01Facts
The appellant secured, through an auction conducted by the Uttar Pradesh Matsya Vikas Nigam Ltd., a document titled “licence for fishing” conferring rights to conduct fishing and remove fish from the Sharda Sagar Jalashya, Pilibhit, for a three-year period from 1998 to 2001, against payment of the auction consideration for each year.
¶ 10–11Although fishing was permitted for only approximately ten months in each year because fishing was prohibited during the statutory breeding season, the licence itself covered the entire three-year term.
¶ 6, 11–14The Collector, Pilibhit, held that the document was in substance a lease of immovable property and directed the appellant to pay deficit stamp duty of Rs. 15,72,525, recoverable as arrears of land revenue.
¶ 2The Chief Controlling Authority and the High Court affirmed that determination.
¶ 3–402Issues
i.Whether a document granting fishing rights in a tank or reservoir constitutes a transfer of a profit à prendre, and consequently an interest in or benefit arising out of immovable property for the purposes of stamp duty and registration.
¶ 16–18ii.Whether the document, notwithstanding its description as a “licence” and the restriction of actual fishing activity to ten months in each year, was in substance a lease or an instrument akin to a lease for a term exceeding one year and therefore compulsorily registrable and chargeable with stamp duty.
¶ 11–15, 18–20iii.Whether the decision in Farookh Ahmad v. State of Uttar Pradesh required the impugned orders to be set aside.
¶ 19–2003Law Applied
Section 3(26) of the General Clauses Act, 1897 treats benefits arising out of land as immovable property; accordingly, a right to catch and carry away fish from a specified water body is a profit à prendre and constitutes immovable property, as held in Anand Behera v. State of Orissa, (1955) 2 SCC 303.
¶ 16Under Section 17(1)(d) of the Registration Act, 1908, a lease of immovable property from year to year or for a term exceeding one year is compulsorily registrable.
¶ 7, 16–18Section 2(16) of the Stamp Act, 1899 treats a lease as including instruments granting rights to cultivate, occupy, or otherwise enjoy immovable property, and such an instrument must bear the appropriate stamp duty.
¶ 7, 16–18Relying on Bihar Eastern Gangetic Fishermen Co-operative Society Ltd. v. Sipahi Singh, (1977) 4 SCC 145, and Santosh Jayaswal v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (1995) 6 SCC 520, the Court held that fishing rights are benefits arising out of land and are therefore instruments attracting stamp duty; where the term exceeds one year, compulsory registration follows.
¶ 7, 16–18The Court also considered the regulatory provisions of Sections 3 and 6 of the U.P. Fisheries Act, 1948 and the U.P. Fisheries (Development and Control) Rules, 1954, which prohibit fishing during specified breeding seasons but do not shorten the contractual duration of the licence.
¶ 12–14Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Registration Act, 1908 Section 17
Indian Stamp Act, 1899 Section 2
General Clauses Act, 1897 Section 3
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 54
04Reasoning
The Court examined the substance and terms of the document rather than its description as a “licence.”
Clause 6 specifically granted the appellant the right to conduct fishing and remove fish from the Jalashya, which was a right to take a benefit from the land and therefore a profit à prendre.
¶ 15Applying Anand Behera, Bihar Eastern Gangetic Fishermen, and Santosh Jayaswal, the Court treated that right as immovable property for stamp and registration purposes.
¶ 16–18The fact that fishing could not be carried on during the breeding season was only a statutory regulatory suspension and did not reduce the licence’s three-year duration.
¶ 11–14Since the document operated for more than one year, it was compulsorily registrable under Section 17(1)(d) of the Registration Act and liable to stamp duty as an instrument akin to a lease.
¶ 18–19Farookh Ahmad was distinguished because, in that case, the High Court had not examined the terms and conditions of the document, whereas the authorities in the present case had considered them and recorded a categorical finding regarding its legal character.
¶ 2005Holding
The Supreme Court held that the fishing document was, in substance, an instrument akin to a lease granting a profit à prendre and a benefit arising out of immovable property.
¶ 18–19Its three-year duration made it compulsorily registrable under Section 17(1)(d) of the Registration Act, 1908, and liable to the applicable stamp duty.
¶ 18–19The orders of the Collector, the Chief Controlling Authority, and the High Court were upheld.
¶ 21–23The appeal was dismissed, and any pending applications were disposed of.
¶ 21–23Original Court PDF
Zaki Ullah KhanvsState Of U.P.And Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
