01Facts
The Petitioner, Greenlam Industries Limited, challenged two orders from the Patiala House Courts arising out of FIR No. 97/2025 (P.S. Special Cell).
¶ 1The FIR concerned an alleged investment fraud of about ₹2.14 crores.
¶ 2Transactions flagged on the NCRP portal were placed on hold, including ₹19,57,212 credited to the Petitioner's HDFC Bank account.
¶ 2The IO's report dated 12 October 2025 stated that the flagged transactions were yet to be verified, yet conveyed no objection to release subject to an indemnity bond.
¶ 3By order dated 14 October 2025, the JMFC-01 directed release on the premise that the amounts were traceable to the complainant, without notice to the Petitioner.
¶ 4HDFC Bank debited the amount on 22 October 2025 and transferred it to the complainant.
¶ 4The Petitioner stated that the sum was a payment from Bisnu Chem India Pvt. Ltd. under a Rate Contract for DFIA transfers, remitted by RTGS on 30 September 2025 (UTR ending 9966), and corroborated by HDFC Bank's credit confirmation.
¶ 5–7The Petitioner's application for intervention and restoration was dismissed by the JMFC-02 on 15 April 2026 on the ground that restoration would amount to impermissible review of a judicial order.
¶ 8During the writ proceedings, the State's status report and AU Small Finance Bank's affidavit showed that the transaction was erroneously tagged to the complainant's NCRP complaint due to a portal interface error, and that the complainant's transfers were distinct transactions (UTR ending 9962).
¶ 9–12The complainant had executed an indemnity bond dated 18 October 2025.
¶ 1802Issues
i.1. Whether the Magistrate's order dated 14 October 2025, directing release of ₹19,57,212 from the Petitioner's account without notice or verified tracing, can be sustained.
¶ 3, 4, 14ii.2. Whether the Magistrate was correct in dismissing the Petitioner's application for restoration on the ground that it amounted to review of a judicial order.
¶ 8, 19iii.3. Whether the Petitioner is entitled to restitution in the present proceedings or must pursue an independent remedy for recovery.
¶ 1503Law Applied
The Court invoked its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution read with Section 528 of the BNSS.
¶ 1Section 503 BNSS permits delivery of seized property to the person entitled to its possession.
¶ 15Section 144 CPC is a statutory recognition of a pre-existing rule of justice, equity and fair play, and restitution places a party in the position it would have occupied had the prejudicial order not been passed, including where a party's conduct induced an order later held unsustainable, as explained in South Eastern Coalfields Ltd. v. State of M.P., (2003) 8 SCC 648.
¶ 16Sri Rahul Chari v. State of Karnataka, W.P. No. 2865/2022 (Karnataka HC, 17 October 2022) set aside a transfer of funds from a third party's account made without hearing the account holder and directed restoration.
¶ 16The terms of the indemnity bond provide recourse against the recipient.
¶ 18Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 528Section 503
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 144
04Reasoning
The 14 October 2025 order rested on an identification that the IO's own report stated was unverified, and the Petitioner, whose funds were directly affected, was not heard.
¶ 14Subsequent banking records established that the ₹19,57,212 was remitted by Bisnu Chem, consistent with contemporaneous commercial documents, and that the transaction was erroneously linked to the complainant's NCRP complaint.
¶ 11–13The Court found no material linking the payment to the complainant's loss.
¶ 13The Magistrate's review-based rejection was held not to bar the High Court from setting aside the erroneous disbursement in supervisory jurisdiction.
¶ 19Although the complainant received the funds under a judicial order and was not at fault, he could not retain money shown to have been wrongly transferred.
¶ 17Merely quashing the order would not remedy the loss, so direct restoration was preferred over compelling the Petitioner to file separate recovery proceedings.
¶ 17The indemnity bond supported this course, as it contemplated recourse against the complainant.
¶ 18The Court limited its scope to the legality of the disbursement and restitution, leaving the liability of the banks and the investigating agency unadjudicated.
¶ 2005Holding
The release order dated 14 October 2025 is set aside only insofar as it authorised transfer of ₹19,57,212 from the Petitioner's account, and the Magistrate's order dated 15 April 2026 is also set aside.
¶ 19(i)–(ii)Restitution was granted as a matter of supervisory relief, and the Magistrate's review objection did not preclude the High Court from doing so.
¶ 19The Court directed the complainant, Respondent No. 2, to restore ₹19,57,212 to the Petitioner's HDFC Bank account within six weeks, with proof of remittance to the Trial Court within one week thereafter.
¶ 19(iii)The complainant's undertaking regarding property T-7/1002, TDI Lake Grove, Kundli, shall remain operative until restitution, subject to the existing rights of the co-owner and secured creditor, and is discharged on confirmation of full repayment.
¶ 19(iv)On non-compliance, the Petitioner may seek enforcement and other lawful remedies.
¶ 19(v)The petition was allowed, and pending applications were disposed of.
¶ 21Original Court PDF
Greenlam Industries LimitedvsState Of Nct Of Delhi & Anr.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
