Delhi High CourtCriminal Procedure and EvidenceCriminal Law

Delhi HC Upholds Prosecution Complaint Against Woman Over Allegedly Fake Medical Certificate Used To Revive Dismissed Case

Anshuv.Nitin Kumar

Delhi HC Upholds Prosecution Complaint Against Woman Over Allegedly Fake Medical Certificate Used To Revive Dismissed Case. Anshu vs Nitin Kumar. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the PDSJ validly formed the opinion that it was expedient in the interest of justice to make a complaint, given that the appellant derived no benefit from the certificate.

The court held

The PDSJ's expediency finding is upheld, as the certificate bears directly on the administration of justice and was used to obtain restoration of the complaint, and the custodia legis bar under Clause (b)(ii) does not apply to fabrication of evidence under Clause (b)(i).

It also directed

The court clarified that all observations in the impugned order are prima facie views for the limited purpose of the complaint decision and are not findings that the certificate is forged or that the appellant acted dishonestly.

The Magistrate must decide the genuineness of the certificate and the appellant's knowledge and intention solely on the trial evidence, uninfluenced by those observations.

The appeal is dismissed; the PDSJ's direction to make a complaint under Section 215 BNSS read with Sections 192–193 IPC (Section 195(1)(b)(i) CrPC) for filing a fake medical certificate stands upheld. A copy of the order is to be sent to the PDSJ, North-East District, for information.

01Facts

The appellant's complaint under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 was dismissed for non-prosecution on 09.10.2024.

¶ 3

In an appeal against that dismissal (CA No. 61/2025), the appellant filed a medical certificate dated 09.10.2024.

¶ 4 · ¶ 26

On the respondent's objection, the Principal District & Sessions Judge (PDSJ), North-East District, Karkardooma, passed an order on 18.10.2025.

¶ 5

The SHO reported that the certificate-issuing clinic had closed, had functioned only in 2019-20, and that the named doctor, Dr. Shahin, was never associated with it and issued no certificate.

¶ 6

On 23.12.2025 the PDSJ recorded that the certificate was prima facie fake, and the appellant withdrew her appeal.

¶ 7

By the impugned order dated 17.03.2026, passed after considering the appellant's reply and hearing both sides, the PDSJ directed that a complaint be made against the appellant for filing a fake medical certificate.

¶ 2 · ¶ 8

The appellant challenged that order in this appeal.

¶ 1

02Issues

i.1. Whether the PDSJ validly formed the opinion that it was expedient in the interest of justice to make a complaint, given that the appellant derived no benefit from the certificate.

¶ 9(i) · ¶ 12–13 · ¶ 17–18

ii.2. Whether the complaint procedure applicable to court-initiated complaints (Section 343(1) CrPC / Section 382(1) BNSS) precludes or affects the making of the complaint.

¶ 9(ii) · ¶ 19–20

iii.3. Whether the impugned order's observations amount to conclusions on guilt that foreclose the trial.

¶ 9(iii) · ¶ 21–23

iv.4. Whether the custodia legis limitation in Iqbal Singh Marwah bars a court complaint, since the certificate was not in court custody when the alleged offence was committed.

¶ 9(iv) · ¶ 24–26

03Law Applied

The procedure is governed by Section 379 of the BNSS because the certificate was filed and prosecution sought after 01.07.2024.

¶ 11

A court is not bound to make a complaint merely because an offence appears to have been committed; it must form an opinion that doing so is expedient in the interest of justice, judged by the effect of the offence on the administration of justice rather than the magnitude of injury to an individual, and a victim must not be left remediless.

¶ 12, citing Iqbal Singh Marwah v. Meenakshi Marwah (2005) 4 SCC 370 · ¶ 23

Under Section 343(1) CrPC (now Section 382(1) BNSS), a Magistrate tries a court-initiated complaint as far as may be as if instituted on a police report; this governs trial procedure only and does not invalidate the complaint.

¶ 19–20

At the complaint stage, the court forms only a prima facie opinion and does not decide guilt.

¶ 21

Iqbal Singh Marwah holds that the custodia legis bar in Section 195(1)(b)(ii) CrPC applies only to forgery committed after the document is produced in court, and it contrasts this with Section 195(1)(b)(i), which covers offences such as fabricating false evidence that have a direct correlation with court proceedings.

¶ 24, citing Iqbal Singh Marwah · ¶ 10

Fabricating false evidence under Sections 192 and 193 IPC (corresponding to Sections 228 and 229 BNS) falls under Clause (b)(i), which is now Section 215(1)(b) BNSS.

¶ 25

04Reasoning

The PDSJ's expediency finding rests on the certificate being filed by the appellant herself as the sole explanation for her default in the appeal, and on its genuineness being tested by court-directed verification rather than on the respondent's plea alone.

¶ 13

The SHO's findings that the clinic was defunct and the doctor never issued the certificate were uncontroverted, and the appellant was heard.

¶ 14–16

Because the document bears directly on the administration of justice, and it was used to obtain restoration of the complaint, the court found that the interest of justice required a complaint.

¶ 17–18

The appellant's argument that she gained nothing was rejected because the certificate was tendered for restoration and the appeal was withdrawn only after it was found prima facie fake.

¶ 18

The Section 343/382 BNSS argument concerns only how the Magistrate tries the case, so it does not undermine the decision to complain.

¶ 20

The court treated the impugned observations as prima facie views confined to the complaint decision, not findings of forgery or dishonest use.

¶ 21–22

The custodia legis argument failed because the alleged offence was fabricating evidence under Clause (b)(i), used in a pending proceeding to explain default, so it directly affects the administration of justice and falls outside the Clause (b)(ii) limitation.

¶ 25–26

05Holding

The PDSJ's expediency finding is upheld, as the certificate bears directly on the administration of justice and was used to obtain restoration of the complaint, and the custodia legis bar under Clause (b)(ii) does not apply to fabrication of evidence under Clause (b)(i).

¶ 17–18 · ¶ 25–26

The court clarified that all observations in the impugned order are prima facie views for the limited purpose of the complaint decision and are not findings that the certificate is forged or that the appellant acted dishonestly.

¶ 22

The Magistrate must decide the genuineness of the certificate and the appellant's knowledge and intention solely on the trial evidence, uninfluenced by those observations.

¶ 23

The appeal is dismissed; the PDSJ's direction to make a complaint under Section 215 BNSS read with Sections 192–193 IPC (Section 195(1)(b)(i) CrPC) for filing a fake medical certificate stands upheld. A copy of the order is to be sent to the PDSJ, North-East District, for information.

¶ 25–28
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

AnshuvsNitin Kumar

Delhi High Court · November 03, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment