Delhi High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceContract Law

Delhi HC Sets Aside Rs 7.5 Lakh Decree Against Woman Who Could Not Deposit 50%, Sends Defence To Trial

Ms.Mili Singhv.M/S Celebrations

Delhi HC Sets Aside Rs 7.5 Lakh Decree Against Woman Who Could Not Deposit 50%, Sends Defence To Trial. Ms.Mili Singh vs M/S Celebrations. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the conditional grant of leave to defend, subject to deposit of 50% of the principal amount, was justified on the facts.

The court held

The conditional leave to defend dated 28.11.2020 was unjustified; the 50% deposit condition is set aside and leave to defend is held to be unconditional.

It also directed

The decree dated 01.03.2021 is set aside as unsustainable.

The appeal is allowed. The parties are to appear before the Judge, South-East District, Saket Courts, on 26.11.2026. The Defendant shall file her written statement within thirty days thereafter, and the suit is to be tried on merits.

Pending applications are disposed of.

01Facts

The Plaintiff, M/s Celebrations (a sole proprietorship of Sumit Batra), sued the Defendant, Mili Singh, under Order XXXVII CPC for Rs. 7,50,000 with interest at 18%, alleging that the sum was invested in a portfolio scheme that promised 10% monthly returns.

¶ 2–4

The Plaintiff relied on a cheque no. 820783 dated 25.06.2018, which was dishonoured for insufficient funds, and on a s. 138 NI Act complaint.

¶ 5–7

The Defendant contested the suit, asserting that the Rs. 7,50,000 was a loan of Rs. 1,44,500 taken for her business, that the Plaintiff routed Rs. 3,00,000 through her account for "tax reasons" and withdrew it via a blank cheque, that five signed blank cheques were given as security, and that the impugned cheque was misused.

¶ 8, 13–18

The Trial Court found that the bank statement showed credits of Rs. 4,44,500 with only Rs. 75,000 shown as repaid, that the cheque series was doubtful, and that triable issues existed.

¶ 20–22

By order dated 28.11.2020, leave to defend was granted conditional on depositing 50% of the principal in FDR form within four weeks.

¶ 23

The Defendant did not comply, citing lack of funds.

¶ 24

By order dated 01.03.2021, the Trial Court decreed the suit for Rs. 7,50,000 with pendente lite interest at 9% and future interest at 6%.

¶ 25

The Defendant appealed under s. 96 read with Order 43 Rule 1A CPC against both orders.

¶ 1, 26

In the s. 138 complaint, the Defendant was acquitted on 29.07.2020.

¶ 29, 40

02Issues

i.1. Whether the conditional grant of leave to defend, subject to deposit of 50% of the principal amount, was justified on the facts.

¶ 34

ii.2. Whether the consequential decree dated 01.03.2021, passed solely for non-deposit, is sustainable.

¶ 45

03Law Applied

The Court applied Order XXXVII Rule 3(5) CPC, which governs leave to defend in summary suits.

¶ 35

A defendant raising triable issues indicating a fair or reasonable defence is ordinarily entitled to unconditional leave, while conditions such as deposits may be imposed only where good faith or genuineness is doubtful and must not be so severe as to shut out a genuine defence, as held in IDBI Trusteeship Services Ltd. v. Hubtown Ltd., (2017) 1 SCC 568.

¶ 35

Leave to defend, with or without conditions, is the ordinary rule and refusal is the exception, and conditions require strong reasons, as reiterated in B.L. Kashyap and Sons Ltd. v. JMS Steels and Power Corporation, (2022) 3 SCC 294.

¶ 36

The acquittal in the parallel s. 138 proceedings, arising from the same transaction, is a relevant circumstance in assessing the bona fides and triability of the defence.

¶ 41

A decree under Order XXXVII Rule 3(6)(b) CPC falls with the invalid condition on which it was founded.

¶ 25, 45

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 96Section 43

Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 Section 138

04Reasoning

The Defendant disputed the nature of the transaction itself, not merely the amount: she pleaded a friendly loan, bank-routed transfers made at the Plaintiff's instance, a withdrawal through a blank cheque, and security cheques that were later misused.

¶ 37

The issues, considered cumulatively, concerned the nature of the transaction, the advance of Rs. 7,50,000, the purpose of banking transfers, the alleged cash component, repayment, and the circumstances of the cheque. These were substantive triable issues going to the root of the Plaintiff's claim rather than bald denials.

¶ 43

The Court relied on the Trial Court's own observations that the sole evidence was oral, that the cash component lacked documentation, and that the money-flow narrative was a matter for evidence.

¶ 38–39

The acquittal in CT 7277/18, which found no transactions showing the Defendant was engaged in financial services or share dealing, and the handwriting variance on the cheque, supported the blank-cheque defence.

¶ 40, 42

On this basis, the defence was held to be bona fide and to raise triable issues. A 50% deposit was unduly severe and unsupported by strong reasons, and the condition could not stand.

¶ 44

Because the decree rested solely on non-compliance with that condition, it was also unsustainable.

¶ 45

The judgment does not adjudicate the Defendant's objections on maintainability of a suit by an unregistered proprietorship, limitation, or non-production of original documents, leaving these for trial.

¶ 8–10, 32

05Holding

The conditional leave to defend dated 28.11.2020 was unjustified; the 50% deposit condition is set aside and leave to defend is held to be unconditional.

¶ 44, 46

The decree dated 01.03.2021 is set aside as unsustainable.

¶ 45–46

The appeal is allowed. The parties are to appear before the Judge, South-East District, Saket Courts, on 26.11.2026. The Defendant shall file her written statement within thirty days thereafter, and the suit is to be tried on merits.

¶ 47

Pending applications are disposed of.

¶ 48
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Ms.Mili SinghvsM/S Celebrations

Delhi High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment