01Facts
The petitioner, an immediate neighbour of Respondent No. 1, alleges that H. No. 96 and H. No. 125/3, Village Karkardooma (the "subject premises"), though residential, are used for commercial groundwater extraction through unauthorised borewells, purification, storage and sale, and that the Delhi Jal Board (DJB) supply line has been illegally tapped.
¶ 2The petitioner complained by email on 30.04.2026 to Respondents 2–9, seeking a joint inspection, sealing of borewells and machinery, disconnection of illegal connections, and action against the activities.
¶ 3The petitioner sent reminders on 07.05.2026 and 04.06.2026 and lodged an online grievance on the CM Jan Sunwai portal on 30.06.2026.
¶ 4The Court issued notice on 27.07.2026.
¶ 7The petitioner relied on photographs dated 05.08.2026 to 09.08.2026 and alleged that DJB officials could not complete an inspection due to resistance at the site.
¶ 8Respondent No. 1 contends that the petition is an abuse of process, filed to pressure him in pending disputes (CS(OS) 203/2026, cross-FIRs, W.P.(C) 6620/2026, CONT.CAS(C) 1225/2026).
¶ 10Respondent No. 1 states that H. No. 125/3 does not belong to him, that H. No. 96 is used only for storage, and that his water-cooling business operates from H. No. 14, Karkardoma Village, under a valid MCD licence and commercial DJB connections.
¶ 11Respondent No. 3 (MCD) filed a status report stating that its field staff inspected both properties, found no commercial activity, and that no Health Trade Licence had been issued for them.
¶ 12DJB (Respondents 4–5) stated that it could not fully verify the position owing to resistance, sought a joint inspection from the District Magistrate (East) on 30.07.2026, and reported minor violations at a meeting on the same date.
¶ 1302Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner's grievance of administrative inaction survives once the authorities have inspected the premises and filed reports.
¶ 15ii.2. Whether the writ court can determine the existence of unauthorised commercial activity, borewells or illegal connections on conflicting affidavits and photographs.
¶ 18iii.3. Whether any further directions (sealing, disconnection, or prosecution) are warranted in the absence of an established violation.
¶ 16–17, 1903Law Applied
The grievance of inaction in a mandamus petition is rendered infructuous once the competent authorities have inspected and placed reports on record.
¶ 15A writ court exercising writ jurisdiction does not assume the role of an inspecting authority and does not decide disputed factual questions on rival affidavits and photographs.
¶ 18Where a violation is later found, the concerned authority must act in accordance with law after due notice to the person affected.
¶ 19If violations recur, the complainant may make a fresh representation, which must be decided by a reasoned order after hearing the affected party.
¶ 2004Reasoning
The Court first found that the petitioner's core grievance, inaction on his complaints, no longer survived, because MCD and DJB had inspected the premises and filed reports.
¶ 15On the merits, the Court weighed the MCD report, which recorded no commercial activity and no Health Trade Licence, against the minutes of the 30.07.2026 meeting, which recorded no borewell at the site and a valid commercial DJB connection.
¶ 16, citing para. 12DJB's admission that verification was incomplete due to resistance, and its undertaking to act after a joint inspection, were noted.
¶ 16Because these materials conflicted and the petitioner's allegations rested on photographs and rival affidavits, the Court held that it could not resolve the factual dispute in writ jurisdiction.
¶ 18The Court therefore declined further directions and instead required the authorities to act in accordance with law if any violation is later found, with due notice to the affected party.
¶ 17, 19The Court preserved the petitioner's right to renew his complaint through a reasoned, post-hearing decision if violations recur. The surrounding litigation between the parties was noted, and the Court expressly left it untouched.
¶ 20–2105Holding
The petitioner's grievance of inaction is infructuous because inspections were conducted and reports filed. The disputed question of unauthorised commercial activity cannot be decided in writ jurisdiction on rival affidavits and photographs. No further directions were warranted at this stage.
¶ 15 · ¶ 18 · ¶ 17The Court directed that the concerned authorities act in accordance with law, after due notice, if any unauthorised commercial activity, borewell, illegal connection or other violation is later found. The petitioner may make a fresh representation if violations recur, to be decided by a reasoned order after hearing Respondent No. 1. The petition, with pending applications, was disposed of in these terms, and no opinion was expressed on the merits.
¶ 19 · ¶ 20 · ¶ 22 · ¶ 21Original Court PDF
Dharamveer SinghvsRajeev & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
