01Facts
The Petitioner, a CISF member, was posted at CISF units at BCCL Dhanbad, SSTPS Shaktinagar, CGBS New Delhi, and IGI Airport.
He was not provided Government accommodation for the periods 10.04.2018 to October 2022, 09.10.2022 to April 2025, 26.04.2025 to March 2026, and 18.03.2026 until sanction of full HRA.
¶ 8, 11Only 25% HRA had been disbursed, with the balance 5% withheld.
¶ 10The writ petition under Article 226 sought full HRA for these periods and for future postings, along with TA and DA on transfer.
¶ 3The Court noted the pleadings contained no particulars on TA/DA.
¶ 6The Petitioner restricted the relief to HRA, with liberty to pursue TA/DA separately.
¶ 7Respondents did not dispute the non-provision of accommodation or the 25% disbursement.
¶ 1002Issues
i.1. Whether a CISF member, denied Government accommodation, is entitled to full (100%) HRA in lieu thereof, such that the withholding of 5% HRA is impermissible.
¶ 8, 11, 15ii.2. Whether the denial or reduction of HRA can be justified by reference to the member's posting station or seniority/percentage-based allotment of accommodation under Rule 61 of the CISF Rules, 2001.
¶ 8, 11–13iii.3. Whether the Petitioner's claims for TA and DA can be adjudicated in this writ petition on the existing pleadings.
¶ 6–7, 1603Law Applied
Rule 61 of the Central Industrial Security Force Rules, 2001, requires accommodation to be provided to supervisory officers in a 45:55 married/unmarried ratio, with HRA payable in lieu where accommodation is unavailable, as applicable to other Central Government employees.
¶ 8, 12As construed in Inspector/Exe. Jaspal Singh Mann v. Union of India, 2008 SCC OnLine Del 649, HRA is not a concession but a component of salary and a compensatory allowance for the absence of accommodation; posting or transfer cannot ground discrimination in its grant; and seniority-based allocation of accommodation cannot deprive a member of HRA, failing which Rule 61 would violate Article 14 and must be read down.
¶ 8, 12–13The Division Bench decisions in Shaikh Abdul Khalik (2019 SCC OnLine Del 7525), Brijesh Kumar (W.P.(C) 4839/2019, decided 18.12.2019), and Anand Kumar (W.P.(C) 6720/2016, decided 30.08.2017) hold that full HRA must be paid where accommodation is not provided.
¶ 9, 14Jaspal Singh Mann was upheld by the Supreme Court (C.A. No. 1132/2009), Brijesh Kumar was upheld in Union of India v. Paramisivan M. (C.A. No. 4967/2023), and the review in Paramisivan M. was dismissed.
¶ 14Ashish Sharma v. Union of India (W.P.(C) 8154/2024, decided 21.05.2026) directed full HRA without reduction, and the DoE Office Memorandum dated 07.07.2017 fixes HRA percentages.
¶ 1404Reasoning
The Court found the Petitioner's case squarely governed by Jaspal Singh Mann and its subsequent followings.
¶ 11The Respondents' non-provision of accommodation for the relevant periods was undisputed, so the Petitioner, under the settled interpretation of Rule 61, was entitled to full HRA irrespective of his postings or seniority.
¶ 9, 10, 11, 14The 5% withholding therefore had no legal basis and was held "untenable in law".
¶ 15As to TA and DA, the Court declined to adjudicate because the pleadings contained no particulars, and the Petitioner, on instructions, confined the petition to HRA.
¶ 6–7The Court therefore granted liberty to pursue those claims in appropriate proceedings.
¶ 1605Holding
The Petitioner is entitled to full HRA for the periods from 10.04.2018 to October 2022, 09.10.2022 to April 2025, 26.04.2025 to March 2026, and 18.03.2026 until sanction of full HRA, and reduction of HRA by 5% is untenable in law.
¶ 15The Respondents were directed to release the balance HRA within three months, failing which the Petitioner is entitled to simple interest at 6% p.a. until actual payment.
¶ 15Liberty was granted to agitate the TA and DA claims separately, and the writ petition was disposed of accordingly.
¶ 16, 17Original Court PDF
Pradip Kumar SinghvsUnion Of India And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
