01Facts
The Respondent (Hindu) married the Appellant on 15.07.2024 at Chandigarh, after a Roka ceremony on 21.04.2024
¶ 4The Appellant was presented on Shaadi.com as "Komal Gupta, daughter of Sh. Manoj Gupta"
¶ 2The Respondent alleged that her real name is Yasmeen, that she is the daughter of Mohd. Shahid @ Sayeed @ Saheed, and that she is a Muslim who demanded he convert to Islam. He alleged she left on 18.08.2024
¶ 2, 6The Appellant's case is that she is a Hindu, the biological daughter of Sh. Manoj Kumar Gupta, and that the "Yasmeen" entries arose from an error made by her mother at school admission. She relied on a paternity report dated 24.11.2025
¶ 3, 10, 23The Respondent sued in Chandigarh for a declaration of nullity under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (HMA). The Appellant did not appear, and the suit proceeded ex parte. The Supreme Court transferred the suit to the Family Court, Karkardooma, as CS No. 18/2026
¶ 8–9The Appellant filed a Written Statement denying that she is a Muslim or named Yasmeen
¶ 10She also filed CS No. 308/2026 seeking correction of her Aadhaar and educational records
¶ 11The Respondent then moved under Order XII Rule 6 CPC on the Appellant's admitted documents: Aadhaar, CBSE X and XII certificates, bank statements and employment letter, all bearing the name "Yasmeen"
¶ 12–14The Family Court allowed the application on 16.09.2026 and declared the marriage void ab initio
¶ 1502Issues
i.1. Whether the Family Court was justified in passing a decree under Order XII Rule 6 CPC on the basis of admissions in the pleadings and documents, without trial.
¶ 12–15, 19–20, 24ii.2. Whether the Appellant's religion and parentage, as reflected in the documentary record, rendered the marriage incapable of solemnisation under the HMA, so as to be void.
¶ 25–29iii.3. Whether the Respondent's conduct after discovery (cohabitation for a time and a reconciliation meeting) amounted to waiver, acquiescence or estoppel barring relief.
¶ 3103Law Applied
The Court relied on Order XII Rule 6 CPC, which permits a decree on admissions, and held that admissions may be inferred from pleadings and documents read as a whole.
¶ 24The Court applied Section 2 HMA, which confines the Act to Hindus, and its Explanation, under which a child is Hindu only where at least one parent is Hindu.
¶ 25–26The Court applied Section 5 HMA, which sets the conditions for a Hindu marriage, and the holding in Gullipilli Sowria Raj v. Bandaru Pavani, (2009) 1 SCC 714, that the word "may" in Section 5 is mandatory, so a marriage between two Hindus cannot be solemnised unless its conditions are met.
¶ 27–28The Court applied the principle that equitable doctrines such as waiver, estoppel and acquiescence cannot validate a marriage contrary to the mandatory requirements of the HMA.
¶ 31A paternity report not obtained under judicial direction is not conclusive proof of parentage.
¶ 23Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
The Court held that the Appellant's name and parentage were not a single stray entry. The Aadhaar, PAN, CBSE, bank and employer records were issued or maintained by independent bodies over a substantial period, and the Appellant admitted their particulars in her Written Statement and in her reply to the application.
¶ 19–20Her explanation of an erroneous school entry could not outweigh later records, particularly bank and salary credits in the name "Yasmeen" around July 2024, the month of the marriage.
¶ 20On parentage, the Court found no birth certificate or other contemporaneous official record establishing that Sh. Manoj Kumar Gupta is her father. The Shaadi.com profile is not proof of parentage.
¶ 21The Axis Bank certificate describing "Komal U/G Manoj Kumar Gupta" showed only guardianship, not biological paternity.
¶ 22The paternity report was not court-ordered and was not conclusive.
¶ 23Because the Court found no Hindu parent on the record, Section 2 was not satisfied, and the marriage fell outside Section 5.
¶ 26, 29The judgment does not identify which Section 5 condition was violated. The reasoning therefore rests on the threshold question of religious application under Section 2, not on a specific Section 5 clause.
The Court held that the Respondent's brief cohabitation and reconciliation attempts did not amount to unequivocal waiver, and that estoppel and acquiescence cannot validate a statutorily invalid marriage.
¶ 31The Court also noted that the pending correction suit did not alter the position as of the date of marriage.
¶ 3005Holding
The Court answered the first issue in favour of the Respondent: the Family Court was justified in granting a decree on the Appellant's admissions, and the Appellant's explanations were not supported by cogent material.
¶ 24, 32On the second issue, the record did not establish that either parent was Hindu, so the statutory requirements under Sections 2 and 5 HMA were not met.
¶ 26, 29On the third issue, waiver, acquiescence and equitable considerations could not validate the marriage.
¶ 31The Appeal is dismissed. The Impugned Order dated 16.09.2026 in CS No. 18/2026 and the consequential decree declaring the marriage of 15.07.2024 void ab initio are upheld.
¶ 32–33Original Court PDF
Yasmeen @ Jass Khan @ Komal GuptavsAditya Narayan Arya Garg
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
