01Facts
The appellants, parents of Sonam (deceased), filed a compensation claim before the Railway Claims Tribunal, Principal Bench, Delhi, which the Tribunal dismissed by judgment dated 11.01.2023 in OA/II(u)/DLI/68/2020.
¶ 1The appeal was filed 800 days late. The appellants, residents of District Hapur and described as poor and illiterate persons from an economically weaker section, attributed the delay to lack of funds and difficulty in contacting counsel.
CM Appl. para. 2The Court condoned the delay, relying on Mohsina v. Union of India (delay of 804 days) and Brijesh Kumar v. Union of India (delay of 1326 days).
CM Appl. paras. 3–5On 13.08.2019, the deceased travelled from Delhi to Hapur by Train No. 15274 (Raxaul Express) with a companion. Her monthly season ticket had expired two days earlier, and she had bought journey ticket No. 00517904 for two passengers.
¶ 2The appellants' case was that, due to crowding, she was standing near the gate when she fell into the river while the train crossed a bridge near Dasna Railway Station. Her body was later recovered from the river.
¶ 2The Tribunal held that she was not a bona fide passenger because no ticket was found in the initial search and the inquest recorded recovery of articles as "nil." It also disbelieved the co-passenger and held there was no "accidental fall."
¶ 3The respondent relied on the absence of a separate recovery memo, a DRM report attributing the incident to the deceased's own negligence, and the absence of any Dasna station report.
¶ 502Issues
i.1. Whether the delay of 800 days in filing the appeal should be condoned.
CM Appl. paras. 4–5ii.2. Whether the deceased was travelling as a bona fide passenger on Train No. 15274 at the relevant time.
¶ 6iii.3. Whether the death resulted from an accidental fall from a train carrying passengers, constituting an "untoward incident" under Section 123(c)(2) of the Railways Act, 1989.
¶ 1003Law Applied
On delay, the Court applied the principle that sufficient cause must be shown, read liberally given the beneficial nature of the legislation, and followed Mohsina and Brijesh Kumar.
CM Appl. paras. 3–4On bona fide travel, the Court applied Union of India v. Rina Devi, (2019) 3 SCC 572, under which the claimant bears an initial burden that may be discharged by an affidavit, the burden then shifting to the Railways; absence of a ticket on the deceased's person does not by itself negate bona fide travel.
¶ 9On untoward incident, the Court applied Section 123(c)(2) of the Railways Act, 1989 and Section 124-A, as interpreted in Union of India v. Prabhakaran Vijaya Kumar, (2008) 9 SCC 527. Section 124-A is a no-fault provision, and "accidental falling of a passenger from a train carrying passengers" is to be interpreted liberally.
¶ 10, 12Victim negligence does not take a case outside Section 124-A unless one of the statutory proviso exceptions applies, as reiterated in Rina Devi.
¶ 10, 12The Court relied on the Railway Commercial Circular No. 5 of 2016 on the validity period of tickets, which the Tribunal had invoked.
¶ 8Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 Section 23
Railways Act, 1989 Section 123
04Reasoning
On delay, the Court accepted the appellants' poverty and lack of access to counsel as sufficient cause, consistent with the approach in the precedents it cited.
CM Appl. paras. 2–4On bona fide travel, the Court held that the Tribunal conflated the factum of ticket issuance with the circumstances of its recovery. The Railways' own Ticket Verification Report confirmed that ticket No. 00517904 was issued at ATVM, Delhi, at 14:18 hours on 13.08.2019 for the Delhi–Hapur journey.
¶ 7The missing recovery memo and the initial "nil" entry in the inquest went to the credibility of recovery, not to the verified issuance. The Tribunal's reliance on the Circular and an online timetable was also weak, because the appellants showed that most listed trains originated from Anand Vihar rather than Delhi Junction, and the Railways did not produce the actual Train Signal Register for 13.08.2019.
¶ 8The appellants therefore discharged their initial burden under Rina Devi, and the Railways produced no rebuttal.
¶ 9On untoward incident, the Court gave weight to the RPF Roznamcha entry, which recorded information from the Dasna Station Master about a girl falling from Train No. 15274, and to the panchnama recording recovery of the body near the river and railway bridge. These contemporaneous records supported the claim, and the Tribunal had not considered them.
¶ 10The absence of a Dasna station report and the Guard's lack of knowledge did not defeat the claim, since the Roznamcha itself reflected the Station Master's information.
¶ 11The DRM's finding of negligence did not bring the death within any proviso exception to Section 124-A, and the respondent produced no evidence of self-inflicted injury or another statutory exception.
¶ 1205Holding
The delay of 800 days is condoned for sufficient cause, and CM Appl. 40201/2025 is disposed of.
CM Appl. paras. 5–6The deceased is held to have been a bona fide passenger on Train No. 15274, and her death is held to be an accidental fall from a train carrying passengers within Section 123(c)(2) and Section 124-A, not excluded by negligence.
¶ 9, 10, 12The impugned judgment dated 11.01.2023 is set aside, and the matter is remanded to the Railway Claims Tribunal to assess compensation in accordance with law. The Tribunal is directed to ensure disbursement within two months of receipt of the order, and the matter is listed before the Tribunal on 11.12.2026. The appeal is allowed and disposed of, and a copy is to be sent to the Tribunal.
¶ 13 · ¶ 14–15Original Court PDF
Hari Singh & Anr.vsUnion Of India
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
