01Facts
The petitioner is the complainant in FIR No. 251/2020 (PS North Rohini), registered on 09.05.2020 under Sections 188, 323, 341, 379, 506 and 34 IPC, arising from an incident dated 08.05.2020 in which the accused allegedly obstructed and assaulted him and took his gold chain, purse, cash and documents.
¶ 3.1–3.2The petitioner was previously engaged to the accused, and the engagement broke off.
¶ 3.3The dispute concerns the accused's date of birth. Documents from 2020–2021 (an Arya Samaj Mandir marriage record, a custody warrant recording age as 20, a marriage deed dated 11.02.2021, and a marriage certificate dated 08.03.2021) record 01.11.1999.
¶ 3.5, 3.7–3.8No juvenility plea was raised on 19.10.2020.
¶ 3.6In September 2021 the accused claimed juvenility on the basis of a school leaving certificate from Government Co-Ed Sr. Sec. School, Dwarka, recording 01.11.2003.
¶ 3.9The Magistrate declared her a child in conflict with law (CCL) on 01.09.2021.
¶ 3.10On the petitioner's challenge, the ASJ set that order aside on 08.06.2022 and remanded for a fresh age inquiry.
¶ 3.11On remand, the Magistrate, relying on the Investigating Officer's (IO) report that the DOB was verified from two schools, again declared the accused a CCL by the impugned order dated 27.09.2022.
¶ 3.12, 8The petitioner earlier filed Criminal Revision No. 64/2023, which he withdrew on 24.04.2024 with liberty to approach the proper forum.
¶ 5During the pendency of the petition, the IO obtained records from three schools, each confirming 01.11.2003, and the APP placed them on record.
¶ 12–16The petitioner could point to no deficiency in those records.
¶ 17In CRL.REV.P. 1016/2024, the petitioner challenges the Sessions Court judgment dated 08.05.2024 in CA No. 22/2023 and the JJB order dated 20.12.2022 terminating proceedings.
¶ 3202Issues
i.1. Whether a Metropolitan Magistrate, rather than the Juvenile Justice Board, has jurisdiction under the JJ Act, 2015 to determine a claim of juvenility.
¶ 4.3, 26ii.2. Whether the accused's age was validly determined as 01.11.2003 under Section 94(2)(i) of the JJ Act, 2015, on the school records, without examining the school authors or permitting cross-examination.
¶ 4.1–4.2, 18–21, 28iii.3. Whether the 2020–2021 documents recording DOB as 01.11.1999 warrant interference with the impugned order under Section 102 of the JJ Act.
¶ 24–25, 27iv.4. Whether the order in CRL.REV.P. 1016/2024 survives if CRL.REV.P. 1011/2024 fails.
¶ 33–3403Law Applied
Section 94 of the JJ Act, 2015 governs age determination. Where a Board has reasonable doubt, it must first seek the school date-of-birth certificate or the matriculation certificate, then a birth certificate from a municipal authority or panchayat, and resort to ossification or medical tests only if those are unavailable.
¶ 19–20Section 9(2) of the JJ Act permits any court other than the Board, on a claim of juvenility, to conduct an inquiry, take evidence (not affidavits), and record a finding on age, and Section 8(1) exclusive Board jurisdiction is expressly subject to the Act's other provisions.
¶ 26Revisional power under Section 102 of the JJ Act is limited to illegality, perversity or material irregularity.
¶ 27Following Rekha Murarka v. State of West Bengal, (2020) 2 SCC 474, a complainant has no vested right to cross-examine school principals or record-keepers where the prosecution does not dispute their records.
¶ 28Updesh Kumar v. Prithvi Singh, (2001) 2 SCC 524, and State of Punjab v. Mohinder Singh, (2005) 3 SCC 702, which the petitioner relied on for the requirement of proving school records by their authors, were distinguished because the petitioner offered no substantiation that the records were fabricated.
¶ 4.1, 23The APP's submissions on Sections 225, 301(2) and 24(8) CrPC, concerning the role of the Public Prosecutor and private counsel, were recorded but not made the basis of the decision.
¶ 6.3Provisions in the judgment · 15 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015. Section 102Section 94Section 8Section 9Section 14Section 36
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 188Section 323Section 341Section 379Section 506Section 34
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 225Section 301Section 24
04Reasoning
On jurisdiction, the court held that Section 9(2) expressly empowers a Magistrate to inquire into juvenility, so the Section 8(1) objection was untenable.
¶ 26On age, the IO's verification was based on certificates from the principals of the schools, and the school admission and withdrawal registers, the 2010 affidavit of the accused's mother and the 2011 affidavit of her father all consistently record 01.11.2003.
¶ 8, 14–16, 20–22These records date from 2010, 2011 and 2015, long before the 2020 dispute, and the petitioner did not show any deficiency in them.
¶ 17, 18, 21The claim that the records were fabricated was held to be a bare allegation without support.
¶ 23The 2020–2021 documents recording 1999 were treated as matters for the petitioner to prove in the separate criminal proceedings in FIR No. 626/2021, not as grounds to disturb the age finding in this revision.
¶ 24–25On the demand to cross-examine the principals, the court found that the prosecution accepted the school documents and did not challenge them, so no cross-examination was required, and the accused's claim was held to have been properly considered on notice, since the petitioner was not served at his last address.
¶ 28–29The court found no illegality or perversity to justify interference under Section 102.
¶ 27, 30Because CRL.REV.P. 1011/2024 failed, the relief sought in CRL.REV.P. 1016/2024 did not survive.
¶ 3305Holding
A Magistrate may determine a claim of juvenility under Section 9(2) of the JJ Act, 2015, and the accused's DOB of 01.11.2003 was validly established under Section 94(2)(i) on consistent school records that the petitioner failed to impeach.
¶ 26, 20–21, 27The court found no ground for interference under Section 102.
¶ 30CRL.REV.P. 1011/2024 is dismissed, leaving the impugned order dated 27.09.2022 intact.
¶ 31The petitioner may pursue the 1999 DOB documents in FIR No. 626/2021.
¶ 25CRL.REV.P. 1016/2024 is dismissed as not surviving.
¶ 33–34Original Court PDF
Vivek Kumar GautamvsState Of Nct Of Delhi
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
