Delhi High CourtAdministrative and Public LawTax Law

Centre Can Decline Anti-Dumping Duty Despite Positive Recommendation: Delhi HC Upholds Polystyrene Decision

Supreme Petrochem Ltd.v.Union Of India And Anr.

Centre Can Decline Anti-Dumping Duty Despite Positive Recommendation: Delhi HC Upholds Polystyrene Decision. Supreme Petrochem Ltd. vs Union Of India And Anr.. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether Rule 4(1)(d), Rule 17 and Rule 18(1) of the Rules of 1995, read with s. 9A of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975, are ultra vires Article 9.1 of the WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement, 1994 and/or Article 14 of the Constitution.

The court held

Issue 1 is answered in the negative: Rule 4(1)(d), Rule 17 and Rule 18(1), read with s. 9A, are neither ultra vires Article 9.1 of the 1994 Agreement nor violative of Article 14.

It also directed

On Issue 2, the CG's second-stage exercise is legislative or quasi-legislative, and it requires neither a redetermination of the DA's findings nor a further oral hearing.

On Issue 3, the CG may depart from a positive DA recommendation on public-interest grounds, provided the discretion rests on relevant material with a rational nexus to the conclusion and is free of mala fides; the CG's decision here met that standard.

The court expressly declined to rest its decision on the existence of an alternative appellate remedy under s. 9C, given the pending question of its amendment. The petition was dismissed. Connected petitions W.P.(C) 16640/2022, 16647/2022 and 17186/2022 were delinked because they concern products other than Polystyrene, and were directed to be listed before the Roster Bench on 08.01.2027 along with W.P.(C) 9754/2026.

01Facts

The petitioner, a domestic producer of Polystyrene, was one of several domestic producers who sought anti-dumping duty (ADD) on imports of the subject good from Iran, Malaysia, Singapore, Chinese Taipei, UAE and the USA.

¶ 2

The Designated Authority (DA) recorded a positive final finding on 12.06.2020, recommending country- and producer-wise definitive ADD under Rule 17(1)(b) read with Rule 4(d) of the Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Anti-Dumping Duty on Dumped Articles and for Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995.

¶ 3

By Office Memorandum dated 11.11.2020 (the "Impugned OM"), the Central Government (CG) declined to impose any ADD.

¶ 3

The petitioner sought: (a) a declaration that s. 9A(1) of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 and Rule 18 are ultra vires Article 14; (b) certiorari quashing the Impugned OM; and (c) mandamus directing implementation of the final findings.

¶ 4

The CG's stated grounds were that one of the three domestic producers had ceased operations following a fire, that the domestic industry's capacity utilisation had declined, and that NITI Aayog and other agencies had assessed the demand-supply impact of duty, which would affect downstream users.

¶ 43–44 · ¶ 10.9

The petitioner contended that the DA had already considered these matters.

¶ 9.2

02Issues

i.1. Whether Rule 4(1)(d), Rule 17 and Rule 18(1) of the Rules of 1995, read with s. 9A of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975, are ultra vires Article 9.1 of the WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement, 1994 and/or Article 14 of the Constitution.

¶ 12(A) · ¶ 13–23

ii.2. Whether the action of the CG in declining to implement the positive recommendation violated the principles of natural justice.

¶ 12(B) · ¶ 24–35

iii.3. Whether the scope of the CG's discretion permits it to depart from a positive recommendation of the DA, and what standard governs the review of that departure.

¶ 12(C) · ¶ 36–49

03Law Applied

Section 9A(1) of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 provides that the CG "may" impose ADD not exceeding the margin of dumping.

¶ 6

Article 9.1 of the 1994 Agreement is read as conferring a permissive discretion on the importing Member's authorities, so that imposition is "desirable" but not obligatory even when all requirements are met.

¶ 14–15

Rule 17 makes the DA's findings recommendatory, and Rule 18(1) confers the levy power on the CG.

¶ 20, 25

The DA's quasi-judicial investigation does not bind the CG, and the CG's second-stage power is legislative or quasi-legislative.

¶ 26, 30, 35

Under Indian Express Newspapers v. Union of India, the court applied a four-part test: competence under the parent statute, consistency with fundamental rights, rational nexus to relevant material, and absence of extraneous considerations or mala fides.

