01Facts
The Petitioner, a member of the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF), was posted at the CISF Unit, Vadodara Airport, from 29.05.2022 to 20.05.2023, and at the CISF Unit, IGI Airport, New Delhi, from 20.05.2023 to 12.08.2025.
pp. 3–4 / para. 9Government accommodation was not provided to the Petitioner for either period.
p. 3 / para. 6, 8The Respondents disbursed only 25% of House Rent Allowance (HRA), reducing the admissible amount by 5%.
p. 3 / para. 8The Petitioner filed this writ petition under Article 226 seeking full HRA for both periods and for future postings, along with Travelling Allowance (TA) and Daily Allowance (DA).
pp. 1–2 / para. 3At the hearing, the Petitioner gave up the TA/DA relief with liberty to pursue it separately.
p. 2 / para. 6The Respondents' counsel did not dispute the non-allotment of accommodation or the 25% disbursement of HRA.
p. 3 / para. 802Issues
i.1. Whether a CISF member, denied Government accommodation, is entitled to full (100%) House Rent Allowance in lieu thereof, or may lawfully be paid a reduced HRA on the basis of the station of posting or seniority-based allotment under Rule 61 of the CISF Rules, 2001.
pp. 2–3 / para. 6 · p. 4 / para. 9ii.2. Whether the 5% reduction in HRA is sustainable in law in view of Jaspal Singh Mann and subsequent Division Bench decisions.
pp. 8–9 / para. 12–1303Law Applied
Rule 61 of the CISF Rules, 2001 requires accommodation to be provided to supervisory officers in a 45:55 married-to-unmarried ratio, subject to Government amendment. Under Rule 61(2), accommodation is rent-free, and where it is unavailable, HRA in lieu applies as for other Central Government employees.
pp. 4–5 / para. 10In Inspector/Exe. Jaspal Singh Mann v. Union of India (2008 SCC OnLine Del 649) (DB), HRA was held to be a compensatory component of salary and a condition of service, not a concession.
p. 2 / para. 6 · p. 4 / para. 10In Jaspal Singh Mann, posting was held to be an incident of service, so entitlement to HRA cannot vary by station; seniority-based percentage distribution of accommodation cannot defeat HRA; circulars cannot override the statutory Rule 61(2); and any contrary reading would violate Article 14. Rule 61 was read down to preserve its validity.
pp. 6–8 / para. 11 · p. 8 / para. 11The Court relied on Shaikh Abdul Khalik (2019 SCC OnLine Del 7525), Brijesh Kumar (W.P.(C) 4839/2019), Anand Kumar (W.P.(C) 6720/2016), and Ashish Sharma (W.P.(C) 8154/2024, decided 21.05.2026).
pp. 2–3 / para. 7 · pp. 8–9 / para. 12Jaspal Singh Mann was upheld in Civil Appeal No. 1132/2009, and Brijesh Kumar was upheld in Union of India v. Paramisivan M. (CA No. 4967/2023), with review dismissed.
p. 9 / para. 12The Department of Expenditure Office Memorandum dated 07.07.2017, fixing HRA percentages, was noted.
p. 9 / para. 1204Reasoning
Because non-allotment of accommodation was undisputed, the Petitioner fell within the category of members entitled to HRA in lieu under Rule 61(2). The case was found to be "squarely covered" by Jaspal Singh Mann and the subsequent consistent line of authority. Under that line, once accommodation is not provided, full HRA must follow, without any correlation to place of posting or seniority-based allotment. The Respondents' 5% reduction therefore had no statutory basis.
p. 4 / para. 9 · pp. 2–3 / para. 7 · p. 9 / para. 12The Court relied on the affirmance of the governing principle by the Supreme Court and on the Ashish Sharma decision, which directed full HRA without reduction. The reduction was thus held "untenable in law". The Court did not separately analyse future postings, and no independent reasoning on that aspect appears in the judgment.
pp. 9 / para. 12–13 · pp. 1–2 / para. 3 · p. 9 / para. 1305Holding
The Petitioner is entitled to full HRA for 29.05.2022 to 20.05.2023 and 20.05.2023 to 12.08.2025, and the 5% reduction is untenable in law.
p. 9 / para. 13The Respondents were directed to release the balance HRA within three months, failing which simple interest at 6% per annum would accrue until actual payment. The writ petition was disposed of, with liberty to pursue TA and DA claims through appropriate proceedings. The relief for future postings was not expressly granted in the operative directions.
p. 9 / para. 13 · pp. 9–10 / para. 14 · p. 9 / para. 13Original Court PDF
SandeepvsUnion Of India And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
