01Facts
The petitioner, an Assistant Administrative Officer at the Karampura Branch of the respondent, a nationalised general insurer, issued Cover Note No. 010401 for a bus on 02.03.2001 at about 2.15 p.m.
¶ 3The premium was booked under the Agency Code of Ms. Seema Arora and the Development Officer code of Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor.
¶ 3The bus met with an accident on 03.03.2001, killing a child.
¶ 4The cheque was accounted for and the cover note underwritten on 05.03.2001.
¶ 5The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal awarded compensation against the respondent, which was satisfied.
¶ 6A 2005 vigilance inquiry concluded that the cover note was issued after the accident and backdated.
¶ 9A charge-sheet dated 01.05.2006 framed three charges: (1) ante-dating the cover note; (2) allowing 20% NCB without previous insurance details; and (3) running a dummy agency in the name of Ms. Seema Arora.
¶ 10–11The Inquiry Officer held Charges 1 and 2 not proved, giving the benefit of doubt, and held Charge 3 proved.
¶ 18The Appointing Authority, without recording disagreement or giving the petitioner an opportunity to respond, held him guilty of all three charges and imposed demotion from Assistant Manager (Scale-II) to Administrative Officer (Scale-I).
¶ 21, 84, 91The Appellate Authority (16.04.2012) and the Chairman-cum-Managing Director (25.02.2013) upheld the penalty on different grounds.
¶ 22–23The petitioner first challenged the 2011 order in W.P.(C) 2531/2014, withdrew it with liberty, and filed the present petition.
¶ 2402Issues
i.1. Whether the writ petition is maintainable under Article 226 despite the petitioner not holding a civil post under Article 311.
¶ 36–38ii.2. Whether the petition is barred by delay and laches.
¶ 39iii.3. Whether the Inquiry Officer's finding on Charge No. 3 (dummy agency) is sustainable.
¶ 35(iii), 40–74iv.4. Whether the Appointing Authority's Order dated 19.07.2011 complies with Rule 26(2) of the CDA Rules and the principles of natural justice.
¶ 35(iv), 75–97v.5. Whether the Appellate Authority's Order dated 16.04.2012 and the Chairman-cum-MD's Order dated 25.02.2013 are sustainable.
¶ 35(v), 98–113vi.6. Whether the matter merits remand.
¶ 35(vi), 114–11803Law Applied
The court applied Article 226 of the Constitution, holding that the respondent, being Government-owned and acting under the CDA Rules, is amenable to writ jurisdiction, including review for natural justice and fair treatment, as recognised in Apparel Export Promotion Council v. A.K. Chopra.
¶ 37–38On disciplinary findings, the High Court may examine whether a conclusion is unsupported by any evidence, and suspicion cannot substitute proof, as laid down in Union of India v. H.C. Goel, together with Sher Bahadur v. Union of India requiring evidence linking the officer to the misconduct.
¶ 43–44Statements recorded during investigation, without the maker being examined, are not admissible evidence in the inquiry, and suspicion is no substitute for proof, as relied upon in Kuldeep Singh v. Commissioner of Police and Roop Singh Negi v. Punjab National Bank.
¶ 51–52, 69Under Rule 26(2) of the CDA Rules, the Competent Authority may disagree with the Inquiry Officer only by recording reasons and its own findings, and natural justice requires tentative reasons to be communicated and an opportunity to be given, as laid down in Punjab National Bank v. Kunj Behari Misra and Yoginath D. Bagde v. State of Maharashtra.
¶ 90–94Rule 37(2) of the CDA Rules requires the Appellate Authority to consider procedural compliance, justification of findings, and adequacy of penalty, with reasons, per Ram Chander v. Union of India.
¶ 98, 104On remand, Kunj Behari Misra and Yoginath D. Bagde were applied to assess whether remand serves any purpose.
¶ 116–11804Reasoning
The court held the writ maintainable because the challenge concerns natural justice and fair treatment, which the respondent's own cited authority recognises as reviewable.
¶ 38The petition was held timely, as the petitioner acted diligently after receiving the 2013 order.
¶ 39On Charge 3, the court found no admissible evidence: Sh. Rajneesh Kapoor was never examined, and his recorded statement described Ms. Seema Arora as a genuine agent working under him.
¶ 48–54The claim that Ms. Seema Arora was untraceable rested on a single registered letter with no proof of dispatch or delivery.
¶ 55–56The Presenting Officer's own witness confirmed that she was a real agent who visited the office.
¶ 59–60The handwriting inference was unsupported because the original cover note was not produced and the Vigilance Officer could not verify the photocopy.
¶ 61–62The "no explanation" premise was contradicted by the petitioner's recorded explanation during the vigilance inquiry.
¶ 63The "direct client book" premise was contradicted by the Senior Branch Manager's statement and the control register.
¶ 64The Appointing Authority's reversal of Charges 1 and 2 lacked Rule 26(2) reasons, relied on matters outside the charge-sheet (Cover Note 010402 and third-party cheques), and gave the petitioner no opportunity to respond.
¶ 84–97The Appellate and Memorial Orders were held defective because the Appellate Authority ignored Rule 26(2) and considered only Charge 3, while the Chairman-cum-MD justified the penalty on the timing of the cover note, which was the subject of Charge 1, found not proved.
¶ 100–112Because the findings were inconsistent across three tiers, no reasoned, consistent basis for penalty survived.
¶ 112–113Remand was refused given the 2001 misconduct, the petitioner's age, the exoneration on the entire evidence for Charges 1 and 2, and the absence of evidence on Charge 3.
¶ 115–11805Holding
The writ petition is maintainable and timely.
¶ 38–39The finding on Charge 3 is unsustainable, and the Appointing Authority's Order dated 19.07.2011 violated Rule 26(2) of the CDA Rules and natural justice.
¶ 113, 119The Appellate Order dated 16.04.2012 and the Order dated 25.02.2013 are not sustainable and do not cure the defects.
¶ 113, 119All three orders are quashed. The respondent is directed to: (i) treat the petitioner as continuing as Assistant Manager (Scale-II) without interruption and re-fix his pay from 19.07.2011 with admissible increments; (ii) pay arrears of pay and allowances; (iii) recompute retiral benefits if he has superannuated; and (iv) comply within twelve weeks, failing which amounts carry simple interest at 6% per annum.
¶ 119–120Remand is refused.
¶ 118Original Court PDF
S.K. AnandvsOriental Insurance Company Ltd.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
