01Facts
The tenant, N C Mittal, challenged the Additional Rent Controller’s order dismissing his application for leave to defend and directing eviction from a room measuring 190 sq. ft. on the ground floor of Property No. 4606/13, Ansari Road, Delhi.
¶ 1–2The landlord sought possession to start a guest-house business. The tenant alleged that the parties’ site plans differed, that the property’s residential character precluded the proposed use, and that the landlord had concealed alternative properties.
¶ 7–12The High Court heard the parties’ arguments on 2 November 2026; after the tenant sought a fresh hearing through new counsel, the Court declined to reopen arguments and decided the petition on the submissions already made.
¶ 3–602Issues
i.1. Whether the discrepancy between the parties’ site plans, including the tenant’s claim to an additional bathroom area, raised a triable issue warranting leave to defend.
¶ 28–37ii.2. Whether the landlord’s proposed guest-house use, given the alleged residential character of the property, undermined the bona fides of its requirement.
¶ 38–40iii.3. Whether the tenant’s allegation that the landlord had concealed alternative accommodation raised a triable issue.
¶ 41iv.4. Whether the Controller’s order disclosed an error warranting interference under the High Court’s revisional jurisdiction under Section 25-B(8) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958.
¶ 20–26, 42–4303Law Applied
Section 25-B(8) of the Delhi Rent Control Act confers supervisory and revisional, not appellate, jurisdiction; the High Court does not reappraise the evidence merely to substitute its view for the Rent Controller’s, and interference is warranted for an error apparent, jurisdictional error, material irregularity, perversity, manifest illegality, or a material plea left unadjudicated.
¶ 20–26Sarla Ahuja v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd., (1998) 8 SCC 119; Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Dilbahar Singh, (2014) 9 SCC 78; Abid-Ul-Islam v. Inder Sain Dua, (2022) 6 SCC 30.
¶ 20–26Under Section 25-B, leave to defend is required where the tenant discloses facts which, if proved, could disentitle the landlord to eviction; vague assertions or facts that would not affect the entitlement do not suffice. A landlord’s prima facie showing of bona fide requirement attracts the presumption recognised in Sarla Ahuja.
¶ 27Section 19(2) protects a tenant against specified misuse of possession following eviction, and Section 14(7) postpones execution of an eviction order for the statutory period.
¶ 27, 40Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
delhi rent control act, 1958 Section 14Section 19
04Reasoning
The Court found that the tenant’s original leave-to-defend affidavit did not specify how the landlord’s site plan was inaccurate and did not dispute the description of the tenancy as one room; the claim to a 5-by-5-foot bathroom appeared only in the rejoinder and, at most, concerned the tenancy’s extent, not the identity of the premises or the landlord’s requirement for the property as a whole.
¶ 32–37The other tenant’s case, in which the plans depicted materially different premises, was therefore distinguishable.
¶ 28–29, 37As to proposed use, the Controller had considered evidence of commercial and mixed use on Ansari Road. The tenant’s reliance on a 1994 order was undermined by his own recorded position in that proceeding that the premises were commercial and were rented for commercial use; whether permissions were needed for a guest house was for the landlord and the relevant authorities, not a triable issue in these proceedings.
¶ 38–40Finally, the tenant identified no address or particulars of any alleged alternative property, and the balance-sheet value of the landlord’s assets did not establish that another property was available. The Court accordingly found no reviewable defect in the Controller’s decision-making process.
¶ 41–4205Holding
The High Court held that none of the tenant’s grounds raised a triable issue or established a basis for revisional interference under Section 25-B(8).
¶ 42–43It dismissed the revision petition as without merit and disposed of any pending applications.
¶ 44–45Original Court PDF
N C MittalvsM/S Madhumala Properties Pvt Ltd
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
