01Facts
The respondent (plaintiff) filed CS (COMM.) 246/2021 before the District Judge (Commercial Court), North District, Rohini Courts, on 26.07.2021 to recover Rs.1,69,32,511.49 with interest for goods supplied
¶ 2Summons were issued on 24.12.2021 through multiple modes, returnable on 28.04.2022
¶ 3The respondent claimed service via WhatsApp on 16.02.2022 on mobile number 981880XXXX, said to belong to Mr. Manish Jha, the petitioner's Chief Business Officer
¶ 4–5The trial court directed the respondent to send the plaint and documents by email
¶ 5On 23.07.2022, the respondent emailed the plaint to five addresses: contact@vlccwellness.com, info@vlcc.co.in, subhendu.batra@vlccpersonalcare.com, regd.office@vlccwellness.com (the MCA-registered address), and kapindra.tripathi@vlccpersonalcare.com
¶ 6On 01.09.2022, the trial court held the petitioner served on 16.02.2022, struck off its defence under Order VIII Rule 10 CPC, and posted the matter for ex parte evidence
¶ 7The petitioner claimed it discovered the email in its spam folder on 19.10.2022, entered appearance on 22.11.2022, and sought recall
¶ 8On 07.07.2023, the trial court dismissed the recall application, relying on the High Court circular dated 17.01.2022 and holding Mr. Jha a principal officer under Order XXIX Rule 2(a) CPC
¶ 9The petitioner challenged both orders under Article 227 of the Constitution
¶ 902Issues
i.1. Whether service of summons via WhatsApp on 16.02.2022 constituted valid service upon the petitioner company.
¶ 20–21ii.2. Whether service of the plaint and summons by email on 23.07.2022 constituted valid service upon the petitioner, such that the 120-day limit under Order VIII CPC applied.
¶ 20, 22–26iii.3. Whether, upon valid service, the trial court was correct in striking off the petitioner's defence for failure to file a written statement within the statutory period, and in refusing recall.
¶ 27–2803Law Applied
The court applied Order V Rule 2 CPC, which requires summons to be accompanied by a copy of the plaint, so that a WhatsApp summons without the plaint is defective
¶ 21It referred to Order XXIX Rule 2(a) CPC, which governs service on a company, as argued by the parties, but did not decide whether Mr. Jha was a principal officer, since the 16.02.2022 service was held defective
¶ 11, 14, 21It applied the principle that a party must maintain continuous access to the email address declared on the MCA portal, and that a litigant cannot disclaim such an address without taking steps to correct it
¶ 23It relied on SCG Contracts India Pvt. Ltd. v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., (2019) 12 SCC 210, which holds that the 120-day period under amended Order VIII Rule 1 CPC is mandatory and cannot be extended beyond that period
¶ 18, 26–27The court reiterated that its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 does not extend to re-appreciating disputed questions of fact
¶ 25Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
The court held the 16.02.2022 WhatsApp service defective because the record did not show the plaint accompanied the summons, and the trial court had itself ordered fresh summons on 28.04.2022
¶ 21It then examined the 23.07.2022 email service. Although the petitioner disputed three addresses as belonging to sister concerns and two as belonging to employees, the court found the MCA-registered address (regd.office@vlccwellness.com) decisive. The petitioner offered no material showing it lacked access to that address, nor had it corrected the MCA record
¶ 23The four other addresses appeared in the memo of parties and were not challenged until the recall application
¶ 24The court therefore held that the respondent had discharged its burden of communicating the plaint, and it declined to disturb the trial court's factual finding under Article 227
¶ 25Because the defective WhatsApp service did not defeat the valid email service, the court treated 23.07.2022 as the operative service date
¶ 26The 120-day period expired on 20.11.2022, while the petitioner's recall application was filed on 22.11.2022, and it showed no cogent reason for the delay
¶ 27The court's holding rests on the email service and the statutory timeline; it expressly did not rest on the validity of service through Mr. Jha
¶ 21, 2605Holding
The court held that service by WhatsApp on 16.02.2022 was defective under Order V Rule 2 CPC, but that the petitioner was validly served on 23.07.2022 by email, including at its MCA-registered address
¶ 21, 23, 26, 28Because the 120-day period under Order VIII CPC expired before the petitioner's recall application, the petitioner forfeited its right to file a written statement
¶ 27–28The petition under Article 227 is dismissed, and pending applications are dismissed. The trial court's orders dated 01.09.2022 and 07.07.2023 stand affirmed
¶ 25, 29Original Court PDF
Vlcc Personal Care LimitedvsSudhir Solvent Private Limited
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
