01Facts
The Assessing Officer (AO) issued a show-cause notice under Section 148A(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 dated 31.03.2025 against the petitioner, alleging it received an accommodation entry of Rs.28,975 from Sh. Rishu Bansal and family.
¶ 1–3The notice relied on a Tax Evasion Petition (TEP) against JSM Overseas. Sh. Rishu Bansal is also the proprietor of Radha Krishna Industries, the counterparty to the petitioner's transaction.
¶ 3–4The petitioner replied on 26.05.2025, stating it had sold cotton waste to Radha Krishna Industries. It supported this with three invoices (Nos. 4939, 4958, 4964, aggregating Rs.28,975), bank statements, GST returns, stock register, and a statutorily audited set of accounts.
¶ 5, 16The AO rejected the reply by order dated 30.06.2025 under Section 148A(3), relying on the family's identification as entry providers and the absence of proof of commercial rationale or delivery.
¶ 6A notice under Section 148 dated 30.06.2025 followed. The Additional Commissioner (Specified Authority) approved the proceedings.
¶ 8, 28The petitioner had declared total income of Rs.62,68,970 on a turnover of Rs.71,80,78,529.
¶ 19The petitioner challenged the proceedings as arbitrary and without jurisdiction.
02Issues
i.1. Whether the AO was justified in rejecting the petitioner's explanation, where the disputed sales of Rs.28,975 were recorded, banked, and reflected in GST filings and the return of income, such that no income could be said to have escaped assessment.
¶ 17–18ii.2. Whether the AO could initiate reassessment on the basis of the possibility of unearthing other unassessed income, absent any finding in the Section 148A(3) order of further bogus transactions or entries.
¶ 21–24iii.3. Whether the Specified Authority's approval under Section 151 was a mechanical act or required independent application of mind to whether the case was "fit" for reopening.
¶ 25–2703Law Applied
Section 148A(3) of the Act requires the AO to decide, on the basis of material on record and the assessee's reply, whether a fit case exists for issuing a Section 148 notice, with prior approval of the specified authority.
¶ 24Section 151 requires the specified authority's prior approval, and approval is not mechanical but demands judicious, pragmatic application of mind.
¶ 25–26Chhugamal Rajpal v. S.P. Chaliha, (1971) 1 SCC 453: the sanctioning authority must itself be satisfied on the material that the case is fit, and statutory safeguards are not mere formalities. The Court extended this principle to Sections 148A(3) and 151.
¶ 27The jurisdictional fact is the income that has escaped assessment as of the date of the order, and speculative possibility of other unearthed income cannot sustain reopening.
¶ 23–24Provisions in the judgment · 4
Income Tax Act, 1961 Section 148Section 148ASection 44ABSection 151
04Reasoning
The only finding in the Section 148A(3) order was the receipt of Rs.28,975 from the Radha Krishna Industries family.
¶ 15The AO himself accepted that the petitioner had demonstrated recorded sales, bank receipts and GST filings. Where the receipts were banked and shown as sales, no income could be said to have escaped assessment.
¶ 17Even assuming the counterparty was an entry provider, a transaction with such a party is not necessarily bogus. The AO's reasoning in para 3.3 of the order treated the petitioner as an evader merely by association.
¶ 20Against a declared turnover of about Rs.71.8 crore and declared income of about Rs.62.7 lakh, the three fragmented invoices were implausible as a bogus sales pattern.
¶ 19The Revenue's argument that other income might be unearthed during reassessment was rejected. Such possibility cannot justify reopening unless the order records a finding of further bogus transactions or material supporting it.
¶ 22–24The Specified Authority was required to examine whether a meagre sum of Rs.28,975 warranted deployment of resources, applying the "fit case" standard.
¶ 25–27Because neither the AO nor the Specified Authority applied their minds to the reply and the facts, the proceedings were found to be without jurisdiction, arbitrary, and a source of harassment.
¶ 2805Holding
The AO failed to consider the petitioner's reply objectively, and the Specified Authority granted approval without examining the facts and law, rendering the reopening without jurisdiction and bad for want of application of mind.
¶ 28The writ petition is allowed. The order dated 30.06.2025 under Section 148A(3), the corresponding Section 148 notice dated 30.06.2025, and all proceedings in furtherance thereof are quashed.
¶ 29–30Pending applications are disposed of. The Court did not decide the Revenue's contention regarding the Rs.50 lakh limit for extended limitation under Section 149, which was raised only in argument.
¶ 10, 31Original Court PDF
Home Textiles India LimitedvsThe Commissioner Of Income Tax Delhi
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