¶ 40

The "person who hears must decide" principle applies only where the statute requires it.

¶ 31

Reliance Industries v. DA is relied upon as to the DA's quasi-judicial character, though distinguished as obiter on the CG's power.

¶ 26, 28–29

Balco Employees Union and R.K. Garg are relied upon for judicial deference in economic policy.

¶ 21, 48

Andhra Petrochemicals is relied upon for the recommendatory character of the DA's findings.

¶ 20

The Saurashtra Chemicals order, which arose from dismissal of SLPs in limine, does not declare binding law under Article 141, citing State of U.P. v. Synthetics Ltd. and U.P. SRTC v. Omaditya Verma.

¶ 32

Section 9C (appeal to CESTAT) is noted, and the effect of the 2023 amendment is observed to be sub judice.

¶ 32–34

Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Customs Tariff Act, 1975 Section 9

Central Excise Act, 1944 Section 3

Special Economic Zones Act, 2005 Section 2

Customs Act,1962 Section 129

04Reasoning

Article 9.1 does not prescribe any institutional structure for decision-making. Footnote 3 to Article 2.2.1 indicates only that "authorities" means senior-level authorities, so a two-tier domestic structure, with a technical DA and a policy-level CG, is not inconsistent with Article 9.1.

¶ 17–19

The statutory "may" in s. 9A(1) reflects the same discretion, and the DA's recommendation is advisory under Rule 17.

¶ 20

The discretion is not unguided for Article 14 purposes, as it is anchored to the DA's findings, public interest, and the object of remedying unfair trade without protectionism.

¶ 21

The DA's investigation is classified as quasi-judicial, and the petitioner had a full hearing at that stage.

¶ 26

The CG's second-stage decision considers public interest rather than the commercial interests of the parties, and its character is closer to policy formulation, so it is legislative or quasi-legislative.

¶ 30

Since neither s. 9A(1) nor Rule 18(1) provides for a further hearing, and the rules show that the legislature knows how to mandate oral hearings (Rule 6(6)), a second hearing cannot be read in.

¶ 31

The argument that the CG was obliged to disclose its material is rejected because disclosure to the affected party is not the applicable standard at this stage.

¶ 39, 47

The CG's reasons were distinct from the DA's mandate. The DA examines dumping, injury and causal link, whereas the CG considers downstream interests, alternative supply, and the risk of a duopoly.

¶ 41–42

The CG's reliance on the closure of a producer and the NITI Aayog assessment provided a rational and direct nexus to its conclusion.

¶ 43–44

The court accepted that the DA had attributed the industry's decline to dumping, but held that the CG's assessment was forward-looking and addressed future supply adequacy, which the DA was never asked to consider.

¶ 45–46

On the record, including the counter-affidavit, the material existed and was rationally applied, and no mala fides or abdication of statutory function was shown.

¶ 47–48

The CG acts as custodian of public interest, balancing domestic producers against downstream users and consumers.

¶ 49

05Holding

Issue 1 is answered in the negative: Rule 4(1)(d), Rule 17 and Rule 18(1), read with s. 9A, are neither ultra vires Article 9.1 of the 1994 Agreement nor violative of Article 14.

¶ 23

On Issue 2, the CG's second-stage exercise is legislative or quasi-legislative, and it requires neither a redetermination of the DA's findings nor a further oral hearing.

¶ 35

On Issue 3, the CG may depart from a positive DA recommendation on public-interest grounds, provided the discretion rests on relevant material with a rational nexus to the conclusion and is free of mala fides; the CG's decision here met that standard.

¶ 40, 48–50

The court expressly declined to rest its decision on the existence of an alternative appellate remedy under s. 9C, given the pending question of its amendment. The petition was dismissed. Connected petitions W.P.(C) 16640/2022, 16647/2022 and 17186/2022 were delinked because they concern products other than Polystyrene, and were directed to be listed before the Roster Bench on 08.01.2027 along with W.P.(C) 9754/2026.

¶ 34 · ¶ 50–51 · ¶ 52–53
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Supreme Petrochem Ltd.vsUnion Of India And Anr.

Delhi High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment