Court

Original Court PDF

Mondira GhoshvsChaitali Ghosh

Supreme Court · May 26, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment