01Facts
On 24.09.2011, Amarjeet Singh Chadha was driving his Alto car near Railway Hospital, SPM Marg, with PW-1 Mohit. A man in police uniform, later identified as the appellant Ajay Kumar Tomar, entered the car, snatched gold chains from the deceased, and fired three shots at him. The deceased died at Tirath Ram Hospital.
¶ 60, 67The appellant fled towards Pul Mithai, where HC Surender Tyagi (PW-8), riding pillion on the motorcycle of Harender Singh @ Sunny, pursued him. The appellant fired at the pursuers and struck Sunny in the neck. Sunny later died at St. Stephen's Hospital on 26.09.2011.
¶ 62, 64, 107, 118The appellant then jumped from the bridge, was apprehended with two pistols, three broken gold chains and three lockets, and a police shirt was recovered.
¶ 62, 70Further recoveries and forensic evidence followed: fingerprints from the Alto car matched the appellant; ballistic reports linked the cartridges to the recovered pistols; and the robbed articles were identified by PW-31 in a TIP.
¶ 68, 94, 95, 100, 119Charges under Sections 302/392/397 IPC and 25/27 Arms Act were framed.
¶ 22The Trial Court (judgment dated 24.12.2021; sentence dated 13.05.2022) convicted the appellant under Sections 302 and 397 IPC (Amarjeet), Section 302 IPC (Sunny), and Sections 25/27 Arms Act, and imposed life imprisonment on both murder counts, with RI of 10 years under Section 397 IPC, and Arms Act sentences.
¶ 26-27The appellant challenged the conviction (CRL.A. 362/2022). The victim's son (CRL.A. 321/2022) and the State (CRL.A. 651/2022) sought enhancement to death or, alternatively, life imprisonment for the remainder of natural life.
¶ 2, 51, 57-5802Issues
i.1. Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant shot and killed Amarjeet Singh Chadha, in light of the ocular testimony of PW-1 and the alleged contradictions and investigative lapses.
¶ 76-104ii.2. Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant's gunshot injured Harender Singh @ Sunny and that his act constituted murder under Section 302 IPC.
¶ 105-122iii.3. Whether the sentence of life imprisonment imposed by the Trial Court should be enhanced to death, or to imprisonment for the remainder of natural life, on the ground that the case is the "rarest of the rare".
¶ 123-13003Law Applied
The court applied Sections 302, 397 and 300 IPC (murder, robbery with deadly weapon, and the intention-based murder standard) and Sections 25 and 27 of the Arms Act, 1959 (unlicensed possession and use of firearms).
¶ 122, 131A dying declaration, if voluntary, truthful and reliable, may found conviction without independent corroboration, though it must be carefully scrutinised.
¶ 92-93A related or friendly witness is not unreliable merely because of relationship, per Baban Shankar Daphal v. State of Maharashtra.
¶ 111Discrepancies not going to the root of the matter should not be given undue importance, per Bharwada Bhoginbhai Hirjibhai v. State of Gujarat.
¶ 114A faulty investigation cannot benefit the accused, per Dhrub Singh v. State of Bihar.
¶ 102On sentencing, the court applied the "life imprisonment is the rule, death the exception" principle and the "rarest of the rare" test from Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab.
¶ 126The aggravating and mitigating framework from Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab was applied to the sentencing question.
¶ 126The cumulative-balancing and reformation principles from Ramnaresh v. State of Chhattisgarh and Madan v. State of U.P. were applied.
¶ 127Death cannot be imposed unless reformation is effectively ruled out, per Sundar v. State.
¶ 127Provisions in the judgment · 29 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 19 provisions
Section 34Section 170Section 171Section 186Section 300Section 302Section 307Section 353Section 379Section 391Section 392Section 394Section 397Section 398Section 411Section 419Section 420Section 468Section 471Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 43Section 161Section 164Section 313Section 354Section 372
Arms Act, 1959 Section 25Section 27Section 54Section 59
04Reasoning
PW-1's testimony was held substantially trustworthy despite omissions under Section 161 CrPC, since the discrepancies related to peripheral details and not the core act of the appellant firing at the deceased.
¶ 81-82The fact that the rehri was not seized and the employment of PW-1 was not documented did not render him a planted witness.
¶ 83, 86Corroboration came from the MLC naming PW-1 as the person who brought the victim, the contemporaneous evidence of PW-8, PW-9 and PW-18, blood on PW-1's clothes, the three gunshot wounds recorded in the post-mortem, the Alto car's spent cartridges and fingerprints, and the ballistic match of cartridges with the recovered pistols.
¶ 87, 90, 91, 94, 95, 99The deceased's oral statements, made in PW-1's presence and conveyed to PW-31, were treated as a dying declaration.
¶ 92-93The robbery motive was established by the recovery of the chains and their TIP identification, and the absence of proof about why other valuables were not taken did not defeat the proof of the act.
¶ 100-101For Sunny, PW-8, who was in active pursuit on the same motorcycle, and PW-22, a friend who saw the shooting, were found reliable on the material aspect of the firing, and their accounts were corroborated by PW-43, the MLC, post-mortem, and the ballistic evidence.
¶ 107-111, 116-119, 121Non-examination of another eyewitness (Ajay) did not create reasonable doubt, and the absence of prior enmity or premeditation did not negate intention. Firing at a pursuer's neck supplied the requisite mens rea under Section 300 IPC.
¶ 115, 120The court accepted that the appellant's status as a police officer and the commission of two murders were significant aggravating factors.
¶ 124The court found no exceptional brutality, depravity, or evidence that reformation was effectively ruled out, so the case did not meet the "rarest of the rare" threshold.
¶ 127-12805Holding
The prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant murdered Amarjeet Singh Chadha, committing robbery with firearms, and intentionally caused Sunny's fatal neck injury under Section 302 IPC, and possessed and used firearms under Sections 25/27 of the Arms Act.
¶ 104, 122, 131The case was held not to be the "rarest of the rare", and the enhancement sought by the State and the victim was rejected.
¶ 129-130The conviction was upheld and CRL.A. 362/2022 (appellant) was dismissed. Consequently, CRL.A. 321/2022 (victim) and CRL.A. 651/2022 (State) were dismissed, and the Trial Court's sentences were maintained. The Trial Court and the Jail Superintendent were directed to be informed of the judgment.
¶ 130, 132-134Original Court PDF
Harvinder Singh @ Vimpy ChaddhavsThe State Of Nct Of Delhi & Anr.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
